- Academic Editor
The aim of this review is to provide an overview of different compositions, in terms of main minerals and vitamins, of milk from animal species that represent the most common source of this food for humans, highlighting the uniqueness of nutritional qualities linked to animal species. It is known that milk is an important and valuable food for human nutrition, representing an excellent source of nutrients. Indeed, it contains both macronutrients (proteins, carbohydrates, and fat) that contribute to its nutritive and biological value and micronutrients represented by minerals and vitamins, which play a relevant role in the body’s various vital functions. Although their supply is represented by small quantities, vitamins and minerals are important components for a healthy diet. Milk composition in terms of minerals and vitamins differs between various animal species. Micronutrients are important components for human health as their deficiency is causes of malnutrition. Furthermore, we report on the most significant metabolic and beneficial effects of certain micronutrients in the milk, emphasizing the importance of this food for human health and the need for some milk enrichment procedures with the most relevant micronutrients to human health.
Milk is an essential component of the human diet. The term “milk” is associated with cow’s milk since it represents 83% of world’s milk production [1]. However, milk of other animal species is also used, whose properties are arousing increasing interest, for some beneficial effects on human health [2, 3]. Human milk, according to the World Health Organization (WHO), is the first and extremely valuable food for infants up to 6 months of age. Although breast milk is strongly recommended, it is not always possible use it and therefore it is substituted with formula milk. Formula milk mimics the nutritional composition of breast milk, and cow’s milk formula is among the three major classes of infant formulas [4]. However, this substitute is not suitable for children with cow’s milk protein allergies [5], and a replacement with suitable alternatives is required, such as hydrolyzed cow’s milk protein, hydrolyzed rice or soy protein, and amino acid–based formula [6]. Nevertheless, milk provides an excellent source of all the nutrients and its nutritive value has long been recognized; indeed, it contains both macronutrients (proteins, carbohydrates, and fat) (Table 1, Ref. [7]) that contribute to its nutritional and biologic value and micronutrients represented by minerals and vitamins, which play an important role in the body’s various vital functions [8, 9, 10]. Among the bioactive molecules that have a major influence on the biological effects of milk are butyrate, conjugated linoleic acid, and omega 3 essential fatty acids. Butyrate, a short-chain fatty acid, has been known for its involvement in food allergy, inflammation, oxidative stress, and diabetes [11, 12, 13, 14]. Conjugated linoleic acids are mainly effective against inflammation, obesity and cancer [15, 16, 17], while omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids are known to reduce inflammation and oxidative stress, playing a protective role in the cardiovascular and nervous systems [18, 19, 20]. The mineral content of milk and dairy products is composed of macroelements (calcium, phosphorus, magnesium, sodium, potassium, and chloride) and numerous microelements present in trace quantities. Both are concentrated in the ash, the inorganic part of the milk nutrients, present in various forms associated with different structural components. Conversely, vitamins are biologically active substances and together with other nutrients are the organic part of the milk nutrients, consisting of lipophilic vitamins (A, D, E, and K) and hydrophilic vitamins (B-complex vitamin and vitamin C). Factors influencing the milk composition are divided in genetic factors, e.g., the breed of cow, and in environmental factors, such as type of dietary regimen, seasonal modifications and milking systems. Furthermore, the composition of milk in terms of minerals and vitamins differs between various animal species. Although they are usually taken as trace amounts, vitamins and minerals are critical components of food and healthy nutrition. The inability of the body to synthesize vitamins makes their consumption indispensable for growth and maintaining health. Compared with other foods, milk offers a cheap and valuable source of vitamins and minerals [21]. Micronutrients are important for human health; indeed, their deficiency is a cause of malnutrition, which primarily affects the health of the most vulnerable groups in the population, as kids and pregnant women, especially in poorest countries. Some important micronutrient deficiencies with adverse health effects involve vitamin A, vitamin D and calcium [22]. Consequently, it is necessary to introduce into the market, milk with minerals (in particular calcium) and vitamins (mainly vitamins A and D) [23]. In this regard, a range of strategies have been put in place for increasing the mineral and vitamin content of milk, both acting on animal nutrition [24] and on direct enrichment “fortification”. Fortification is defined as the process of incorporating micronutrients like essential vitamins into foods [25]. Milk is a good product for the process of fortification because is a staple food well accepted by the population. The aim of this review is to provide an overview on the micronutrients of milk from animal species that represent the most common source of this food for humans, highlighting the uniqueness of nutritional qualities linked to animal species. Furthermore, we report on the most relevant metabolic and beneficial effects of the major micronutrients of the milk, emphasizing the importance of this valuable food for human health. Finally, we report on the influence of raw milk processing on drinking milk micronutrients and provided an insight into some milk enrichment strategies with the most relevant micronutrients to human health.
Human | Donkey | Cow | Sheep | Goat | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
(g/L) | |||||
Proteins | 9–19 | 14–20 | 30–39 | 45–70 | 30–52 |
Fat | 21–40 | 3–18 | 33–54 | 50–90 | 30–72 |
Lactose | 63–70 | 58–74 | 44–56 | 41–59 | 32–50 |
Source adapted and modified from Claeys et al. [7], 2014.
Specific and comprehensive articles or reviews, mainly from the last decade, were considered in this narrative review, using PubMed database. The keywords used to find the right articles are the following: cow milk, donkey milk, sheep milk, goat milk, human milk, micronutrients, food-fortification, cow feeding techniques. A brief overview of the reviewed literature is reported in Table 2 (Ref. [7, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37]). Limitations: aspects of only a few major micronutrients were considered in this review. In addition, only the types of milk considered to be of greatest interest for human consumption were considered. Strengths: the work done for this review is of a multidisciplinary nature, taking into consideration different research fields and different fundamental aspects in the composition of the milk as a final product.
Authors | Title | References |
---|---|---|
Barone G, et al. Int Dairy J. 2021 | Calcium fortification of a model infant milk formula system using soluble and insoluble calcium salts | [26] |
Cobo-Angel C, et al. Animal Frontiers. 2014 | Selenium in milk and human health | [27] |
Vincenzetti S, et al. Beverages. 2020 | B-Vitamins Determination in Donkey Milk | [28] |
Vincenzetti S, et al. Nutrients. 2021 | Vitamins in Human and Donkey Milk: Functional and Nutritional Role | [29] |
Gentili A, et al. J Agric Food Chem. 2013 | Comprehensive profiling of carotenoids and fat-soluble vitamins in milk from different animal species by LC-DAD-MS/MS hyphenation | [30] |
WL Claeys, et al. Food Control. 2014 | Consumption of raw or heated milk from different species: An evaluation of the nutritional and potential health benefits | [7] |
Saeterdal, et al. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2012 | Fortification of staple foods with vitamin A for vitamin A deficiency | [31] |
Kay JK, et al. J Dairy Res. 2005 | A comparison between feeding systems (pasture and TMR) and the effect of vitamin E supplementation on plasma and milk fatty acid profiles in dairy cows | [32] |
Woźniak D, et al. Foods. 2022 | Reasonableness of Enriching Cow’s Milk with Vitamins and Minerals | [33] |
Polzonetti V, et al. Nutrients. 2020 | Dietary Intake of Vitamin D from Dairy Products Reduces the Risk of Osteoporosis | [34] |
Itkonen ST, et al. Nutrients. 2018 | Vitamin D Fortification of Fluid Milk Products and Their Contribution to Vitamin D Intake and Vitamin D Status in Observational Studies-A Review | [35] |
Niero G, et al. J Dairy Sci. 2019 | Validation of a gold standard method for iodine quantification in raw and processed milk, and its variation in different dairy species | [36] |
Perales S, et al. J Agric Food Chem. 2006 | Fortification of Milk with Calcium: Effect on Calcium Bioavailability and Interactions with Iron and Zinc | [37] |
Calcium (Ca) is the main mineral found in milk, divided into the soluble and micellar phases. In the watery phase, Ca is present in its free form combined with citrate, inorganic phosphate and whey proteins. Two thirds of Ca is bound to casein in the micellar phase, related to organic phosphate (phosphoseryl residues of casein molecules) [26]. Partitioning of this mineral between these phases is complex, highly dynamic and influenced by different factors, such as temperature, ionic strength and pH. The Ca is thermodynamically equilibrated between the water and micellar phase, in relation to the chemical condition. Biological acidification processes such as lactose fermentation, during processing of dairy products, are primarily responsible for moving Ca into the water phase [38]. Ca bioavailability in milk is high [39] and certain milk components, e.g., lactose and phosphopeptide may improve the uptake of this mineral [40]. Ca milk content is lower in human and donkey milk compared to cow’s milk, while in sheep’s and goat’s milk is present a higher concentration (Table 3, Ref. [7, 36, 41, 42, 43, 44]). Milk represents an important source of Ca to the human diet.
Human | Donkey | Cow | Sheep | Goat | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
(mg/100 g) | |||||
Ca | 28–34 | 33–115 | 112–123 | 159–242 | 130–197 |
P | 14–43 | 32–73 | 59–119 | 124–175 | 79–153 |
Mg | 3–4 | 2–8 | 7–12 | 16–25 | 14–36 |
Na | 10–18 | 10–27 | 42–58 | 30–75 | 28–59.4 |
K | 53–62 | 24–75 | 106–163 | 94–162 | 140–242 |
Fe | 0.04–0.2 | 0.04–0.26 | 0.03–0.1 | 0.08–0.1 | 0.05–0.3 |
( |
|||||
Se | 1.8 | trace | 1.7 | 1.7 | 1.1–17 |
( |
|||||
I | 144 | 7.26 | 66.82 | 243.16 | 591.06 |
Source adapted and modified from Claeys et al. [7], 2014; Niero et al. [36], 2019; Verduci et al. [41], 2019; Balthazar et al. [42], 2017; Barłowska et al. [43], 2011; Fernández-Sánchez et al. [44], 2007.
Phosphorus (P), an important component of milk and dairy products, is present in different forms of organic and inorganic phosphates and in various localizations. The organic form of P binds various molecules, mainly to casein molecules, in the micellar phase. The inorganic form of P is divided between the water and micellar phase. This mineral is transferred into the water phase mainly during acidification processes. P is mostly abundant in goat’s and sheep’s milk (Table 3) and is present in various animal foods [45]. Therefore, there is no shortage of this mineral for humans.
In contrast to Ca and P, magnesium (Mg) is not a very abundant component in milk and milk products. The effects of Mg on physiochemical stability of whey protein are similar to those for Ca. It is present in the micellar phase bound to casein proteins, while in the water phase is associated with citrate and P. Two thirds of Mg is present in the soluble part of milk [46]. This distribution, as well as Ca and P, depends on the physiochemical condition. Mg is found in higher concentrations in sheep’s and goat’s milk (Table 3). Milk and dairy products are good contributors of dietary Mg.
Sodium (Na) and potassium (K) are present mainly as free ions in the water phase
of milk and milk products and their concentrations are increased by salting [47].
These minerals contribute to the cheese’s physical-chemical properties [48], to
the micro-organism’s selection and to enzymatic activities throughout maturation
processes. Na is a mineral quite present in milk and found in different
concentration in animal species. Indeed, it is in twice the concentration in
goat’s, sheep’s and cow’s milk than in human and donkey milk, as reported in
Table 3. Similarly, K, the most abundant mineral in milk, is present especially
in ruminant milk, while its concentration is lower in human and donkey milk
(Table 3). Iron is deficient in milk; indeed, is present in low concentration and
associated with casein and whey proteins [49, 50]. Selenium (Se) is a mineral
found particularly in milk and dairy products [51], and mainly present bound to
casein molecules and whey proteins [52]. Se can be found in two distinct forms:
inorganic and organic. Inorganic forms include selenate (Na
In milk from different animal species, the minerals are distributed differently in soluble and non-soluble fractions (mainly casein micelles). K and Na are present in the water phase, while P, Ca, Mg, Se and I are partly linked to casein micelles. Mineral composition in milk is regarded as relatively constant, but the mineral content can vary mainly according to the lactation stage, the nutritional and health status of the animals [58]. In summary, milk is a food rich in precious minerals with mineral composition varying according to the animal species. Comparing the different animal species considered, it appears that sheep’s and goat’s milk are the richest in minerals compared to other types of milk, as reported in Table 3.
Vitamins play an important role in intermediate metabolism as co-factors in many
enzymatic reactions or in non-enzymatic physiologic functions, and do not
function as structural components within the cell. The vitamin content in milk
varies considerably among mammals and is closely related to the type of feeding
given to the animals. In particular, increased vitamin E and carotenoids have
been observed in milk and dairy products obtained from pasture-fed cows compared
with those obtained from milk of cows on corn silage feeds [59]. Milk and milk
products contain both water-soluble vitamins (vitamins B-complex and vitamin C),
and liposoluble vitamins (A, D, E and K) [60]. The water-soluble vitamins are
situated in the watery phase of milk and therefore present in skim milk; while
the liposoluble vitamins found in the lipidic phase, as in whole milk, cream and
cheese. B complex vitamins perform numerous and important cellular functions,
being implicated as cofactors in anabolic and catabolic reactions. Thiamine or
vitamin B
Human | Donkey | Cow | Sheep | Goat | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
( |
|||||
Thiamine | 14–17 | 21–60 | 28–90 | 28–80 | 40–68 |
Riboflavine | 20–60 | 30–97 | 116–202 | 160–429 | 110–210 |
Niacine (B |
0.18 | 0.09 | 0.13 | 0.41 | 0.24 |
Piridoxine (B |
11–14 | 30–70 | 27–80 | 7–48 | |
Folic acid (B |
5.2–16 | 1–18 | 0.24–5.6 | 0.24–1 | |
Cobalamin (B |
0.03–0.05 | 0.11 | 0.27–0.7 | 0.30–0.71 | 0.06–0.07 |
Vitamin A | 60 | 58 | 41 | 64 | 48 |
Vitamin D | 0.06 | 2.23 | 0.08 | 0.18–1.18 | 0.25 |
Vitamin E | 300–800 | 5.1 | 20–184 | 120 | |
Vitamin K | 0.2–1.5 | 1.1–3.2 |
Source adapted and modified from Claeys et al. [7], 2014; Verduci et al. [41] 2019; Vincenzetti et al. [29] 2021.
The fat-soluble vitamin content of milk is related to the overall fat content of
milk. Vitamin A is found in various forms: retinol, retinal and retinoic acid and
is highly sensitive to oxidation, light or different oxidant factors [67]. The
concentration in milk declines after heat-treating and acidification processes
[68]. The content of vitamin A is higher in breast and sheep’s milk compared to
other animal species listed in Table 4. In western countries, there is no lack of
vitamin A, and milk may be regarded as a good source of the vitamin. Vitamin D is
a group of components, the most important are ergocalciferol (vitamin D
Ca is the major mineral in the human body and plays different structural and functional roles. Indeed, it is important to proper skeletal development [70] and many cellular metabolic processes, such as nerve and muscular cells and for normal blood pressure maintainance [71]. This ion helps to form and maintain the excitability of tissues and conduction of nerve tissue stimuli [72]. Ca plays an important role in the blood coagulation processes. Maintenance of a constant concentration is therefore of vital importance. Vitamin D, lactates and citrates support its absorption in the digestive tract. Dietary Ca derives from milk and milk products, primarily from cheese. Therefore, the main sources of this mineral are skim milk, yogurt and semi-skim cheese, since the lactose they contain promotes its absorption.
Despite milk and dairy products being sources of calcium, the bioavailability of this mineral is influenced by several factors, such as the physiological intestinal barrier, the ratio of calcium to phosphorus, the presence of lactose, vitamin D, oxalates, phytates or some fiber components [73]. In particular, plant foods contain considerable anti-nutritional factors, such as oxalates and phytates. These bind to calcium and form insoluble salt complexes, resulting in lower absorption [74].
As well as for other micronutrients, in some conditions such as aging and during pregnancy, the need Ca intake increases and it is quite difficult to meet recommended Ca levels, leading to the necessary use of Ca-fortified dairy-based products. In fact, the lack of calcium mainly has repercussions on bone health at all ages, since it causes rickets in infants, delays the acquisition of proper bone mass at the time of skeletal development in adolescents and is responsible for accelerated bone loss in adulthood in both women and men, leading to the development of osteoporosis [75].
Selenium (Se) is an essential trace element for humans and animals. Most of the
Se in milk is protein bound [76]. Indeed, this mineral is often found in the form
of selenoprotein and is involved in various physiological functions, such as the
enhancement of immunity and oxidation resistance [77]. Se is important as
enzymatic cofactor in various biological systems and plays an important role in
antioxidant enzyme processes [78]. The absorption of Se is mainly through the
diet and the dietary levels of antioxidant agents, such as vitamins C and E,
methionine and total protein can increase the bioavailability of Se. Milk and its
products contribute over 4% of the total dietary Se consumed by humans [79]. In
milk, about 60–80% of Se is bound to caseins. Se content of forages/feeds
generally depends on the season and agro-ecological conditions, which can
subsequently affect its milk content. Studies have been conducted in different
places around the world in order to document the Se content in milk from dairy
cows, evidencing a considerable variability, depending mainly on the amount of
this element in the soil. The selenium content in cow’s milk from European
countries is in a wide range: in Greece, 110
Iodine (I) is an important element in human health, as it is key component of thyroid hormone [85]. Thyroid hormones are essential for the cellular metabolism and the proper fetal development [86]. In addition to being a structural and functional component of thyroid hormones, it also plays a significant role as a bactericidal because of its oxidative properties [87]. The amount of I in natural foods is highly variable and mainly depends on the soil where plants and animals grow [88]. Milk and milk products can have a significant I concentration and therefore considered among the most common dietary sources of this mineral [89]. Several studies showed that a low I intake results in poor development of neurological and physical functions in children [90]. Furthermore, in adults mild-to-moderate I deficiency increases the incidence of hyperthyroidism due to toxic goiter [91]. On the other hand, the excess I intake has been associated with the development of autoimmune thyroiditis and hypothyroidism [92].
Vitamin A represents a group of organic compounds represented by two principal forms in foods: retinol, found in animal-sourced foods; and provitamin A, known as beta-carotene, present in animal and vegetable foods [93]. Vitamin A is an important nutrient required throughout life, which generally functions as a mediator in various metabolic and physiological processes within the body. Vitamin A is one of the key components involved with visual function, but also in development and cellular differentiation, primary epithelial cells and bone tissue [94]. It also sustains fetal development and embryonic growth [95]. Furthermore, it keeps the immune system active and strengthens its humoral and cellular components [96]. Vitamin A represents one of the most efficient substances in delaying aging, as is involved in maintenance, regulation, and repair of adult tissues [97]. It accelerates skin regeneration by influencing protein synthesis, metabolism and cell proliferation. Lack of vitamin A leads to night blindness, xerophthalmia (progressive blindness due to drying of the cornea of the eye), keratinization (accumulated keratin in the digestive, respiratory and urinary-genital tract tissues) and at last exhaustion and death [98]. A good source of vitamin A is represented from milk and milk products, and the fat content of milk facilitates the dissolving and absorption of vitamin A. Vitamin A is stored in the body and, therefore, deficiency disease is difficult. Nevertheless, the lack of vitamin A is a serious public health problem in many low- and middle-income countries. This primarily concerns young children, women of reproductive age and pregnant women [31]. Especially in this context the intake of milk and milk products fortified with vitamin A can have a positive impact on the functioning of the immune system [99].
The term vitamin D refers to a group of fat-soluble secosteroids: the two main
forms are vitamin D
Vitamin E (primary its isoform a-tocopherol) is an essential antioxidant, which protects cell and sub-cell membranes against attacks of endogenous and exogenous free radicals [109]. The main role of vitamin E is the protection of lipids against oxidative damage. It has been demonstrated that vitamin E acts not only as an antioxidant but also, as a modulator of signal transduction and a regulator of genetic expression. Indeed, some isoforms regulate gene expression in different tissues and cell types [110, 111] and are essential in preventing cardiovascular diseases, especially in coronary artery disease and atherosclerosis. The non-antioxidizing functions of vitamin E can involve several cell- signaling pathways which cause inhibition of the proliferation of smooth muscle cells, platelet adhesion, and aggregation of adhesion molecules. Signs of vitamin E deficiency include ataxia, retinopathy, peripheral neuropathy, musculoskeletal myopathy, and immune response disorders [112]. Vitamin E content in animal foods is generally low, but such products can provide important sources of the vitamin for humans due to their high intake. While the vitamin E content of milk is low, fortification of milk with this vitamin may have an important impact on public health.
Vitamin B is a complex of a broad array of compounds which are essential for
maintaining good health and well-being [113]. Vitamin B
Vitamin C or ascorbic acid exhibits many biological functions, such as antioxidant, collagen, and neurotransmitter synthesis [129]. Vitamin C is important to maintain the integrity of the intracellular matrix and to improve the immune system [130]. Vitamin C deficiency manifests symptomatically with irritability and anorexia, poor wound healing, gingival swelling with loss of teeth, mucocutaneous petechiae, bruising, and hyperkeratosis [131]. Milk is not usually considered an important source of vitamin C, mainly because concentrations are significantly reduced during handling and storage.
Protein-mineral interactions in milk are essential for the functionality of milk
and the nutritional benefits that provides. The protein or peptides of milk can
function as carriers, chelators of various minerals and thus enhance or inhibit
bioavailability [132]. Milk and milk products provide a wide range of bioactive
compounds, among them proteins such as caseins, whey proteins, and other minor
constituents, have been seen to exhibit important biochemical and physiological
functions on human metabolism and health [133, 134, 135]. The caseins, which accounts
for about the 80%, are divided in
Drinking milk is produced from raw milk through a series of steps that include:
collection, normalization that allows reaching the right fat content based on the
type of milk to be produced (skimmed, partially skimmed or whole), homogenization
to break up the fat globules suspended in the milk to distribute them throughout
the entire volume avoiding the accumulation of fat on the surface, heat
treatments such as pasteurization or ultra-high temperature (UHT) sterilization
and finally spillage into commercial packaging for storage and sale [141]. It is
well known that heat treatments of milk affect both mineral distribution
(especially calcium and phosphorus) between its aqueous and colloidal phase,
e.g., a reduction in the solubility of calcium phosphate is observed [142, 143],
and on the concentrations of micronutrients in milk. While no substantial loss of
B complex vitamins as vitamin B
The milk processing objective is to reduce microbial pathogens in raw milk, but several multiple evidence showed that homogenization and pasteurization, through disruption of fat globules and casein micelles, alter the milk fat and protein molecular structure, increasing the allergenicity of processed milk [151]. The casein, beta-lactoglobulin and alpha-lactalbumin are mainly involved in cow’s milk protein allergy. The exclusion of milk and derivatives from the diet is known to cause nutritional deficiencies in macro and micronutrients [152, 153]. However, not excluding these products from the diet in people allergic to proteins or also lactose intolerant (due to the deficiency of the lactase enzyme), produces a wide spectrum of adverse symptoms that mainly affect the gastrointestinal tract but also causes dermatitis and respiratory problems [154, 155].
Different factors influence the micronutrient concentration in milk, both
genetic factors, such as animal breed and environmental factors, like seasons,
soil, and feeding regimens. One of the major factors that affect milk composition
is the animal’s diet. A number of studies have shown that increased grazing
intake from cows effects on milk quality, indeed, increased levels of n-3 fatty
acids, vitamins A, E, carotenoids, and phenols in milk was observed [32, 156].
For example, higher consumption in pasture (usually associated with lower
consumption of concentrate feed) has been associated with higher concentrations
of polyunsaturated fatty acids [157, 158, 159]. In addition, production systems that
are more dependent on grazing have produced milk with higher levels of
antioxidants and vitamins [160]. The concentrations of minerals and trace
elements show wide variations [161], influenced by various factors, including
lactation stage, season, soil type, race, food and contaminants. Actually, diet
correlates with small variations in the mineral content of cow’s milk. Indeed,
dairy cows feeding has relatively small impact on the content of Ca and P in
milk, as the cow’s skeleton serves as a mineral reservoir [162]. Regarding
selenium, higher levels were found in food products derived from monogastric
animals which were fed with grain feed, as well as dairy cows administered with
feed rations containing more mixed feeds enriched in mineral additives. In
addition, the selenium content of milk used in different countries is unknown and
depends on its content in soils [54]. Moreover, elevated Se concentrations appear
in soils rich in iron compounds and organic matter in saline soils [163]. The
variations in essential trace element concentrations in milk are mainly
influenced by animals’ concentrate intake due to the systematic supplementation
of these elements to concentrate feeds [164]. Feeding has a high effect on
liposoluble vitamins, which concentrations are lower when the animals are fed
with grass silage, corn silage or hay than fresh forage. In particular, in these
conserved forages the vitamins and carotenoid concentrations (vitamin A precursor
such as
Also, with respect to water-soluble vitamins, and in particular B-vitamins
complex, correlations with dietary intake were demonstrated. Ruminal synthesis of
B-vitamins is modified by diet composition. In particular, it is affected by
dietary forage and the unfermented carbohydrate content of dairy cow diet,
indeed, it was observed that increasing dietary forage content decreased ruminal
synthesis of pyridoxine, folic acid and vitamin B
It is also noteworthy that among milk production systems, the organic system is the one that most ensures high quality milk from the perspective of micronutrient composition. Indeed, this system combines the preservation of a high level of biodiversity, protection of natural resources and high standards of animal welfare. The animal feeding choices adopted by this system ensure a source of a variety of bioactive substances that become part of milk [176].
In addition to animal feeding strategies adopted to increase the minerals or vitamin content in milk, the enrichment of this food can be carried out by a process of “fortification”, a necessary practice since some important micronutrient deficiencies have a detrimental effect on human health. As reported by Woźniak and colleagues [33], it is difficult to meet the needs of calcium, iron, vitamin A and D, particularly in the diet of young children. In fact, in many cases supplementation of these components is necessary to avert health problems especially in the most vulnerable groups. This leads to the conclusion that, not only should milk consumption be encouraged, but fortification of milk with these micronutrients to balance its deficiencies due to both different treatments of milk itself and poor milk consumption, can be of great help [33]. Shortages of vitamin A, vitamin D and Ca (even in high- latitudes countries) have been reported to be a major concern [177, 178]. Food fortification is one of the public health actions aimed at improving the content of essential micronutrients, i.e., vitamins and minerals (including trace elements) in a food, representing a good choice to improve the nutritional quality of the food. In certain countries, especially populations at high latitudes such as Finland, Sweden and Canada, the fortification of milk with vitamin D is strongly recommended [35]. Indeed, in Northern latitudes, particularly in winter, ultraviolet B radiation is too weak for the dermis to synthesize vitamin D [179] and its supplementation is required to prevent deficiency [180], because many foods commonly consumed by humans contain low levels of vitamin D. Vitamin A can be found in large quantities in whole milk, as it is mainly related to the fat phase of milk. As a result, vitamin A should be added to dairy products whose fat has been removed, in the amount needed to restore the quantity of these vitamins lost in fat removal. In contrast, whole milk is not considered as an important source of vitamin D, and therefore the elimination of fat does not make milk less nutritious if we consider the amount of this vitamin [181]. Milk and dairy products contain high levels of Ca with high bioavailability. However, milk consumption is decreasing in industrialized countries, resulting in inadequate intake of Ca. This is one of the reasons for the industrial development of Ca-fortified foods, ensuring an adequate consumption of this mineral. Indeed, studies showed an excellent Ca bioavailability in Ca-fortified milk, but all that glitters is not gold as the Ca fortification has a negative impact on iron absorption percentages [37]. Despite this inhibitory effect on iron uptake, consumption of Ca-rich foods should be encouraged, considering that fortification of milk with vitamin D and Ca nearly eliminated the public health concerns related to rickets in the 19th century. In Table 5, micronutrients were classified according to milk enrichment practices.
Micronutrient-fortified milk | Grazing and feeding techniques | |
---|---|---|
Calcium | ||
Vitamin A | ||
Vitamin D | ||
Vitamin E | ||
B-vitamins complex | ||
Selenium |
Food fortifications are a cost-effective strategy for improving the population nutritional state [182] and were associated with strong economic advantages [183]. Indeed, cost effectiveness, considering deaths averted or disabilities cured, has helped to give fortification high priority as a preventive health-care intervention. The prerequisites for food fortification include modern food-processing facilities, quality control and monitoring systems, distribution facilities, and regulatory support, which certainly drive up the cost of the final product. However, this price increase, can be considered insignificant compared to the high return in terms of health and disability prevention [184]. On the other hand, the different types of selected feeds and forages, which ensure a nutritionally quality product, have significant economic and environmental impacts. To date, factors such as scarcity of land, soil, and water, ongoing global warming and frequent drastic climatic variations, and increased competition for arable land can pose serious economic and environmental challenges to the sustainability of feed production systems and fodder cultivation [185]. In addition, the production, processing and transport of feed account for ~45% of the anthropogenic greenhouse gas emission from the livestock sector [186]. Therefore, food fortification remains an efficient economic and environmental strategy for human health.
Over the past few years, researchers’ attention to the quality of foods consumed by humans to prevent the onset of malnutrition has significantly increased. A number of studies have been carried out to analyze the composition and nutritional quality of foods. Of these, a large space is occupied by milk, a food rich in all nutrients, which makes it particularly valuable. The particularly interesting nutritional components of milk are minerals and vitamins, which despite their presence in small amounts, are essential compounds because their consumption is crucial for the growth and maintenance of human health. The mineral and vitamin profile in milk varies according to animal species, making each unique. In this review, we examined the main differences in terms of minerals and vitaminic profile of milk from different animal species, observing more marked differences in micronutrient content between ruminant and non-ruminant animal species. In detail, it appears that sheep’s and goat’s milk are the richest in minerals and complex B vitamins, while human milk is distinguished by its vitamin A and vitamin E content. In addition, we focused on the main effects of certain minerals and vitamins on human health, emphasizing the adverse effects due to the lack of these valuable milk components, which make it a valuable food for humans. Fortunately, the current industrial practices of processing raw milk in drinking milk lead to limited alteration in micronutrients, except in special cases. Finally, we analyzed certain strategies adopted to increase micronutrient content in milk. Animal feeding type is known to play an important role in determining higher or lower levels of micronutrients in milk, and thus milk quality. It has become apparent that higher consumption in pasture associated with lower consumption of concentrate feed is the optimal strategy for enriching milk with micronutrients. Also, to date, the fortification systems of milk with certain micronutrient, is a preventive practice on the development of malnutrition-related diseases. Vitamin A, vitamin D and Ca deficiencies have been identified as a major public health concern, primarily in the poorest countries. The problem is partly addressed through the formulation of fortified milk.
The further exploration of effective systems to produce milk rich in essential ingredients for human health should therefore be encouraged and strengthened.
GC and FC contributed to the conception of this manuscript. GC, FC, AC, RT and IV contributed to manuscript writing-original draft preparation. GC contributed to manuscript writing-revision and editing. FC and LP contributed to manuscript visualization. GC contributed to manuscript supervision. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Not applicable.
Not applicable.
This research received no external funding.
The authors declare no conflict of interest. GC is serving as Guest Editor of this journal. We declare that GC had no involvement in the peer review of this article and has no access to information regarding its peer review. Full responsibility for the editorial process for this article was delegated to JJ.
Publisher’s Note: IMR Press stays neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.