Academic Editor: Graham Pawelec
Abiotic stresses are wide-ranging environmental factors that adversely affect the yield and quality of tea plants (Camellia sinensis). As perennial woody economic plants, various environmental factors affect its growth and development. To survive under stress conditions, plants adapt to or withstand these adverse external environments by regulating their growth and morphological structure. Recently, there have been knowledges regarding the significant progress in the mechanisms of abiotic stresses (including cold and heat, drought, salt and heavy metal stresses) tolerance in tea plants. Many evidences suggest that several phytohormones are in response to various environmental stresses, and regulate plant stress adaptation. However, the regulatory mechanisms of plant abiotic stress responses and resistance remain unclear. In this review, we mainly summarize the studies on the adaptive physiological and molecular mechanisms of tea plants under abiotic stress, and discuss the direction for tea plant resistance and breeding strategies.
Tea plant (Camellia sinensis (L.) O. Kuntze), as an important economic plant, is popularly and widely cultivated in the world because of the tea leaves used for making a beverage. In tandem with the light-demanding, dampness and shade characteristics of tea plants, it generally grows in warm and humid hills, mountains and plains. As perennial evergreen woody plants, its development and growth are severely affected by various environmental factors such as extreme temperature, drought, salinity, heavy metal pollution. In addition, biotic stress such as pests and diseases are also known to affect its yield and quality [1, 2, 3]. With the rapid development of industrial modernization and the increase of human activities in recent years, unfavorable external factors around the plants become more serious and frequent in the face of environmental pollution and climate change. Hence, the study of the response mechanisms of tea plants to abiotic stresses not only to improve its stress resistance, but also increase yield and agronomic traits. In this article, we review the effects of abiotic stress on the growth and development of tea plants, and provide the references for further study on the molecular mechanisms of plant stress resistance. It also expands the relevant knowledge to develop superior stress resistance and high yield cultivar.
Extreme temperature, which has a periodic variation by season, includes high temperature, low temperature and frost. It is the most common environmental factor that affects tea plant’s growth in nature. In recent years, with the increase in human activities and exacerbation of global climate change, tea plants are often subjected to extreme high or low temperature environment. The yield and quality of tea plants was seriously affected by these adverse conditions [4, 5, 6]. When tea plants are suffered from high temperature stress, its growth and development are significantly inhibited, which mainly shows in physiological responses and metabolic abnormalities. In the natural environments, high temperature weather is often accompanied by drought. It has previously been shown that the stomatal conductance, net photosynthetic rate and transpiration rate of tea leaves are significantly lower under the combined stress of high temperature and drought than shading conditions [7].
Photosynthesis is regarded as the most important physiological and biochemical reaction in plants, which is most vulnerable to environmental stresses. Investigations on tea leaves photosynthetic system has shown that high temperature stress can inhibit the activity of enzymes that affect the electron transmission and the structure of photosystem I and II [8]. High temperature also leads to the overproduction of reactive oxygen species (ROS) in leaves and cause serious damage to tea plants. This can damage the plant leaves during growth and photosynthesis process [9]. The C. sinensis sucrose non-fermenting-related protein kinase (CsSnRK) can be induced by high temperature stress [10]. The C. sinensis transcription factor CsRAV2 is present mainly in roots and its expression can be largely induced by high temperature stress [11]. The C. sinensis heat shock protein CsHSP17.2 is located in the cytoplasm and nucleus. The shock protein has also been found to be induced by high temperature, but it is not induced by cold temperature. Heterologous expression of CsHSP17.2 can enhance the tolerance of Escherichia coli and Saccharomycetes to high temperature stress [12]. The CsHSP17.2 can also function as a molecular chaperone to improve plant stress tolerance under high temperature stress [12]. It does this by maintaining high levels of photosynthesis and protein synthesis efficiency, eliminating ROS as well as inducing the expression of high temperature stress-related genes.
Indeed, the current research on tea plants response to high temperature is insufficient as there are only a few reports on the physiological, biochemical and gene expression of the plants under high temperature stress [7, 8]. Due to its long growth cycle, tea plants are exposed to complex and ever-changing external environments during its growing process. During the summer, it is also often suffered from joint stresses of high temperature and drought. Therefore, it is difficult to get an accurate reflection of its response mechanisms to adverse stresses in the natural environments by a single experimental condition. During the study of tea plants, the functions of several stress-related genes are achieved by heterologous expression in Arabidopsis or tobacco. However, the study of molecular biology and heritage is still lagging behind in other plant models. In conclusion, for the conduction of depth-exploration of the molecular regulatory mechanisms of tea plants response to high temperature stress, further research is needed.
Low temperature stress includes cold damage (above freezing point) and freeze injury (below freezing point) [13]. Tea trees thrive in a warm and humid climate, so the low temperature environment has become one of the main factors that affect their growth and development and restrict their geographical distribution. Cold damage or freeze injury caused by low temperature environment leads to the abnormality of cell membrane structures. Moreover, this results in reduction in enzyme activity and affects normal physiological response of tea plants, causing disorder of cell metabolism and eventually inhibition of the plant’s growth [13, 14]. It has been found that the systems of enzyme protection, which includes peroxidase (POD), catalase (CAT), and superoxide dismutase (SOD) etc., are involved in the cold resistance response [15]. The activities of POD, CAT and SOD are considerably higher in strong cold-resistant tea plants and lower in weak cold-resistant tea plants [16]. Soluble protein content is also remarkably higher in strong cold-resistant tea plants than those in weak cold-resistant tea plants [16]. Consequently, the activities of POD, CAT, SOD and soluble protein content can be used as the physiological evaluation indexes to identify the cold resistance of tea plants [15]. Under low temperature, it appeared to inhibit cellular respiration, reduce consumption of carbohydrate as well as increase content of soluble sugar and irreducible water. This thus contributes to enhancing the cold hardiness of tea plants [15, 17].
With the application of molecular biology and transcriptome technology, multiple genes related to tea plants response to cold stress have been identified. The C. sinensis cold-regulated gene CsCOR1 is located in the cell wall [18]. Under low temperature or dehydration, the expression levels of CsCOR1 in tea leaves are increased significantly [18]. The C. sinensis betaine aldehyde dehydragenase gene CsBADH1 and choline monooxygenas gene CsCMO are key enzymes in the synthesis of betaine [19, 20]. It has been found that low temperature induces the expression of both the enzymes. The C. sinensis transcription factor CsRAV2 is expressed in the roots, stems, leaves and flowers of tea plants. It is also found that the expression of CsRAV2 is significantly up-regulated when tea plants are exposed to low temperature [11]. The transcription factors CsICE and CsCBF3 are related to low temperature stress of C. sinensis [21, 22]. CsICE is located in the nucleus while CsCBF3 is located in the nucleus and cell membrane and both the genes are detected in all tea organs. Low temperature can significantly induce the expression of CsICE and CsCBF3 (Fig. 1). In Arabidopsis, overexpression of CsICE and CsCBF3 can improve the tolerance of plants to low temperature [21, 22]. Further study has proved that CsCBF3 is involved in mediating the response of low temperature stress through regulation of the downstream gene-expression of AtCOR15a and AtCOR78 in the cold response pathway [22]. Zhao et al. [23] have reported that the expression of UGT91Q2 encoding a putative glucosyltransferase is strongly induced by cold stress. The glucosyltransferase UGT91Q2 specifically catalyzes and glycosylates the nerolidol. The glycosylated nerolidol exhibits significantly higher scavenging ability of ROS than dissociation state nerolidol. The down-regulation of UGT91Q2 expression reduces the accumulation of glucosides in tea plants as well as the scavenging capacity of ROS (Fig. 1). These eventually contribute to the increased tolerance of tea plants to cold stress [23].
A proposed model for UGT91Q2 and CsCBF3 involved in cold stress response.
Nerolidol, as the volatiles, which is synthesized and released from tea plants during cold stress. The expression of the glucosyltransferase UGT91Q2 is induced by cold stress. The plant cells can absorb nerolidol and convert it to the glucosylated nerolidol catalyzed by UGT91Q2. The nerolidol glucoside reduces the ROS accumulation and thus increases the cold tolerance of tea plants. The transcription factors CsICE and CsCBF3 are important cold responsive genes. The expression levels of CsICE and CsCBF3 are induced by cold stress, CsCBF3 regulates the expressions of the cold-regulated gene COR15a and COR78 and improves the cold tolerance of plants. Abbreviations: UGT91Q2, sesquiterpene UDP-glucosyltransferase; ROS, reactive oxygen species.
So far, several genes related to the tea plants response to low temperature stress is mainly conducted for the cloning of tea plant genes into other plant models such as Arabidopsis, tobacco, etc. This is done so as to observe their expression and to verify the specific function of genes when tea plants are suffering from cold damage. However, there are few reports on transgenic researches about tea plants. Also, the in-depth research of molecular regulatory mechanisms is neither adequate nor systematic.
Due to global warming and water shortage, drought stress has become one of the main limiting factors that affect tea plant production [1, 5]. Drought stress can seriously affect tea plant growth and yield, sometimes even causing death to the tea plants [24]. Some statistics have it that, in some major tea plant producing regions around the world, the losses of tea production caused by drought is about 17–33%. These stats also show that large regional differences exist as different geographical environment and tea plant varieties. For instance, the yield of tea plants tends to decrease during drought, by 17%–31% in some regions of India [25], by about 26% in some regions of Sri Lanka [26], and by about 33% in some regions of Tanzania [27]. Going on, in Yunnan, Guizhou provinces and other southern tea producing regions of China, the losses of tea production caused by drought has been found to be particularly frequent. In conclusion, due to global climate change, drought has become an important constraint for the growth and yield of tea plants.
Drought stress often leads to the morphological and physiological changes in tea plants. These changes include the accelerated senescence, yellowing of leaves, dropping of old leaves, and inhibited growth of new shoots. The abnormal growth resulted from drought stress is usually due to the imbalance of hormone metabolism, excessive accumulation of ROS, and weakening of photosynthesis in tea plants [28, 29, 30, 31]. Different degrees of drought influence tea plants in various ways. First and foremost, under low drought stress, tea leaves, with decreasing photosynthetic capacity, change from green to yellow-green. Secondly, under high drought stress, tea leaves, which are curled and wilting, turn yellow or brown and fall off. Thirdly, the extreme and severe drought environment causes the tea plants to wither and die due to an acute lack of water.
There have been a series of recent researches in which tea plants response to drought stress are mainly focused on the analyses of physiology, biochemistry and gene expression. To respond to drought stress, tea plants undergo signal transduction through signal perception, transmission and response. After that, it regulates the changes of gene expression, physiological response and morphological structure [32]. Presently, scientists have pin-pointed and identified multiple genes that participate in the response of tea plants to drought stress (Table 1, Ref. [1, 10, 18, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41]). These genes mainly contain transcription factors, with some genes related to stress resistance and metabolism [42, 43, 44]. In addition, some heat shock proteins, molecular chaperones, miRNAs, MYB protein families are believed to be related to tea plants response to drought stress [45, 46]. Wang et al. [47] have reported that the CsHis-H1 gene is involved in mediating the response of tea plants to drought stress. The heterologous expression of the nucleus-localized CsHis-H1 in tobacco can improve the tolerance to drought stress. Further researches have also reported that CsHis-H1 improves the resistance of tea plants by maintaining the photosynthetic efficiency of leaves [47].
Gene | Genbank accession | Gene type | The subcellular location | References |
CsINV10 | KT359348 | Neutral/alkaline invertase | Chloroplast | [33, 34] |
CsMDHAR | MN402504 | Monodehydroascobate reductase | [35] | |
CsGPX1 | Glutathione peroxidase | [36] | ||
CsGPX2 | JQ247186 | Glutathione peroxidase | [37] | |
CsSnRK2.1 | MG026837 | Sucrose non-fermenting-1-related protein kinase | Cytoskeleton | [10] |
CsSnRK2.2 | MF662805 | Sucrose non-fermenting-1-related protein kinase | Cytoplasm | [10] |
dr1 | BQ825883 | Drought responsive | [1] | |
dr2 | BQ825884 | Drought responsive | [1] | |
dr3 | BQ825885 | Drought responsive | [1] | |
CsCOR1 | GQ461357 | Camellia sinensis cold-regulated gene 1 | Cell wall | [18] |
CsLEA3 | Late embryogenesis abundant protein | [38] | ||
CsNAM-like protein | JQ619837 | NAC family proteins | Nucleus | [39] |
CsARF6 | Auxin response factor | Nucleus | [40] | |
CsWRKY40 | The WRKY transcription factor | [41] | ||
CsWRKY57 | The WRKY transcription factor | [41] |
Under drought stress, tea plants resist or adapt to adverse condition by activating the expression of drought-enduring genes and protein synthesis. This resistance involves multiple adaptive physiological responses in tea plants, including osmotic regulation, endo-hormone regulation, and antioxidant defense system regulation, etc. [48]. During drought, plant cells lose their water and thus give rise to cell turgor. As such, tea plants need to maintain the turgor pressure by synthesizing proline, soluble saccharide and proteins to ensure that photosynthesis and life activities are not being affected. Drought stress can also result in excessive production of ROS, oxidation and destruction of cell membrane structure, as well as impact the physiological and biochemical reactions [49]. Tea plants scavenge ROS mainly through the combination of catalase (CAT), superoxide dismutase (SOD), peroxidase (POD), etc. [50, 51]. Tea plants can also reduce the ROS-induced injury by combining antioxidant substances such as ascorbic acid, glutathione and carotenoid [51, 52].
Furthermore, hormones are also involved in the regulation of the response of tea plants to drought stress. It has previously been indicated that salicylic Acid (SA) is involved in mediating the response of tea plants to drought stress by regulating the activities of SOD and POD. Abscisic Acid (ABA) can regulate stomata divergence degree and transpiration for alleviating adverse effects of drought on tea plants [53]. Over the years, the tea plants have established physiological adaptive response to drought stress by regulating gene expression, endogenous hormone level and stomatal switch [54]. This is to enhance its ability to resist and adapt to adverse stresses.
Soil salinization is also a major limiting factor that affects the production of
tea plants [55]. Tea plants grow well in acid soil, as it directly affects its
growth development with changes in the pH value of the soil. High concentration
of salt and alkali in the soil affects the absorption of mineral ions and water
by plant roots, and then inhibits the growth of tea plants. When teat plants are
subjected to high salt, the water absorption ability of the roots is
significantly decreased. Also, excessive amounts of Na
Under the stimulation by salt and alkali, plant cells can induce the expression
of stress-inducible genes and protein synthesis through the perception,
transduction and response of environmental signals. It involves an elaborative
regulatory network to resist or adapt to adverse environmental conditions.
Recently, scientists have cloned and highlighted some genes related to the
response of tea plant to salt and alkali stress through molecular biological
technology (Table 2, Ref. [10, 11, 19, 20, 33, 34, 35, 37, 39, 40, 41, 47, 64, 66, 60, 61, 62, 63, 65, 67]). The
Na
Gene | Genbank accession | Gene type | The subcellular location | References |
CsbZIP1 | JX050148.1 | The basic leucine zipper proteins | Nucleus | [60, 61] |
CsbZIP4 | AGD98702.1 | The basic leucine zipper proteins | Nucleus | [62] |
CsbZIP7 | KC215406.1 | The basic leucine zipper proteins | Nucleus | [60] |
CsbZIP8 | KC215415.1 | The basic leucine zipper proteins | Nucleus | [60] |
CsbZIP14 | KR906062 | The basic leucine zipper proteins | Nucleus | [60] |
CsbZIP17 | KR906065 | The basic leucine zipper proteins | Nucleus | [60] |
CsbZIP18 | KR906066 | The basic leucine zipper proteins | Nucleus | [60] |
CsNHX1 | MG722977 | The Na |
Vacuolar membrane | [63] |
CsNHX2 | MG515211 | The Na |
Vacuolar membrane | [63] |
CsNHX6 | The Na |
Golgi apparatus | [64] | |
CsWRKY40 | The WRKY transcription factor | [41] | ||
CsWRKY57 | The WRKY transcription factor | [41] | ||
CsSnRK2.1 | MG026837 | Sucrose non-fermenting-1-related protein kinase | [10] | |
CsSnRK2.2 | MF662805 | Sucrose non-fermenting-1-related | [10] | |
protein kinase | ||||
CsARF1 | JX307853 | Auxin response factor | Cytoplasm | [40, 65] |
CsARF6 | Auxin response factor | Nucleus | [40] | |
CsARF16 | Auxin response factor | Nucleus | [40] | |
CsMAPK3 | MF034662 | Mitogen-activated protein kinase | Cytoplasm and nucleus | [66] |
CsGPX2 | JQ247186 | glutathione peroxidase 2 | Chloroplast | [37] |
CsNAM-like protein | JQ619837 | NAC family proteins | Nucleus | [39] |
CsERF-B3 | GU393024 | APETALA2/ethylene-responsive | [67] | |
factor | ||||
CsMDHAR | MN402504 | Monodehydroascobate reductase | [35] | |
CsINV10 | KT359348 | neutral/alkaline invertase | Chloroplast | [33, 34] |
CsCMO | JX050146 | Choline monooxygenase | Chloroplast | [20] |
CsBADH1 | JX050145 | Betaine aldehyde dehydragenase | [19] | |
CsHis-H1 | EU716314 | H1 Histone gene | Nucleus | [47] |
CsRAV2 | GQ227992.1 | CsRAV2 Transcription Factor | [11] |
The ABA-mediated signaling pathways have been shown to be the most critical
regulatory pathways in the response of plants to salt and drought stress [34, 68]. In response to high salt stress, ABA mediates stomatal closure and the
expression of stress-resistant genes, and weakens physiological activities
related to tea plant growth, and enhances the ability of plants to resist salt
stress [34, 68]. The expression of CsNHX6 is induced by ABA, implying
that CsNHX6 can possibly participate in tea plant response to salt
stress through the ABA-dependent signal pathway [64]. Li et al. [18]
have reported that exogenous application of ABA can induce the expression of
CsCOR1, and overexpression of CsCOR1 in tobacco can
significantly improve the tolerance of tea plants to salt stress. This indicates
that the expression of CsCOR1 may be activated by the ABA-dependent
signaling pathway in the process of tea plants response to salt stress [18, 69, 70]. In addition, exogenous application of SA or hydrogen sulfide (H
Due to modern industrialization, massive exploitation of minerals, large scale use of pesticides and fertilizers, and discharge of sewage, the problem of environment contamination is increasingly becoming serious. The soil, containing heavy metals, not only has a serious impact on the growth of tea plants, but also affects the yield and quality of agricultural products. Heavy metal can be taken up by plants roots and accumulated in different plant organs, which leads to adverse effects on human health through the food chain. As a result, a vast majority of the research works is conducted on the basis of the impacts of heavy metal stress on the growth and development of tea plants. It has previously been shown that heavy metal with low concentration can promote the growth of tea plants. However, heavy metal with high concentration inhibits the growth of tea plant and reduces the yield and quality of tea plants [72]. High heavy metal content also changes the pH of soil and growing circumstance of rhizosphere microorganism. It not only affects the nutrient absorption by plant roots, but also leads to excessive absorption of heavy metal, consequently inhibiting the growth and development of the plants [72, 73]. Through evolution over the years, the plants have gradually developed multiple mechanisms for tolerance and avoidance of heavy metal stress. The avoidance mechanisms mainly refer to how root exudates mediate the activity of rhizosphere microorganism and mobility of heavy metals. It also highlights changes in the cell wall structure, so as to reduce the entry of heavy metals into plants [73, 74]. The tolerance mechanisms mainly refer to the physiological regulatory mechanisms of tea plants, such as osmotic regulation, antioxidant systems and chelation, so as to reduce the damage of heavy metals to the plants [74, 75, 76, 77].
An investigation on hydrargyrum stress shows that mercury treatment can reduce
the chlorophyll content in tea leaves and affect the photosynthesis of tea
plants. It also highlights how the mercury treatment can cause a significant
decrease in the content of proline and propylene glycol in tea leaves [78]. Xia
and Lan [79] have conducted biophysical research on tea plants response to
cadmium stress and found that low cadmium (Cd) concentration had no significant
effect on the growth of tea plants. However, with increase in the Cd
concentration, the damage degree is gradually increased, mainly manifested in the
wilting, yellowing and abscission of leaves. When the Cd concentration reaches up
to 60 mg/kg, tea plants start dying. After Cd treatment, the content of
malondialdehyde and free proline in tea is increased, while the content of
chlorophyll and soluble sugar exhibits opposite trends in different seasons [79].
During spring season, Cd treatment leads to significant increases in the content
of chlorophyll and soluble sugar in leaves, but reduces the content of
chlorophyll and soluble sugar in leaves in the summer season, indicating the
temporal and spatial differences in response to Cd stress [79]. In addition, lead
(Pb) and chromium (Cr) treatment are used to study the physiological and
biochemical response of tea plants. It is observed that, when the concentration
of Pb
Tea plant, a perennial green plant, experiences multiple seasonal changes in its life cycle. Also, changes in external environments directly affect the growth development of the plant. In the natural environments, diverse stressful factors often adversely affect the performance of plant growth. With the frequent occurrence of abnormal weather and aggravation of environmental pollution, tea plant production is under huge threat by cold damage, high temperature, soil heavy metal pollution and soil salinization. In the process of tea plant growth, its development is often affected by multiple environmental factors at the same time. These stresses are important factors affecting the yield and quality of tea. As the AP2/ERF-B3 transcription factor, the expression of CsERF-B3 was induced by high temperature stress, low temperature stress and salinity stress [67]. In the plants, the transcription factor of ERF subfamily is involved in the abiotic stresses by regulating the expression of stress-related genes. This implies CsERF-B3 play an important role in abiotic stress response and tolerance in tea plants. With the development of molecular biotechnology, the application of transcriptomics and transgenic technology has become an effective way to explore the regulatory mechanisms of tea plant adaptation to abiotic stress. In the future, we expect more genes that regulate plant stress adaptation to be discovered. Searching for important genes and exploring its molecular regulatory networks of tea plants response to abiotic stress will help us better understand the regulatory mechanism of plant resistance to adverse stress.
Previous studies mainly focus on single stress treatment but little study of tea plants response to a variety of stresses has been reported. Therefore, it is of great necessity to carry out the experiments of combining multiple stresses together, including high temperature, drought, salt-alkali and heavy metal to better explore the stress-resistance physiology of plants in the natural environments. The combination process is also important for the cultivation of excellent salt-tolerant, drought-tolerant and high temperature resistant tea varieties. Moreover, most of the previous reports about the stress resistance of tea plants focuses squarely on the phenotypic observation and the determination of physiological and biochemical indexes. The researches on the molecular regulatory mechanism of teat plants response to abiotic stress is still far behind other model plants such as Arabidopsis, rice, corn and soybean. Thus, it is very important to unravel the molecular mechanisms of stress resistance in tea plants by applying the physiological, biochemical and molecular analyses, so as to improve the plant’s stress resistance ability and to increase its yield.
YS is the main author of the thesis; YS, JZ and JG participate in the writing and revision of the thesis.
Not applicable.
We thank Congsheng Yan for linguistic assistance.
This work was supported by the Open Fund Project of Key Laboratory of Tea Plant Biology and Tea Processing of Ministry of Agriculture (LTBB20140401), Stable Talent Project of Anhui Science and Technology University (XJWD201801) and Innovation and Entrepreneurship Training Program for College Students in Anhui Province (S201910879197).
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
CsSnRK, Camellia sinensis Sucrose non-fermenting-Related
protein Kinase; POD, peroxidase; CAT, catalase; SOD,
superoxide dismutase; CsBADH1, Camellia sinensis Betaine
Aldehyde Dehydragenase; CsCMO, Camellia sinensis Choline
Monooxygenas; SA, Salicylic Acid; ABA, Abscisic Acid;
H