We review the neurological bases of emotions and anxiety-related behavior,
integrating contributions from the medical, biological, cognitive neuroscience,
and psychological sciences. In particular, we discuss recent affective
neuroscience of anxiety-related neurological circuits and
metabolic-neuroendocrine systems and their dynamic interaction. This interaction
is a delicate process during which can render the brain more capable of reacting
to anxiety in adaptive or maladaptive into the most critical deficit in emotional
regulation associated with risk for psychopathological conditions. The essence of
this associated risk involves the reciprocal influence between
hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal function, the relay nucleus within the amygdala
reactivation, and the hippocampus as essential structures associated with the
forebrain pathways mediating threat-induced hormones and the
Affective neuroscience involves the dynamic interplay of multi-level brain interactions associated with generating emotional experience parallel with cognitive processes that are perceived to have a substantial influence on behavioral intents [1]. Individual affective states are likely to evolve converging on complex neural dynamics of emotions that need to be conceptualized and consciously linked to the multicomponent of cognitive processes from which they emerge as adaptive responses in anticipation of stimuli that threaten to disturb homeostasis [2, 3, 4, 5]. The brain mechanism of affect underlying perception and cognitive appraisal of a situation is likely to activate specific brain circuits that instigate to affective experience related to the behavioral responses associated with fear and anxiety [6, 7]. Collectively, these mental representations of the interpreted context on the subjective quality of affective states are an essential contributor to future emotional and behavioral tendencies [8, 9]. This behavioral experience accompanies spontaneous physiological and emotional reactions. Steimer (2002) identified that these reactions which are associated with emotions, ultimately facilitate adaptive responses to environmental challenges and boost memory presentation, to a certain extent enabling the famous “fight or flight” reaction. The human brain and its context-dependent response functions, including cross-level integration of signalling structures and circulating hormones, are sophisticated and flexible. The study of Raz et al. (2012) examined emotions emerging from the neurodynamics of many interacting brain systems, like how neurons behave in relations to emotions can have a substantial influence on cognitive processes and impact different systems that have specialized functions in executing body activities [10, 11]. In this intriguing reciprocal connection, underlying emotional processing in the brain transmits to bodily changes associated with emotion-specific expression, cognition, and motivated behavior to even assimilate the conscious experience of being fearful.
Interacting areas of the brain are structurally interrelated, enabling flexible coherent functioning, such as the limbic system [12, 13]. The system is conceived as an essential component of the emotional brain where interacting subcortical structures meet the cerebral cortex [14, 15]. The amygdala located near the hippocampus, interconnecting with other components of the limbic system, is responsible for many aspects of emotions, including recognition of facial expression of fear and anxiety-related memories [16, 17, 18]. Alternatively, the amygdala may register emotional stimuli and initiate coordinated physiological and behavioral responses that underlie defensive reactions [19, 20]. Some studies have shown, using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), that these brain regions where the amygdala as being directly responsible for immediate reaction associated with conditioned fear, become active when experiencing anxiety [21, 22] which generally helped to shed light on the underlying neurobiological causes of anxiety [23, 24]. The limbic system attends a variety of functions. In addition to its involvement in metabolism, it controls the physical and psychological responses to environmental stimuli, especially those with emotional content [25, 26]. Together with the hypothalamus, the amygdala produces autonomic components of feelings and is responsible for mediating all emotional responses and influence homeostatic mechanisms and neuroendocrine signalling [27].
Conversely, the close association between the amygdala and hippocampus provides complimentary action on emotionally salient stimuli and sub-optimal stress-related information, which generates responses through the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) and other effectors systems [28] (Fig. 1). In several imaging studies, the amygdala is found to mediate emotional reactions that modulate fear and anxiety behavior [29, 30, 31]. With its role as an integrative detective center for emotion, the hippocampus likewise plays an essential role in the formation of new memories and expression of adaptive emotional behaviors. The critical function of fear and anxiety acts as a signal of threat or motivational conflict, and thus triggers appropriate adaptive responses. Craig and colleagues (1995) underscored that anxiety is a generalized response to an unknown threat or internal conflict.
A schematic illustration of the brain’s complex circuitry mediating fear responses and anxiety behavior along with hormonal mechanisms responsible for hyperactivity of the HPA axis in response to a threat. When the brain receives a threat signal, the hypothalamus which is activated by the amygdala triggers the release of CRH. It funnels CRH to activate the Pituitary gland, which ultimately controls the other endocrine glands and body’s hormonal response to stress. This occurs via the action of CRH that stimulates the pituitary synthesis of ACTH as an interconnecting element of the HPA Axis. In turn, ACTH travels down the bloodstream and stimulates the adrenal glands located atop of both kidneys to secrete more stress and threat hormones including Cortisol, Adrenaline, and Noradrenaline and release them into the bloodstream to assist the body in handling threat or stress better resulting in higher levels of cortisol in the blood. However, prolonged high cortisol levels in the bloodstream exacerbate anxiety and interfere with the body’s natural self-repair mechanism. Hence, Cortisol’s far-reaching, systemic effects play numerous roles in the body’s effort to carry out its processes and maintain homeostasis. Correspondingly, these are the hormones, particularly cortisol, involved in the regulation of the HPA system that plays a vital role in anxiety-related disorders.
In contrast, fear is focused on known external danger, which implies a different mechanism of the neural circuit [32]. This response is likely to be mediated by a network of subcortical structures centered on the amygdala. To reiterate, the amygdala contributes to emotional arousal processing and is specifically involved in memory processes and motivation. Consistent with this view, some ablation and fear extinction studies showed that the amygdala is directly responsible for responding to threats that contribute to feelings of anxiety [12, 33, 34]. By the same intention, they found that patients with diminished feelings following amygdala damage may reflect the elimination of the indirect consequences of amygdala activity on feelings without increasing their negative impact [35, 36]. Another comparable investigation of Feinstein et al. (2013) inferred that a healthy amygdala might well usually serve to inhibit panic. In another empirical observation suggested that hyperactive amygdala can result in dramatic changes in emotional responses such as fear and anxiety responses [37]. These findings presumably indicate enormous evidence that the amygdala plays an essential role in processing emotions and anxiety states. However, some studies indicated that patients with amygdala damage can still feel fear, panic, and express pain [38, 39]. From the perspective of this empirical result, numerous experimental paradigms put forward the process by which the subjects modify the expression, the experience, and the physiology of their emotions, as a form of cognitive change characterized by adjusting the meaning of an emotional stimulus [40, 41, 42]. According to these experimental studies, which endeavored to apply emotion regulation strategies have made explicit that subjects can modify the behavioral expression, experience, and the bodily processes of their emotions [43, 44, 45].
In another study, LeDoux (2015) stressed, the amygdala is an essential part of the circuit that allows the brain to detect and respond to threats, but it is not necessary to feel fear. He added that once learned, the emotional and behavioral response occurs unconsciously and automatically. Indeed, embedded within this experience shifts, the emotional value of a stimulus is modified. The subject is expected to more automatic responses to match the newly acquired stimulus value [46, 47]. In this view, physiological, cognitive, and behavioral responses may simultaneously form the experience of emotion [48]. Specific limbic system structures, the hypothalamus, amygdala, and the hippocampus, deals with the basic drives, emotions, motivations, and memory that can have a substantial influence on the cognitive process [1, 49]. These regions work in concert to both generate and modulate fear responses to imminent and identifiable threats [50, 51], where the amygdala and the hippocampus carry out synergistically to form long-term memories of significant emotional events.
There are many processes associated with the limbic system. Still, the system is most frequently linked to emotion, and affective reactivity believed to involve such cognitive processes which in turn has to do with the role of a conscious effort to control innate behavior thought and feeling [1, 52, 53]. The essence of this point, suggests anxiety response starts in a region of the brain called the amygdala [54] and dorsal anterior cingulate cortex (dACC) process aversive signals and send output to the hypothalamus, basal ganglia, and brainstem to produce defensive behaviors [35, 55]. Supplementary to this study are the inquiries making impressive claims that, although it is held that the limbic system and in particular the amygdala because they have been identified with the highest density of neuropeptides that influence the activity of the brain and the body in specific manners [4, 7, 56, 57]. The investigation addressed that this mixture of neurotransmitters called neuropeptides travels throughout the body and the brain to support the experience of emotion through body-brain interactions [58, 59]. Neuropeptides presumably enhance the perception of multisensory signals, and in the case of threats, the signals are suggested to reach a threshold that triggers a fear response.
In an intriguing amygdala’s reciprocal connections with many brain regions are found to display high levels of neural activity involved in emotion generating actions that may initiate critical physiological and behavioral responses across the anxiety spectrum [35] (Fig. 1). It responds to a variety of emotional stimuli and interacts with emotional memory, mental state as well as focuses on automatic responses such as threat detection [6, 27]. Due to strong emotional content involved, fear is a triggered response and is linked with the functioning of the amygdala [60]. In the absence of the amygdala, the alarm in our brain that pushes us to avoid danger is missing [36]. The brain is the crucial organ of anxiety response because it determines what is potentially threatening, and therefore stressful [61]. It also regulates the behavioral and physiological responses to potentially stressful experiences. It determines how one should respond emotionally by using input from the subject’s stored knowledge. The hippocampus and the amygdala regulate the HPA axis, which mediates the fight or flight response [8]. Like the rest of the brain, the hypothalamus communicates with the rest of the body through the nervous system to shift the body’s energy resources towards fight or flight [62]. Tension triggers the HPA axis, a neuroendocrine system that regulates central and peripheral homeostatic adaptive responses to anxiety [63, 64]. The HPA axis regulates various bodily processes and is a vital component of the body’s neuroendocrine response and behavioral changes in mediating fear and anxiety [65].
When a threat is perceived, the body reacts by secreting stress hormones into the bloodstream. These are complex chemicals that convey messages throughout the body via the bloodstream and trigger specific anxiety responses (Fig. 1). The hypothalamus triggers the pituitary gland, which causes secretion and synthesis of another hormone called corticotrophin-releasing hormone (CRH) that enables the body to continue to resist the stress or threat until homeostasis is resumed [66, 50]. As outlined in Fig. 1, the CRH circuit stimulates the pituitary gland to secrete adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH) into the bloodstream. The anterior pituitary gland controls the secretion of ACTH in response to CRH from the hypothalamus. The adrenal gland receptors detect the high levels of ACTH, which also stimulate the secretion of cortisol. Often called the stress hormone, cortisol regulates energy-controlling blood sugar levels, mobilizes energy to target tissues and muscles, and reduces inflammation in the body. Cortisol concentration plays a vital role in the body’s stress response as an indicator of stress level [67]. However, when cortisol levels rise, the HPA axis starts to slow down the release of CRH from the hypothalamus and ACTH from the pituitary gland, as demonstrated in Fig. 1. As an adaptive response to a threat, the level of various hormones also changes. When threat or stress goes high, so does cortisol level [68, 69].
Correspondingly, ACTH levels start to fall when cortisol is high. As detailed in Fig. 1, the end-product of the HPA axis is cortisol and other stress hormones norepinephrine and epinephrine, which contribute to the inflammatory response. Cortisol, an essential glucocorticoid, has many significant functions in the natural processes of the body, involved in regulating metabolism, immune response, and general homeostasis [70]. Cortisol potentiates the body into a general state of arousal, giving that hyperactive and overwhelming influences on the affect [71]. To foster physiological response, cortisol tapped into proteins stored in the liver, provides the body with high amounts of glucose in the bloodstream, enhances brain’s use of glucose and increases the availability of substances that repair tissues, therefore, reducing inflammation [61, 72, 73].
The CNS coordinates all functions of the body systems, organs, down to the
primary functional unit - the neuron. Every behavior, emotions, and the essential
features of living interact in essential ways in the entire brain. How neurons
behave concerning emotions ultimately implicates for a central state of emotion,
like fear and anxiety. The HPA axis integrates the neuroendocrine functions as
well as regulates hormonal and neurotransmitter release, particularly the
Moderating the extent to which the GABA neurotransmitters connected to the
central nucleus of the amygdala are hence adequately positioned via synapses,
encourage synaptic inhibition [80]. As outlined in Fig. 2, these synapses are
tiny gaps filled with ions where communication takes place between neurons (axon
and dendrites) via neurotransmitters. These neurotransmitters are molecules that
travel from one neuron to another neuron to allow chemical transmission. They
cross a synapse between them to communicate with each other, as shown in Fig. 2.
Upon activation, the messages they send are believed to play a role in anxiety
regulation. GABA and its receptor activation can cause a massive increase in
chloride conductance through the cell membrane [81]. This facilitates a
regulatory role in maintaining a balance between neuronal excitation and
inhibition. When GABA molecules are released into the synaptic cleft, they bind
to their receptors. The latter receptors function to inhibit or reduce the
neuronal activity of the neurons by inhibiting nerve transmission, thereby
reducing unwanted brain excitability. This ultimately produces a calming effect
and helps to bring balance to the body and maintains homeostatic adaptive
responses to anxiety [79]. A synapse is a site of functional contact between
neurons that facilitate the transmission of impulses from one (presynaptic)
neuron to another (postsynaptic) neuron. Typically, when GABA binds to its target
protein receptors - known as GABA
Illustration depicting the brain circuits in the amygdala to include an inhibitory network of GABA interneurons to transmit neural information across the synapse. GABA has a structure of an amino acid. Neurotransmitters stored in synaptic vesicles that are positioned along the presynaptic membrane enhance molecular secretion to modulate anxiety responses. When a neural message reaches the axon terminal, the GABA neurotransmitter is released, carrying information across the synaptic gap to the receiving neuron (dendrite). GABA plays a vital role in reducing overwhelming feelings of anxiety by slowing down the signals or neuronal excitability throughout the nervous system.
Being highly involved in the emotional reactions when danger is perceived, the amygdala sends a distress signal to the hypothalamus which stimulates the sympathetic nervous system and triggers a cascade of hormones resulting in the final release of cortisol from the adrenal cortex situated atop the kidney [25, 83, 84]. Risks seem to be linked to the HPA axis releasing stress hormones abnormally [85], it not only causes anxiety and depression, but also affects the digestion, immune system, mood and emotions, sexuality, and energy storage and use, because the HPA axis involves these complex range of functions. Most body cells have cortisol receptors that elicit effects on many tissues under physiological conditions [86] (Fig. 1). In this regard, the manifestation of the HPA axis that transects with those of both anxiety dysfunction, is caused by tension and anxiety. Healthy body functioning can be disrupted when cortisol is released in excess due to prolonged activation of stress response systems in the body and brain. Thus, when a level of cortisol interacts with the hypothalamus, the HPA axis will slow down its activity to maintain hormonal balance within appropriate levels. In the presence of circulating hormonal factors, cortisol and other stress hormones via the bloodstream towards relevant organs, mobilize the body’s resources by increasing energy and decreasing inflammation, especially upon injuries. These systems-level physiological changes suggest that CRF plays an important role both in the development of a functional HPA axis and is a major integrator of adaptive responses in mediating anxiety-related behavioral consequences [87, 88]. However, the high levels of cortisol due to unrelenting anxiety can wear down the brain’s ability to function appropriately, including metabolism. Cortisol has been considered one of the main culprits in the stress-anxiety connection, although it plays a fundamental role in helping one cope with threats [54]. It can be enlightening to consider that anxiety disorders involve prominent disturbances of both cognitive and emotional regions deeply interwoven in the fabric of the brain that can be conceptualized as disorders of the emotional-cognitive brain [51, 52, 89]. Disturbances in how fear-inducing information is perceived and processed surges a defective pattern of thinking and leading to different psychological vulnerabilities and the emotional risks that go with it [12, 90, 91]. Anxiety is a subjective experience of discomfort in response to an actual or perceived threat via projections to the hypothalamus, visual cortex, and prefrontal cortex [92]. The perception of the threat depends upon the anxious, as one perceives threats about self, the world, or related to the future. This threat perception elicits a physiologic reaction associated with rapid heartbeat, blood pressure, sweating, and an overall sense of vigilance, exacerbating the activation of the primal response of flight or fight [93, 94]. In some cases, anxiety symptoms may persist even after the threat is gone. Yet, alterations in the HPA axis suggest the neurobiological basis of anxiety disorders with reported structural and functional differences that can manifest dispositional negativity across disparate psychopathologies [95].
Anxiety is not the same as fear, which is a response to a real or immediate threat and anxiety [96, 97]. Anxiety involves the expectation of future threats, is fear-based, and may occur unexpectedly, even in the absence of real danger. Craske and Stein (2016) indicated that those with heightened sensitivity to anxiety respond to those sensations with dread and pressing urge to escape a dangerous situation. Hence, anxiety can only be understood by taking into account some of its cognitive traits because a primary aspect of anxiety appears to be uncertainty, which is a negative effect on self-esteem leading to insecurity [98]. Thus, anxiety and insecurity are both fears for abstract threats that impede the ability to mitigate its adverse impact resulting in helplessness and isolation [99]. A moderate amount of anxiety helps subjects think and act more effectively and is a normal emotion under stressful circumstances of threat. Thus, mild anxiety is adaptive and sustains motivation for survival. It is characterized by adaptive emotion that prepares one both physically and psychologically for coping with an adverse event that could be dangerous [100]. Although adaptation is not easy, there have to be conscious efforts in part of the executive control system necessary to bring the body and mind in tune and coherence about executing a behaviour-the anxious feel vulnerable and weak between threat perceptions. Thus, the anxious often feels a sense of uncertainty and helplessness, becoming withdrawn with a distinct need for solitude [93, 101]. It is important to note that the entire process begins with negative thoughts due to stressful events and constant threats such as the COVID-19 pandemic that intensified over an extended period, escalating through, until panic attacks set in [102]. Intrusive thoughts build-up recurring concerns of risky situations involving threats and bring about the onset of anxiety and panic disorder. Symptoms are caused by feelings of extreme apprehension of impending doom that occur even in the absence of actual danger.
Adapting to anxiety involves physiological and psychological response stressing the destructive and stressful impact on what might happen in the future, such as the current COVID-19 pandemic. Thus, it is always future-oriented, fear-based, and focused on worrying over what is about to come, and conceivably one may become excessively anxious about the need for reasonable safety precautions [93, 103, 104]. Therefore, this leads to the thinking part of anxiety, which brings dominant symptoms of worry, which suggests always planning, looking ahead, trying to control circumstances, and a stressful urge to defeat a threat [105, 106]. In other words, anxiety is only a problem when it extends beyond legitimate worry in an unreasonable and disproportionate to the actual threat. Indeed, entrenched within a diffuse apprehension that is vague is associated with feelings of uncertainty and helplessness.
Increasing brain activity studies have made significant contributions to our understanding of the brain responsiveness to emotional perception in addition to biological processes through its mediation of fear and anxiety-related behavior. We gave much attention to mapping output hormonal pathways to identify a specific brain circuitry for the functional roles played by various brain regions and their mutual interactions, especially those that trigger an emotional response. The period when the brain, mind, and emotion are in synch highlights the connection between cognitive and emotional functioning. In a related manner, peripheral physiological changes can all go along with various emotional experiences that would support defensive psychophysiological adjustments. These representations reflect more closely to approximate parallel brain regions, and neural events are thought to be most directly involved in the development of cognitive-behavioral response. Accordingly, we refer to brain circuits that detect and respond to threats as physiologically self-protective functions, towards behavioral expressions in avoiding threats as defensive behaviors. Amygdala activation indicates a close interaction with the cortical brain region serves a pivotal role in cognitive and emotional functions, which dynamically influence the mental state.
To assess these essential considerations, this review has focused on understanding how the HPA stress and anxiety-response pathway, and the amygdala activation contribute to the circuitry underlying adaptive or defensive and pathological anxiety behaviors. Converging evidence provides significant insights that, although the emotional centers can appear to be out of control, perhaps especially when it continually senses threat signals, which could account that amygdala damage can result in. Correspondingly, the cortex has a mechanism in emotion processing, that filters out and controls the emotional input the cortex is receiving from the amygdala. This is expected because the amygdala serves as the interface between emotion and cognition, and with the help of the HPA axis, the amygdala, and the prefrontal cortex, modulate adaptive success. In this respect, much remains to be discovered to elucidate whether the neurochemical mechanism involved in GABA molecules in brain circuits relevant to anxiety processes, could provide valuable information regarding the psychobiology of anxiety and its reducing effects. Beyond question, it is entirely rational to be anxious. Taking specific action to control and focus on physiological responses underlying hormonal and molecular mechanisms that drive behavioral adaptation and resilience, help maintain a sense of normalcy. In the final analysis, neuroscience has much to offer to the psychology of human behavior, feelings, and both conscious and unconscious thoughts. Still, like any new approach, these contributions will take time to realize. Future work in this emerging field should focus on the intersection of biological and psychological theories and cognitive neuroscience.
We thank two anonymous reviewers for improving the quality of the paper. I-Code, Universiti Sultan Zainal Abidin, supported this research.
Authors declare that the research was conducted without any conflict of interest.