Academic Editors: Morris Karmazyn and Victor L. Serebruany
Invasive cardiovascular procedures which include heart transplantations, congenital heart surgery, coronary artery bypass grafts, cardiac valve repair and replacement, and interventional cardiac electrophysiology procedures represent common mechanisms to treat a variety of cardiovascular diseases across the globe. The majority of these invasive approaches employ antibiotics as a regular and obligatory feature of the invasive procedure. Although the growing incidence of bacterial resistance to currently used antibiotics threatens to curtail the use of all interventional surgical techniques, it remains an underappreciated threat within the arsenal of cardiovascular therapies. It is reasonable to expect that the continued overuse of antibiotics and the frequent management of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) infected patients with high doses of antibiotics will inevitably accentuate the rise of multidrug resistance. The purpose of this article is to heighten awareness of the role of bacterial infections in cardiovascular disease, the use of antibiotics in today’s cardiovascular surgical theaters, the threat facing cardiovascular surgery should multidrug resistance continue to rise unabated, and the development of new antibiotic platforms to solve this problem.
Although life style, diet and behavioural changes play an increasingly important therapeutic and preventative role in cardiovascular disease (CVD) , cardiac surgery remains a valuable and integral clinical tool to address heart and vascular disease. It is not a coincidence that invasive cardiovascular surgical procedures became prominent in the 1920’s at about the same time that antibiotics were developed. Generally, the primary forms of cardiovascular invasive procedures used today are heart transplantation, congenital heart disease, coronary artery bypass grafts (CABG), percutaneous coronary artery interventions (PCI), cardiac valve repair and replacement, and interventional cardiac electrophysiology procedures (Table 1, Ref. [2-9]). Just these invasive cardiac surgical procedures total about 2 million per year in the USA alone. Without antibiotics to combat the bacterial infections that inevitably accompany these surgeries (with the exception of PCI in which infection is not common), their valuable life saving utility would not be possible.
|Surgical Intervention||Annual Incidence of Use||Year Introduced|
|Congenital heart disease||1938|
|Cardiac Electrophysiology Pacemakers||1958|
|Total cardiovascular surgeries/yr||1,898,000|
|Data are from references [2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9]. CABG, coronary artery by-pass graft; PCI, percutaneous coronary intervention; TAVR, transcatheter aortic valve replacement.|
The types of bacterial species found to infect patients during cardiovascular surgery are varied. Staphylococcus aureus, particularly the methicillin-resistant type (MRSA), has received the most research and clinical attention due to its prevalence and the clinical challenges it generates. However, many other bacterial species are of concern in cardiovascular sugery (Table 2). A recent systematic review of 12 studies documented the presence of Yersinia sp. in infective endocarditis, most commonly in the mitral valve but also in the aortic valve . Aminoglycosides, cephalosporins and quinolones were used to deter the fever, sepsis and heart failure that was found to accompany these Yersinia infections . Corynebacterium jeikeium has also been found as a rare cause of infective endocarditis . Actinetobacter baumannii and Actinetobacter calcoaceticus complexes are becoming a serious problem in intensive care units, particularly as these species become increasingly resistant to conventional antibiotic therapy. Actinetobacter iwoffii has also been identified as an infective species. The aortic valve was most commonly involved. Aminoglycosides, cephalosporins and carbapenems were the usual antibiotic therapy administered. A combination of a cephalosporin and an aminoglycoside was used in 78.5% of the cases in one study . The antibiotic therapy was successful in 70.3% of the cases and overall mortality was 32.4% . An invasive species of Enterobacter cloacae has been identified in transplant recipients  as has Nocardia bacteraemia . In over 1000 clinical samples collected from patients suspected of heart infections, 57% contained gram negative bacterial growth . Of the 109 different gram negative bacteria isolated, 40% were Escherichia coli, 30% were Klebsiella pneumoniae . Oral flora like Rothia aeria and Rothia dentocariosa have been recovered from patients during cardiac surgery and have been suggested to be rare but significant causes of infective endocarditis .
|Staphylococcus aureus||Actinetobacter baumannii|
|Actinetobacter calcoaceticus||Actinetobacter iwoffii|
|Enterobacter cloacae||Nocardia bacteraemia|
|Escherichia coli||Klebsiella pneumoniae|
|Rothia aeria||Rothia dentocariosa|
|Yersinia sp (Y. pestis, Y. enterocolitica and Y. pseudotuberculosis)|
Antibiotics are required for use in cardiovascular surgery to prevent or treat bacterial infections described above that inevitably occur post-surgery. Catheter-related bloodstream infection is a serious complication associated with increases in morbidity, mortality and escalating health care costs . It is important to recognize that although this is not a cardiac specific problem, it does have an important impact on cardiac surgeries. In a 1990 survey of surgical members of the American College of Chest Physicians, the overwhelming majority of respondents gave prophylactic antibiotics for their invasive cardiovascular procedures and today they are used routinely (Table 3, Ref [12,19]). Infections associated with invasive cardiovascular procedures are not solely a problem for chest surgery.
|Surgical Procedure||Frequency of Antibiotic Use (%)|
|Cardiac Valve Surgery||96|
|Coronary Artery Bypass Graft Surgery||91|
|Electrophysiological Surgical Procedures||78|
|Congenital Heart Surgery||routine*|
|Electrophysiological procedures include pacemakers and defibrillators. Data are from LoCicero, 1990  and *.|
Mediastinitis is an inflammatory infection of the mid-chest due to perforation of the esophagus and deep sternal wound infections. It is a serious acute or chronic complication that can accompany every cardiac surgery that involves a sternotomy . Post-operative infections occur at an incidence rate of 1–18% in children with delayed closure of the sternum . Increased morbidity and mortality as well as increased costs are associated with post-operative infections . As early as the 1960’s, placebo-controlled trials clearly demonstrated the benefits of the use of antibiotic prophylaxis for the treatment and prevention of bacterial infections post cardiac surgery [22,23]. Limiting the use of antibiotics or antibiotic resistance to surgical site infections generally and sternal and mediasternal infections specifically have significant ramifications for both mortality and morbidity, in addition to the economic implications in lengthened hospital stays and extra drug expenses [20,24,25].
The clear benefit of antibiotic administration post cardiac surgery has led to the development of guidelines for the use of antibiotics. These guidelines advise on both the type of antibiotic to use as well as the duration and timing of the intervention. The type and dosages currently recommended for use in the various surgeries has, however, evolved over time and experiencial usage. Over thirty years ago, cardiac surgical procedures used cephalasporins over 89% of the time. Of these, 57% were early generation cephalosprins and 32% were late generation . Penicillin was employed 1.7% of the time and aminoglycosides 0.7% . In the 1990’s, patients who were allergic to penicillin were administered cephalosporins 44% of the time, vancomycin 35%, clindamycin 11% and aminoglycosides 5% of the time . Twenty percent of cardiac surgeries delivered no pre-operative or intra-operative antibiotics. Approximately 35% of surgeons delivered antibiotics for 4 hours after surgery with 28% employing a 6-hour duration of delivery . By 1999, 94% of sugical centers were using first or second generation cephalosporins for perioperative antibiotic therapy for 24 hours, but never exceeding 76 hours . More recently, the most used prophylaxis regiment employed second generation cephalosporins together with aminoglycosides .
In postoperative situations, less consensus was apparent. Twenty-nine different
antibiotics from 8 subclasses were employed . By 2007, the Society of
Thoracic Surgeons Practice Guidelines recommended the use of
Pre-operative administration of antibiotics like cephalosporins for 1 hour
before skin incision has now been recommended and should be continued for 48
hours after the completion of cardiac surgery [27,29]. Two grams of cefazolin is
recommended for patients weighing
In 2014, The World Health Organization published an extensive report “Antimicrobial resistance: global report on surveillance 2014”, officially recognizing the rapid spread of multidrug resistance as a global threat . In 2020, the World Health organization stated that “anti-microbial resistance is one of the top ten global health threats facing humanity” . It is important to put this rather dire prediction in perspective. In the past, the primary causes of death at the turn of the 20th century which continued through its early decades were bacterial in origin—pneumonia, dysentery, enteritis, diphtheria and tuberculosis . These diseases were controlled through the discovery of antibiotics and their eventual regular use in medical practices by the third and fourth decades of that century were major factors in reducing the rates of death and increasing our life span throughout the 20th century and into the present day. Unfortunately, antibacterial resistance was observed  soon after the initial discovery of antibiotics in the 1920s and a multidrug resistant bacteria was identified as early as 1955 . Each new class of antibiotics was subsequently followed by the appearance of resistance to them . Drug development became less profitable which led to large pharmaceutical companies leaving the field, further worsening the problem .
In 2013, the Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimated that 2 million people get ill each year in the United States from antibiotic-resistant infections . By 2019, that estimate had increased to at least 2.8 million antibiotic-resistant infections with more than 23,000 deaths each year . Of note, methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus was identified as one of the “Serious Threats” in this document. In 2018, there were 250,000 resistant bacterial infections in Canada, and more than 5400 directly related deaths . It is predicted that by 2050 about 10 million deaths globally each year will be attributed to bacterial resistance, which will exceed deaths from cancer .
Multidrug resistance has economic as well as health implications. It is expensive to develop new antibiotics but it has become apparent that a lack of useful antibiotics is even more expensive . Antibiotic resistance was estimated to cost the Canadian healthcare system $1.4 billion/year in 2018 . Canada’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP) was estimated to be reduced by $2 billion in 2018 due to multidrug resistance . Within less than 10 years, antimicrobial resistance is predicted to drive 24 million people globally into extreme poverty . The costs to the world economy would be expected to exceed $100 trillion .
Overuse of antibiotics in therapy for humans, as well as for farm animals and fish in aquaculture is implicated as a major reason for the rapid spread of bacterial multidrug resistance on a global scale. Bacteria, including non-pathogenic bacteria in the environment, are exposed to sublethal concentrations of antibiotics creating a powerful selective pressure resulting in resistance to multiple antimicrobials . These resistance genes accumulate on plasmids which can be transferred laterally amongst different bacterial species and insures resistance continues to evolve and grow .
The molecular basis for the evolution of drug resistance in bacteria has been
studied extensively. There are four main mechanisms of resistance. Multidrug
resistance in bacteria may be achieved by upregulation of multidrug efflux pumps
via random mutations [46,47]. Multidrug efflux pumps are able to extrude a wide
variety of compounds making them one of the driving forces behind multidrug
resistance . In addition, resistance can be achieved through a decrease in
membrane permeability by down-regulation of bacterial porins, or via alteration
of drug binding sites to deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) via chromosomal mutations in
the ribosome, or, finally, by inactivation of the drug via its modification by
aminoglycoside modifying enzymes and
Over a century ago, the Hemagglutinin Type 1 and Neuraminidase Type 1 (H1N1) influenza A pandemic wreaked havoc on the health of the world. About one third of the world’s population died, most likely not due to the influenza virus itself but due to secondary bacterial infections like pneumonia [50-52]. Collonising the lungs with opportunistic pathogenic bacteria like Staphylococcus aureus and Staphylococcus pneumoniae were the likely deadly suspects . With this knowledge in hand, it was suspected that physicians would increase their usage of antibiotics during the current COVID-19 pandemic. Indeed, the overall number of antibiotic prescriptions in the UK during the pandemic increased significantly (6.71%) according to National Health Service of England data despite a growing trend since 2014 to reduce the use of antibiotics . Additional preliminary evidence supports the contention that broad spectrum antibiotics are used increasingly during the COVID-19 pandemic . A review of current literature found that 72% of hospitalized COVID-19 patients received antibiotics, while only 8% actually demonstrated bacterial or fungal co-infections . A more extensive meta-analysis of antibiotic use in COVID-19 patients demonstrated the prevalence of prescribing antibiotics in COVID-19 patients was 75% . The prescription of antibiotics was higher with increasing age, higher in those on mechanical ventilation and lower in children . With the estimated incidence of bacterial co-infection at 9%, it is clear that over-prescription of antibiotics is rampant during the current COVID-19 pandemic . Indeed, up to 70% of antibiotic usage in COVID-19 patients was not indicated clinically .
This has led to the inevitable conclusion that the escalating and unnecessary use of high dose antibiotics to curb the current COVID-19 pandemic will accelerate multidrug resistance [52,55]. Significantly, countries like India are already showing disturbing trends. COVID-19 and secondary bacterial co-infection rates were higher and resulted in an increased incidence of death . It is, therefore, again reasonable to expect that the estimates of the rise of bacterial resistance to antibiotics created prior to the COVID-19 pandemic may have underestimated the time line of its impact on health care in the coming years.
It is important, however, to recognize that these data and the concerns about antibiotic overuse are dependent upon the period studied and the country investigated. A recent study of antibiotics usage in 204 countries revealed a 46% increase in the daily consumption of antibiotics globally from 2000 to 2018 . The specific country examined influenced usage significantly (9 fold) from its low in the Philippines to a high of 46 defined daily doses of antibiotics per 1000 population in Greece . This likely reflects differences in admission procedures, hospital capabilities and capacities. High income countries have a more than three times higher rate of antibiotic usage than low and middle income countries .
Simply adding up the numbers of surgeries currently estimated for CABG, PCI, heart transplants, interventional electrophysiological procedures and cardiac valve replacements from the figures above, 2.5–3 million cardiovascular surgical interventions would be expected to occur in the USA alone each year (Table 1). Denying all or even a fraction of these patients access to these, in many cases, life-saving surgical interventions, would have a drastic effect on the overall health status of Amnericans. Increases in death rates and decreases in average life span, a rise in hospitalization rates and increased length of hospitalization stays would also be expected to develop. One would expect similar implications for the world’s population with orders of magnitude greater numbers involved. It is unlikely that the expected global death rate estimated for 2050 described in the preceding section takes into account the diminished, delayed or complete removal of access to life saving cardiovascular surgery that will inevitably accompany the development of bacterial resistance to all antibiotics.
However, is there any emerging evidence of multidrug resistance bacteria
appearing in the cardiovascular surgical theatre or is this an idle threat at the
present time? A body of data on rapidly spreading multidrug resistance in
bacterial species implicated in cardiovascular maladies and invasive treatments
is accumulating, including Helicobacter pylori,
Porphyromonas gingivalis and Chlamydia pneumoniae. In a Brazilian case report, a 59 year old male heart transplant patient
went into septic shock and multiple organ failure leading to death 50 days post
transplantation due to infection with multidrug resistant Klebsiella
pneumonia. In China’s Wuhan Hospital, of 299 heart transplant
patients, 49.2% were found to be infected with 259 different pathogens . Of these 147 infected patients, 64 multidrug resistant bacteria were
detected within one year after the transplant. Extended spectrum
The challenge of multidrug resistant bacteria is not restricted to cardiac transplantation surgeries. Patients undergoing a variety of cardiac surgeries (including open heart surgery) have shown evidence of infectious complications with multidrug resistant bacteria varying in incidence from 0.6%  to 10% . Patients with multidrug resistant infections had a higher mortality rate than those infected with non-multidrug resistant bacteria . More severe illness with multidrug resistant bacteria was also observed . E. coli,S. aureus and Acinetobacter baumannii strains were identified as the multidrug resistant strains present [67,68]. Recurrent infections with a multidrug resistant Pseudomonas aeruginosa bacteria has been identified during repeated triscupid valve replacements with aortic valve homografts employed to treat relapsing tricuspid valve endocarditis . Multidrug resistant P. aeruginosa bacteria have also been identified following implantation with left ventricular assistant devices [70,71]. In pediatric cardiac surgery cases, the rate of multidrug resistant cases was 3.8% in 2973 patients . Interestingly, multidrug resistant bacteria was more often found in children admitted from other hospitals in comparison to children admitted from home . In clinical samples collected from patients suspected of heart infections, where the majority of the bacteria identified were E. coli or K. pneumoniae, 58% of the gram negative bacteria were resistant to ampicillin and 48% were resistant to nalidixic acid in susceptibility tests . Over half of the bacterial isolates were multidrug resistant . It is clear from these studies that multidrug resistant bacteria are not only present currently in invasive cardiovascular surgical procedures but its emergence is increasing .
For most of the history of antibiotics, the standard pharmaceitcal approach has been to develop antibiotics that can be used for many situations without the need to first identify the cause (Fig. 1, Ref. [74-82]). These broad-spectrum antibiotics affect unintended and often non-pathogenic bacteria in the environment, which act as reservoirs for the development of multidrug resistance . Broad-spectrum antibiotics also have a huge impact on the human gut microbiota, frequently resulting in an overgrowth of Clostridium difficile. The multiplicity of molecular mechanisms underlying multidrug resistance has led to the search for different approaches in new anti-infectious strategies, including (in the addition to the development of new antibiotics) drug re-purposing. An idea to abate the problem associated with broad spectrum antibiotics is to generate/design narrow-spectrum antibiotics . Narrow-spectrum antibiotics, conversely, are largely ignored by unintended targets and, therefore, would not be expected to have a major impact on multidrug resistance development. In the antibacterial pipeline there has been an upward trend in the development of narrow-spectrum antibiotics . However, the use of narrow-spectrum antibiotics must be coupled with rapid and accurate diagnosis. An innovative idea to overcome existing resistance mechanisms is to produce antibiotic hybrids, which are two different antibiotic types or an antibiotic and an adjuvant covalently bound . Other approaches which are currently being explored include antimicrobial peptides, anti-virulence compounds, phage therapy , structural analogues of existing antibiotic platforms and novel platforms of drug development [76,79]. However, a new platform for antibiotics has not been introduced into the marketplace for over 40 years. If this continues unabated, pathogenic bacteria will challenge our health care systems as they did in past centuries. An exciting new approach has been to specifically target bacterial energetics instead of the conventional targets of membrane integrity, protein synthesis and DNA replication [76,79]. The inhibition of bacterial respiration represents a novel platform that also enjoys the secondary consequence of inducing cell suicide by the generation of reactive oxygen species [76,79]. However, this approach, like phage therapy and many other novel advances, has yet to be successfully employed clinically.
Current approaches for drug development to combat antibiotic resistance. These strategic approaches include phage therapy, antimicrobial peptides, anti-virulence compounds and the development of novel drug designs.
Pathogenic bacteria, particularly a wide array of gram negative bacteria, continue to represent a challenge to invasive cardiovascular surgery of all kinds and cardiovascular diseases in general. The development of antibiotics that are immune to the resistance currently displayed by pathogenic bacteria will be critical if the fate of cardiovascular surgery is to be retained in even a facsimile of what it is today. The crisis facing the world should bacteria continue to develop resistance to current antibiotic therapies, as is predicted for the future, will revolutionize medicine as it is practiced today. The pharmaceutical industry must meet this impending challenge with novel antibiotic platforms that have the potential to avoid multidrug resistance [76-84].
GNP created the idea for the manuscript topic, carried out initial research and wrote the first draft. ED, PD, AR, CR and MM contributed to the writing of the paper and provided critical input. MM designed and created the figure. All authors contributed to editorial changes in the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
We would like to express our gratitude to all those who helped us during the writing of this manuscript. Thanks to all the peer reviewers for their opinions and suggestions.
This work was supported by a Foundation Grant from CIHR to GNP, and an NSERC grant to PD.
PD is the Chief Scientific Advisor for Viotika Life Sciences, Inc.