1 Department of Psychiatry, Kangci Hospital of Jiaxing, 314500 Tongxiang, Zhejiang, China
Abstract
Psychiatric disorders are often accompanied by complex comorbidities. Even non-psychiatric medical professionals are increasingly encountering patients with mental disorders during routine clinical practice. This study assessed post-training mental health knowledge and additional training needs across grassroots medical workers who had recently undergone systematic training, aiming to provide empirical evidence for building the capacity of mental health professionals.
This study surveyed 503 medical staff from various levels and types of medical institutions in Tongxiang city, China, who had undergone systematic mental health training. Data regarding baseline characteristics and mental health-related knowledge were obtained 1–2 days after training completion using two questionnaire types: the “Questionnaire on Medical Staff’s Awareness of Mental Health Issues” and the “Questionnaire on Training Needs of Medical Staff”. The Kruskal-Wallis (K-W) test was used to compare the demand for psychiatric services and total psychiatric knowledge scores among primary care medical staff with different job positions, specialties, professional titles, and years of service.
The mean mental health knowledge score among 503 grassroots medical workers was 53.22 ± 17.44 out of the total 70 points. Regarding mental health service training content, over 80% of the respondents reported knowledge and skills items as “urgently needed” or “needed”, with some items exceeding 90%. Short-term training workshops were the preferred delivery approach, with centralized on-site lectures or distance education as the favored formats. High demand was reported for theoretical knowledge sessions, simulated case-based discussions, simulation exercises, and internship practice; the preferred training duration was half a working day per session. The leading motivations for participating in training were job requirements, personal professional development needs, and skill enhancement, whereas the main barriers to participating in training were workload or scheduling conflicts. Multiple factors were found to affect training effectiveness, including training time, format, and content. Significant differences were observed in the proportion of mental health service needs regarding primary job positions, specialties, professional titles, and years of service (p < 0.05). Total mental health knowledge scores also varied by primary job position, years of service, and prior participation in mental health work (p < 0.05).
Grassroots medical workers demonstrated a foundational level of mental health knowledge following recent systematic training, with significant inter-individual variation. Demand for mental health service training was generally high, with job requirements and personal capacity enhancement as the primary drivers, while time constraints and insufficient course practicality of the modules were the main barriers. It is recommended to develop and implement corresponding strategies to address these challenges and enhance grassroots medical workers’ mastery of mental health knowledge.
Keywords
- health personnel
- mental health
- health knowledge, attitudes, practice
- health surveys
- needs assessment
Psychiatric disorders are common, chronic health conditions associated with high disease burden and significant disability rates [1, 2]. The implementation of the three-tier prevention system for mental illnesses relies on early detection, accurate diagnosis, and timely treatment to halt and reduce disease progression [3]. Because mental health awareness directly impacts early detection and effective intervention, healthcare professionals must integrate strong clinical skills with evidence-based understanding, appropriate attitudes toward mental conditions, and adequate mental health knowledge.
Recent medical evidence demonstrates that psychiatric disorders often coexist with other complex conditions and contribute to the pathogenesis of organic diseases, such as endocrine and metabolic disorders, cardiovascular pathologies, and a range of infectious and gastrointestinal diseases [4, 5, 6, 7]. Mental health-related hospitalization increases across clinical services, and medical professionals increasingly encounter patients with mental disorders, necessitating enhanced mental health knowledge among non-psychiatric practitioners.
Current research on mental health knowledge awareness is limited and predominantly focuses on student populations. Among adolescents, Chinese youth reveal an overall awareness rate of 66%, with a higher rate reported among university students (73%) and a lower rate among secondary students (61%) [8]. Indonesian adolescents demonstrate significant cognitive deficits that hinder disease recognition and delay treatment [9]. Similarly, secondary students in northern Jordan exhibit low understanding of mental health issues [10]. Notably, among medical undergraduates in Uganda, knowledge retention regarding mental disorders reaches 77.72%, yet positive attitudes (49.29%) and sufficient mental health cognition (46.92%) remain inadequate [11].
Beyond the student cohort, population-level gaps are more prominent.
Community-based surveys in Ethiopia reveal relatively poor public awareness of
mental illnesses [12]. In clinical settings, only 21 out of 245 registered mental
health nurses in the United Kingdom scored
Grassroots medical personnel primarily working in community health centers and township settings, including registered physicians, nursing staff, and allied health professionals, form the cornerstone of primary care and play a crucial role in delivering mental health services. Their proficiency in mental health knowledge directly influences patients’ adherence to treatment and recovery outcomes. However, systematic assessments of their current mental health knowledge remain limited. Consequently, this study investigates grassroots medical workers to assess their mental health knowledge and identify specific needs, providing empirical evidence to inform workforce development and capacity-building in primary care.
The study was performed between 1 January 2024 and 31 December 2024, and included 503 medical workers from multiple tiers and facility types in Tongxiang city, China. This survey enrolled participants from 35 institutions across six categories: 4 municipal general hospitals (11.43% of institutions; 167 participants, representing 33.20% of the sample), 3 municipal specialized hospitals (8.57%; 62, 12.33%), 4 community health centers (11.43%; 87, 17.30%), 5 township health centers (14.29%; 89, 17.69%), 16 community health stations/village clinics (45.71%; 90, 17.89%), and 3 other types of institutions (8.57%; 8, 1.59%). These 35 institutions collectively contributed to the 503 completed surveys.
The study was approved by the Medical Ethics Committee of Kangci Hospital of Jiaxing (Approval No. 2025-LUNLI-013). All procedures performed in compliance with the Declaration of Helsinki.
Inclusion criteria for selection of study participants were as follows: (1) employment in primary care institutions; (2) minimum one year of work experience; (3) voluntary participated and independent completion of the questionnaire; and (4) provision of informed consent.
The participants were excluded if (1) undertaking an internship training, (2) employed in secondary or tertiary hospitals or specialized medical institutions, (3) off duty during the survey period (e.g., advanced studies, rotations, standardized training programs) or not a formal staff member, (4) with history of major physical disorders within the past year requiring continuous treatment or significantly impacting daily activity, cognition, or mood (such as severe cardiovascular disease, advanced cancer, severe neurological disorders like dementia or Parkinson’s disease), (5) with history of severe psychiatric conditions requiring hospitalization or ongoing medication, such as schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, or major depressive disorder.
The study employed a structured questionnaire as the survey instrument comprising two major sections: a ‘demographic’ and a ‘mental health knowledge and training’ section. The demographic section recorded data regarding gender, age, specialty, highest degree, professional qualification, technical title, primary role, and participation in mental health work. The mental health knowledge-assessment section comprising the Mental Health Awareness Questionnaire for Medical Workers (included 35 items where a 2-point score indicate “well-informed”, 1 indicates “somewhat informed”, and 0 show “uninformed”, with total scores obtained by summing all items) and the Training Needs Questionnaire for Medical Workers (evaluating content needs—8 knowledge-based items and 8 skill-based items—and format needs including training channels, methods, teaching approaches, scheduling, motivations for participation, barriers to attendance, and other factors influencing effectiveness).
After standardized investigators training, participants were contacted by phone and informed about the purpose of the survey, confidentiality procedures, and voluntary participation. Trained participants were then invited to complete the questionnaire within 1–2 days of training. Participants were informed that the training was part of a study that would involve a subsequent knowledge and training needs assessment. After obtaining consent, investigators distributed a quick response (QR) code linking to the Questionnaire Star survey. Investigators clarified the questionnaire structure and completion guidelines but refrained from interpreting specific items. Respondents completed and submitted questionnaires independently online.
Two questionnaire types were used to assess mental health awareness and training requirements across health care workers.
(a) Mental Health Awareness Questionnaire: the dimension framework included the recognition of symptoms in common severe mental disorders, anxiety and neurosis-related issues, mental rehabilitation, insomnia and psychological counseling, organic brain disorders, relevant laws, regulations, and ethics. This framework was primarily developed from the core modules of the World Health Organization (WHO) Mental Health Gap Action Programme (mhGAP) Intervention Guide, the National Health Commission’s “Standard Operating Procedures for the Management and Treatment of Severe Mental Disorders”, and the “National Basic Public Health Service Standards”. Crucial knowledge gaps and common misconceptions critical to primary care were identified by reviewing domestic and international mental health capacity-assessment tools for primary care, combined with focus group interviews with 15 health care professionals from 3 community health service centers in the city (8 general practitioners, 3 public health physicians, 4 nurses). Examples included identifying somatic manifestations of depression and anxiety, key elements of suicide risk assessment, and communication skills for interacting with these patients. After drafting the questionnaire instrument, cognitive interviews with 10 grassroots medical staff were used to optimize technical terminology and improve the relevance of scenario-based items, for example, changing “negative symptoms” with “manifestations such as lack of motivation and flat affect”.
(b) Training Needs Questionnaire: this questionnaire was developed using a competency gap model for training needs analysis. Dimensions included: knowledge needs (e.g., identification, assessment, basic pharmacology, psychosocial interventions), skills and operational needs (e.g., risk assessment, communication skills, emergency management, follow-up care), preferences for training method and resources (e.g., online modules, offline (in-person) workshops, case discussions, preferred duration), and perceived barriers to training (e.g., time conflicts, insufficient funding, lack of high-quality resources). The design referenced national policies for primary care workforce development and research reports on mental health training needs. Priorities and practical constraints were clarified through semi-structured interviews with 8 managers of grassroots medical institutions and 12 frontline medical staff. Pre-testing emphasized the rationality and appropriateness of response options and the time required to complete the questionnaire.
Eight experts evaluated content validity. The expert panel included 2 chief psychiatrists (1 specializing in community mental health), 1 professor of general practice, 1 official from the provincial mental health program office, 1 community health service center director (with a general practice background), 1 senior physician in community mental health prevention, 1 nursing management specialist experienced in primary care, and 1 medical education expert. The review was conducted via an online questionnaire platform. Experts received questionnaires, detailed definitions of each dimension, and review guidelines instructing them to rate item relevance and clarity on a 4-point scale and to provide specific revision suggestions. The review period lasted for three weeks.
For the Mental Health Awareness Questionnaire, item-level content validity index (I-CVI)
ranged from 0.75 to 1.00. Among these, 2 items had an I-CVI of 0.75 (rated 3 or 4
by 6/8 experts), the and all remaining items were
For the Training Needs Questionnaire, I-CVIs ranged from 0.88 to 1.00, with S-CVI/UA = 0.90 and S-CVI/Ave = 0.96. Experts suggested refinements to response options within the “training barriers” dimension.
Based on expert ratings (with particular focus on items with I-CVI
Reliability was evaluated using 503 valid responses from medical staff at community health service and township health centers (physicians 43%, nurses 34%, public health personnel 15%, other 8%).
For the Mental Health Awareness Questionnaire, the overall
Cronbach’s
For the Training Needs Questionnaire, the overall Cronbach’s
Questionnaire data were double-entered in EpiData software (version 3.0; The
EpiData Association, Odense, Denmark), and statistically analyzed using SPSS
software (version 16.0; IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA). Continuous variables were
presented as mean
The study enrolled 503 primary care providers, including 126 (25.05%) men and
377 (74.95%) women. Among 503 grassroots medical workers, the average duration
of professional experience was 15.15
| Variable | n (%) | |
| Gender | ||
| Male | 126 (25.05) | |
| Female | 377 (74.95) | |
| Age (years) | ||
| 20~29 | 72 (14.31) | |
| 30~39 | 269 (53.48) | |
| 40~49 | 125 (24.85) | |
| 37 (7.36) | ||
| Specialty | ||
| Clinical medicine (western/Traditional Chinese) | 190 (37.77) | |
| Nursing | 88 (17.50) | |
| Others (public health, management, radiology, laboratory medicine) | 225 (44.73) | |
| Highest education | ||
| Technical secondary school | 5 (0.99) | |
| College | 47 (9.34) | |
| Bachelor’s degree | 437 (86.88) | |
| Master’s degree or higher | 14 (2.78) | |
| Professional qualification | ||
| Clinical (assistant) physician | 197 (39.17) | |
| Public health (assistant) practitioner | 5 (0.99) | |
| Registered nurse | 227 (45.13) | |
| Technician/Technologist | 49 (9.74) | |
| Others | 25 (4.97) | |
| Professional title | ||
| No title | 12 (2.39) | |
| Junior title | 197 (39.17) | |
| Intermediate title | 206 (40.95) | |
| Senior title | 88 (17.50) | |
| Primary job position | ||
| Clinical doctor | 143 (28.43) | |
| Nursing staff | 153 (30.42) | |
| Mental health prevention personnel | 22 (4.47) | |
| Psychiatric specialist | 32 (6.36) | |
| Psychiatric nurse | 48 (9.54) | |
| Others (public health/medical technician/TCM/rehabilitation/immunization/maternal | ||
| child health, etc.) | 105 (20.87) | |
| Participation in mental health work | ||
| Yes | 102 (20.28) | |
| No | 401 (79.72) | |
| Job tenure (years) | ||
| 113 (22.47%) | ||
| 166 (33.00%) | ||
| 224 (44.53%) | ||
Note: TCM , Traditional Chinese Medicine.
Responses were scored as 2 (well-informed), 1 (somewhat informed) and 0
(uninformed). The mean total score for mental health awareness among the study
participants was 53.22
| Question | Well-informed | Somewhat informed | Uninformed |
| 1. October 10th is “World Mental Health Day”. | 279 (55.47) | 170 (33.80) | 54 (10.74) |
| 2. The mental health law stipulates that inpatient treatment for mental disorders follows the principle of voluntary admission. | 308 (61.23) | 153 (30.42) | 42 (8.35) |
| 3. The Management Measures for Reporting Onset of Severe Mental Disorders (Trial) requires mandatory reporting for six severe mental illnesses: schizophrenia, schizoaffective disorder, persistent delusional disorder (paranoid psychosis), bipolar disorder, mental disorders due to epilepsy, and intellectual disability with associated mental disorder. | 312 (62.03) | 145 (28.83) | 46 (9.15) |
| 4. Medical institutions and individuals shall maintain confidentiality of mentally ill patients’ names, portraits, addresses, workplaces, medical records, and other identifiable information. | 371 (73.76) | 113 (22.47) | 19 (3.78) |
| 5. Consultation-Liaison Psychiatry refers to psychiatrists providing psychiatric care, education, and research in general hospitals, delivering medical and rehabilitation services through multidimensional biopsychosocial approaches. | 297 (59.05) | 179 (35.59) | 27 (5.37) |
| 6. Schizophrenia is a common severe mental illness with incompletely understood etiology. It predominantly affects young adults, often follows a relapsing-remitting course causing disability, though a minority may achieve full/partial recovery. | 330 (65.61) | 152 (30.22) | 21 (4.17) |
| 7. Bipolar disorder is characterized by complex alternating/irregular episodes of depression and mania/hypomania, accompanied by distractibility, recklessness, grandiosity, racing thoughts, hyperactivity, reduced sleep, and pressured speech. | 321 (63.82) | 158 (31.41) | 24 (4.77) |
| 8. Early schizophrenia may present subtly as neurosis-like symptoms, mild personality changes, or avolition without overt psychosis, making recognition difficult. | 301 (59.84) | 178 (35.39) | 24 (4.77) |
| 9. Maintenance pharmacotherapy after first-episode schizophrenia remission should last |
290 (57.65) | 175 (34.79) | 38 (7.55) |
| 10. Schizophrenia patients may pose risks of dangerous behaviors when acting under delusions/hallucinations. | 313 (62.23) | 165 (32.80) | 25 (4.97) |
| 11. Dementia syndrome is a chronic global cognitive disorder featuring progressive intellectual decline. | 310 (61.63) | 176 (34.99) | 17 (3.38) |
| 12. Delirium—an acute consciousness disturbance with vivid hallucinations—commonly affects medically complex elders and signals severe illness. | 306 (60.83) | 175 (34.79) | 22 (4.37) |
| 13. Early dementia signs include: reduced interest/efficiency, recent memory loss, slowed thinking, poor concentration, and personality changes. | 317 (63.02) | 170 (33.80) | 16 (3.18) |
| 14. Advanced dementia often involves behavioral/psychological symptoms like hallucinations/delusions. | 302 (60.04) | 183 (36.38) | 18 (3.58) |
| 15. Parkinson’s medications may induce psychosis due to dopaminergic effects. | 264 (52.49) | 209 (41.55) | 30 (5.96) |
| 16. Depressive mood may manifest as somatic complaints (e.g., chest tightness, palpitations, fatigue, dizziness, and frequent urination). | 303 (60.24) | 187 (37.18) | 13 (2.58) |
| 17. Early morning awakening is the most characteristic sleep disturbance in depression. | 297 (59.05) | 184 (36.28) | 22 (4.37) |
| 18. Antidepressants typically take 1–2 weeks to show initial effects, with optimal efficacy at 4–8 weeks. | 266 (52.88) | 181 (35.98) | 56 (11.13) |
| 19. Current depression treatments include pharmacotherapy, modified electroconvulsive therapy (MECT), psychotherapy, and repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS). | 275 (54.67) | 198 (39.36) | 30 (5.96) |
| 20. Suicidal behaviors in depression may occur during severe, early, or recovery phases, often in the early morning. | 293 (58.25) | 183 (36.38) | 27 (5.37) |
| 21. Anti-anxiety medications include benzodiazepines, non-benzodiazepine anxiolytics, antidepressants, and |
274 (54.47) | 183 (36.38) | 46 (9.15) |
| 22. Generalized anxiety disorder features persistent worry without specific triggers, accompanied by autonomic symptoms, muscle tension, and motor restlessness. | 260 (51.69) | 209 (41.55) | 34 (6.76) |
| 23. Obsessive-compulsive disorder is characterized by coexisting intrusive obsessions and neutralizing compulsions. | 283 (56.26) | 197 (39.17) | 23 (4.57) |
| 24. Somatic symptom disorder involves recurrent physical complaints without explanatory organic pathology, persisting despite medical reassurance. | 268 (53.28) | 207 (41.15) | 28 (5.57) |
| 25. Cardiac neurosis, psychogenic hyperventilation/hiccups, gastric neurosis, neurotic diarrhea, psychogenic bloating, irritable bowel syndrome, and psychogenic urinary frequency/dysuria are all somatic symptom disorders. | 249 (49.50) | 214 (42.54) | 40 (7.95) |
| 26. Polysomnography (PSG) is a key sleep medicine technique assessing sleep architecture, efficiency, staging, and respiratory events (e.g., hypopnea/apnea). | 229 (45.53) | 232 (46.12) | 42 (8.35) |
| 27. Crisis intervention following major trauma may reduce post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) incidence. | 265 (52.68) | 208 (41.35) | 30 (5.96) |
| 28. Most hypnotics are Class II psychiatric drugs. They improve insomnia but should not be routinely prescribed. | 290 (57.65) | 187 (37.18) | 26 (5.17) |
| 29. Psychotherapy is a professional interpersonal process wherein therapists use verbal/nonverbal methods to facilitate positive psychological/physiological changes for recovery. | 288 (57.26) | 194 (38.57) | 21 (4.17) |
| 30. The mental health law mandates psychotherapy exclusively within medical institutions. | 281 (55.86) | 191 (37.97) | 31 (6.16) |
| 31. The Law requires medical institutions to provide essential psychiatric medications for home-based severe mental disorder patients and offer technical guidance to community rehabilitation facilities. | 277 (55.07) | 194 (38.57) | 32 (6.36) |
| 32. Psychiatric rehabilitation restores social functioning impaired by mental disability through biological, social, and psychological approaches. | 274 (54.47) | 205 (40.76) | 24 (4.77) |
| 33. The three principles of psychiatric rehabilitation are: functional training, comprehensive rehabilitation, and social reintegration. | 305 (60.64) | 179 (35.59) | 19 (3.78) |
| 34. Psychiatric rehabilitation includes: life skills training, medication self-management training, and skills for seeking medical assistance. | 289 (57.46) | 186 (36.98) | 28 (5.57) |
| 35. Social skills training prepares patients for community reintegration through guided participation in social activities (e.g., family visits, group activities). | 297 (59.05) | 183 (36.38) | 23 (4.57) |
As summarized in Table 3, across both knowledge and skills domains of mental health service training, over 80% of grassroots medical workers rated each time as “urgently needed” or “needed”, with several items exceeding 90%.
| Training content | Urgently needed + needed | Already mastered, not needed | Not needed for work | |
| Knowledge areas | ||||
| 1. Clinical manifestations of severe mental disorders | 409 (81.31) | 70 (13.92) | 24 (4.77) | |
| 2. Recognition and prevention of early signs of relapse | 420 (83.50) | 60 (11.93) | 23 (4.57) | |
| 3. Common adverse reactions to psychiatric medications and management measures | 429 (85.29) | 47 (9.34) | 27 (5.37) | |
| 4. Clinical manifestations of common psychological and behavioral issues | 439 (87.28) | 47 (9.34) | 17 (3.38) | |
| 5. Application of screening scales for common psychological and behavioral problems | 439 (87.28) | 26 (5.17) | 38 (7.55) | |
| 6. Health education knowledge on symptoms, treatment options, and home care | 453 (90.06) | 34 (6.76) | 16 (3.18) | |
| 7. Mental health laws and regulations | 442 (87.87) | 38 (7.55) | 23 (4.57) | |
| 8. Policies on assistance for patients with severe mental disorders | 445 (88.47) | 29 (5.77) | 29 (5.77) | |
| Skills areas | ||||
| 1. Addressing psychological issues while identifying and treating physical illnesses | 452 (89.86) | 29 (5.77) | 22 (4.37) | |
| 2. Identifying and treating physical health problems in patients with mental disorders | 448 (89.07) | 34 (6.76) | 21 (4.17) | |
| 3. How to refer patients with mental/psychological issues | 431 (85.69) | 45 (8.95) | 27 (5.37) | |
| 4. Specific measures for case management | 445 (88.47) | 23 (4.57) | 35 (6.96) | |
| 5. Communication techniques with patients experiencing mental/psychological issues | 461 (91.65) | 26 (5.17) | 16 (3.18) | |
| 6. Self-protection measures during communication and follow-up with mentally ill patients | 454 (90.26) | 33 (6.56) | 16 (3.18) | |
| 7. Psychological counseling | 449 (89.26) | 33 (6.56) | 21 (4.17) | |
| 8. Evidence-based psychotherapy | 447 (88.87) | 17 (3.38) | 39 (7.75) | |
Grassroots medical workers favored short-term workshops as the preferred delivery mode for mental health service training. Centralized on-site lectures or distance education were the most favored training formats. Demand was high across instructional methods, theoretical knowledge instruction, case-based discussions, simulation exercises, and practical internships. Half-day sessions on weekdays were the preferred training duration. The leading motivations for participation were job position requirements, the need to improve personal competency, and opportunities to broaden skills and perspectives. The primary barrier to non-participation was workload and schedule conflicts. Multiple factors potentially affecting training effectiveness were training timing, delivery format, and content, as presented in Table 4.
| Training method | Yes | No | |
| Training method (multiple choices) | |||
| Advanced studies at specialty hospitals | 295 (58.65) | 208 (41.35) | |
| Conducting short-term training courses | 429 (85.29) | 74 (14.71) | |
| Long-term systematic training | 192 (38.17) | 311 (61.83) | |
| Others | 3 (0.60) | 500 (99.40) | |
| Training format (multiple choices) | |||
| On-site centralized lectures | 412 (81.91) | 91 (18.09) | |
| Distance education | 354 (70.38) | 149 (29.62) | |
| Self-study followed by assessment | 201 (39.96) | 302 (60.04) | |
| Others | 4 (0.80) | 499 (99.20) | |
| Instructional approach | |||
| Theoretical knowledge lectures | 433 (86.08) | 70 (13.92) | |
| Case-based analysis and discussion | 442 (87.87) | 61 (12.13) | |
| Simulation drills | 334 (66.40) | 169 (33.60) | |
| Internship/practical training | 308 (61.23) | 195 (38.77) | |
| Others | 1 (0.20) | 502 (99.80) | |
| Training duration (single choice) | |||
| Full workday sessions | 117 (23.26) | - | |
| Half workday sessions | 232 (46.12) | - | |
| Full weekend day sessions | 44 (8.75) | - | |
| Half weekend day sessions | 105 (20.87) | - | |
| Others | 5 (0.99) | - | |
| Reasons for attending training (multiple choices) | |||
| Job position requirements | 444 (88.27) | 59 (11.73) | |
| Personal competency development | 373 (74.16) | 130 (25.84) | |
| Building professional networks | 207 (41.15) | 296 (58.85) | |
| Promotion requirements | 178 (35.39) | 325 (64.61) | |
| Broadening perspectives and enhancing skills | 326 (64.81) | 177 (35.19) | |
| Others | 1 (0.20) | 502 (99.80) | |
| Reasons for not attending training (multiple choices) | |||
| High cost | 120 (23.86) | 383 (76.14) | |
| Lack of leadership support | 53 (10.54) | 450 (89.46) | |
| Heavy workload/schedule conflicts | 443 (88.07) | 60 (11.93) | |
| Irrelevant content to job duties | 42 (8.35) | 461 (91.65) | |
| Unaware of training information | 48 (9.54) | 455 (90.46) | |
| Others | 1 (0.20) | 502 (99.80) | |
| Factors affecting training effectiveness (multiple choices) | |||
| Training content | 317 (63.02) | 186 (36.98) | |
| Training schedule | 358 (71.17) | 145 (28.83) | |
| Training format | 322 (64.02) | 181 (35.98) | |
| Instructor qualification | 246 (48.91) | 257 (51.09) | |
| Organizers’ coordination | 169 (33.60) | 334 (66.40) | |
| Others | 2 (0.40) | 501 (99.60) | |
Significant differences (p
| Variable | n (%) | Rank mean | H | p-value | |
| Primary job position | 38.992 | ||||
| Clinical physicians/nurses | 296 (58.85%) | 227.28 | |||
| Mental health prevention personnel and psychiatric physicians/nurses | 102 (20.28%) | 330.53 | |||
| Other (public health personnel; medical technicians; TCM/rehabilitation/physiotherapy; immunization/child/maternal healthcare) | 105 (20.87%) | 245.40 | |||
| Specialty | 41.077 | ||||
| Clinical medicine (western/TCM) | 190 (37.77%) | 202.53 | |||
| Nursing | 88 (17.50%) | 251.97 | |||
| Other (public health; management; medical imaging; laboratory medicine; others) | 225 (44.73%) | 293.79 | |||
| Professional title | 42.671 | ||||
| No title | 12 (2.39%) | 145.04 | |||
| Junior title | 197 (39.17%) | 216.22 | |||
| Intermediate title | 206 (40.95%) | 260.69 | |||
| Senior title | 88 (17.50%) | 326.34 | |||
| Job tenure (years) | 6.641 | 0.036 | |||
| 113 (22.47%) | 225.27 | ||||
| 166 (33.00%) | 246.60 | ||||
| 224 (44.53%) | 267.39 | ||||
Note: TCM, Traditional Chinese Medicine.
Total mental health knowledge scores across grassroots medical workers were
significantly influenced by primary job position, job tenure, and current
participation in mental health work (p
| Variable | n (%) | Rank mean | H | p-value | |
| Primary job position | 40.849 | 0.000 | |||
| Clinical physicians/nurses | 296 (58.85%) | 235.27 | |||
| Mental health prevention personnel and psychiatric physicians/nurses | 102 (20.28%) | 332.36 | |||
| Other (public health personnel; medical technicians; TCM/rehabilitation/physiotherapy; immunization/child/maternal healthcare) | 105 (20.87%) | 221.09 | |||
| Specialty | 0.924 | 0.630 | |||
| Clinical medicine (western/TCM) | 190 (37.77%) | 258.27 | |||
| Nursing | 88 (17.50%) | 240.61 | |||
| Other (public health; management; medical imaging; laboratory medicine; others) | 225 (44.73%) | 251.16 | |||
| Professional title | 6.133 | 0.105 | |||
| No title | 12 (2.39%) | 201.17 | |||
| Junior title | 197 (39.17%) | 244.57 | |||
| Intermediate title | 206 (40.95%) | 248.98 | |||
| Senior title | 88 (17.50%) | 282.64 | |||
| Job tenure (years) | 7.149 | 0.028 | |||
| 113 (22.47%) | 246.20 | ||||
| 166 (33.00%) | 230.20 | ||||
| 224 (44.53%) | 268.99 | ||||
| Participation in mental health work | 40.092 | 0.000 | |||
| Yes | 102 (20.28%) | 332.36 | |||
| No | 401 (79.72%) | 231.56 | |||
Note: TCM, Traditional Chinese Medicine.
Among 503 grassroots medical workers, the mean mental health knowledge score was 53.22 out of 70 (76%). Although this indicates a foundational knowledge base, labeling it ‘moderate-to-high’ needs caution. The substantial standard deviation of 17.44 points reflects significant inter-individual variation and high scores may reflect item difficulty or specificity rather than practical competence. Over 80% of grassroots medical workers selected mental health training items as “urgently needed” or “needed”, with some items exceeding 90%. This indicates a consistently high demand for mental health training among primary healthcare providers. Key contributing factors include:
First, since 2018, China’s National Health Commission has required primary healthcare institutions to screen for severe mental disorders, register patients, and provide follow-up management [15]. In some regions, mental health training has been included in professional title assessments, directly driving the need for systematic training. Second, rising social stressors, changing living environments, and post-Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) conditions have increased the incidence of mental disorders and psychologically mediated diseases [16, 17], surpassing primary care capacity and necessitating enhanced skills among frontline physicians. Moreover, recovery from mental disorders is chronic and clinically characterized by high relapse rates, requiring continuous rehabilitation management [18]. Consequently, grassroots medical workers need competencies spanning the full cycle of care, driving substantial demand for comprehensive mental health training.
For training delivery, grassroots physicians favor short-term, intensive training programs, with “half-day weekday sessions” as the preferred choice. This preference reflects the requirements to manage heavy clinical workloads while timely updating mental health knowledge. Evidence on teaching formats reveals a parallel demand for centralized onsite instruction and distance education. Centralized onsite training—typically brief sessions—minimizes repeated absences that disrupt clinical services and suits the “multi-role staffing” nature of primary care. Conversely, distance education enables learning during fragmented time slots (e.g., between shifts or post-night duties), eliminates geographical barriers to reduce travel time and costs, and allows revisiting complex content via recordings to accommodate diverse learning paces.
Regarding teaching methodologies, there is a high demand for multiple instructional approaches, consistent with modern medical education’s “theory-practice-innovation” progression. The leading motivations for participation were “job requirements” and “professional development”, underscoring that updated knowledge or skills are essential for maintaining clinical quality and career advancement. In contrast, principal barriers to attendance were overwhelming clinical duties that complicated scheduling, concerns about service coverage during leave, and perceptions of irrelevant or lengthy course content.
Our analysis indicates that psychiatrists/psychiatric nurses, staff with senior professional titles, and those with longer years of service report a higher demand for psychiatric services. This likely reflects frequent, direct patient contact among psychiatrists/psychiatric professionals, supervisory and complex case responsibilities among senior medical staff, and greater overall exposure to cases among long-serving professionals, all of which indicate the need for continuous learning and ongoing competency development. The primary care health workers dealing with a huge number of patients need to understand the critical role of early psychiatric services in patient prognosis and also need extensive knowledge.
Furthermore, medical staff in public health, management, imaging, and laboratory
professions also report greater demand for psychiatric services than clinical and
nursing staff. The demand may likely be due to population-level responsibilities
(public health), policy and resource planning (management) and the need to
interpret laboratory findings in the context of psychiatric presentations
(imaging and laboratory). In contrast, clinicians and nursing staff are more
focused on acute care, which may reduce training needs. Consistent with
expectations, higher psychiatric knowledge scores were observed among
psychiatrists/psychiatric nurses, those with
We acknowledge that this study has several limitations. First, it is a
single-center, cross-sectional survey conducted in Tongxiang city, China, which
limits the generalizability of the findings to regions with different healthcare
systems, cultures, and economic contexts, warranting multi-center studies across
diverse regions of China. Second, our statistical analysis relied on
non-parametric tests and did not adjust for potential confounding factors using
multivariate regression models. Thus, future studies with larger sample sizes
could employ multiple linear or logistic regression to better estimate the
independent effects of variables such as job position, years of service, and
training participation on knowledge scores and training needs. Third, the very
high Cronbach’s
Primary care providers demonstrated foundational mental health knowledge, with significant inter-individual differences. Demand for mental health service training was uniformly high. Preferences for short-term, blended training formats and barriers of time constraints provide critical empirical evidence for informing the development of targeted training programs. Future research should implement and rigorously evaluate the effectiveness of such programs in improving clinical practices and patient outcomes.
To address these gaps, short-term intensive training courses that combine online and offline (in-person) approaches/components are recommended, with streamlined theoretical content and training programs or curricula tailored by position/role, professional title, and years of service. Policy guidance and incentive mechanisms should be used to enhance mastery of core mental health content. Furthermore, based on the significant disparities in mental health knowledge across job positions, a stratified training approach tailored to specific occupational roles should be implemented. For instance, psychiatric medical staff/clinicians, who had the highest scores, would benefit from advanced, case-based decision-making modules to further refine their diagnostic and intervention skills. Clinical physicians and nurses, who play a supplementary role in mental healthcare, should receive training on identification, referral, and basic psychosocial interventions. Similarly, public health workers and technicians should prioritize foundational mental health literacy and public health-oriented content.
• Grassroots medical workers demonstrated moderate-to-high baseline awareness of mental health challenges.
• Over 80% reported high training demand in both knowledge and skills, with some items exceeding 90%.
• Short-term workshops were the most preferred approach, with centralized lectures and distance education as favored formats.
• Key factors influencing participation in training included job requirements, career development needs, and workload constraints.
• Significant differences in training needs were observed across job positions/roles, specialties, titles, and service duration.
• Mental health knowledge scores were significantly affected by job role, years of service, and prior engagement in mental health work.
All data included in this study are available from the corresponding authors upon reasonable request.
YYM, CDT and JZ designed the research study and wrote the first draft. YYM and CDT performed the research. YYM analyzed the data. All authors contributed to the important editorial changes in the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript. All authors have participated sufficiently in the work and agreed to be accountable for all aspects of the work.
The study was approved by the Medical Ethics Committee of Kangci Hospital of Jiaxing (Approval No. 2025-LUNLI-013). All procedures performed in compliance with the Declaration of Helsinki. All patients provided informed consent.
Not applicable.
This study is supported by Zhejiang Province Medical and Health Science and Technology Plan Project (No. 2024XY180).
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
References
Publisher’s Note: IMR Press stays neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
