1. Introduction
Alzheimer’s disease (AD),
first described by German neuropathologist Alois Alzheimer in 1906 [1], is a
neurodegenerative disease characterized by various degrees of memory impairment,
cognitive dysfunction, and loss in daily living activities. According to medical
statistics, approximately 50 million people are suffering from AD globally,
accounting for 1/2–3/4 of all dementia cases. In fact, the majority of the
population is over 65 years old. With the increase in the number of aging people
around the world, the number of people affected will increase to 81.1 million by
2040 [2]. The reduction in the ability to perform daily life activities due to AD
puts an unsupportable financial burden on the families of the patients and the
government. Under these conditions, researchers are trying to find out more about
the progression and pathogenesis of AD. To our great delight, the last decades
have seen significant scientific progress in biochemistry, genetics, cell
biology, and neuroscience. These findings have broadened our horizons and created
more possibilities for AD research. Numerous epidemiological studies have shown
that aging and genetics are the main factors contributing to AD, followed by
brain damage, hyperlipidemia, diabetes, and obesity [3, 4, 5, 6]. The primary
pathogenesis of AD is extracellular amyloid plaque deposition and neurofibrillary
tangles within neurons, both of which comprise highly insoluble and dense
filaments [7]. Their complex pathogenesis has attracted the attention of
scientists and researchers. Several challenges are faced when figuring out the
exact pathogenesis of AD. At present, there are many hypotheses, including the
amyloid cascade hypothesis based on amyloid plaques, the tau hypothesis based on
neuronal fiber tangles, the inflammation hypothesis based on brain damage due to
prolonged inflammatory responses, the cholinergic and oxidative stress
hypothesis, and the neuroprotection hypothesis based on synaptic dysfunction and
neuronal death [8, 9, 10]. Because the factors involved in AD are complex and
influence a lot more than is known, currently, there are no satisfactory
prevention and treatment methods, although AD was proposed more than a century
ago. Here, we will discuss the risk factors and related mechanisms of AD
pathogenesis, as well as the potential of Chinese Medicine in the management of
Alzheimer’s Disease. This will not only contribute to further research on AD, but
also to the development of new drugs.
2. Amyloid Beta (A): The Potential Target for AD
The senile plaques formed by excessive extracellular deposition of A
induces a series of pathological reactions, which are significant factors in the
formation of AD.
2.1 The Generation of Amyloid Beta
Amyloid precursor protein (APP) is a
transmembrane glycoprotein widely found in mammalian cells. The APP is spliced by
the
-secretase and
the -secretase, both aspartate hydrolases,
to
generate A. The
-secretase is an intramembrane
protein expressed in various tissues and is concentrated at the synaptic of
neurons. APP can be broken down by
-,
-, and
-secretases.
When hydrolyzed by -secretase, it forms the soluble fragment
sAPP with C38 at the carboxyl terminus; the C38 is hydrolyzed by
-secretase to P3. The role of sAPP is neuroprotective, so
this pathway is not harmful to the organism. The -secretase and
-secretase splice APP
successively, then APP is broken down to
the A; when A is hydrolyzed by
-secretase, it
forms the soluble fragment sAPP at the amino-terminal and CTF
at the carboxyl terminus. CTF is then split by
-secretase into amyloid precursor
protein intracellular domain (AICD), and soluble A and
A, which are associated with the deposition of powdery plaques
[11]. A is a polypeptide comprising 39 to 43 amino acids. It can be
produced by various cells and circulates in the blood, cerebrospinal fluid, and
interstitium. Most A molecules bind to chaperonin molecules, and a few
exist in a free state. APP is cleaved by the BACE-1 enzyme into -APP and
C99; simultaneously,
C99 is catalyzed by -secretase to
produce A and A (see Fig. 1), the most common A
isomers in humans. A can easily enter the cerebral vasculature
and induce cerebral amyloid angiopathy; similarly, A is highly
hydrophobic and easily aggregates into oligomers, which have a toxic effect on
axons and synapses, leading to degenerative neuronal necrosis and synaptic
dysfunction, which then induces AD pathological changes [12]. Compared to
A, A is 1
to 1.5 times more in content, is more toxic, and is more likely to aggregate,
forming a core of A precipitates that can cause neurotoxicity [13, 14].
Fig. 1.
Amyloid precursor protein (APP), a transmembrane protein be
processed by both amyloid and non-amyloid pathways. A is produced
through the amyloid processing pathway. APP is cleaved by -secretase
into sAPP and CTF (C99) fragments, and then
-secretase cleaves C99 into A and amyloid precursor protein
intracellular domain (AICD) fragments. In the non-amyloid processing pathway,
-secretase cleaves APP into soluble sAPP and C83 fragments,
followed by -secretase-mediated cleavage of C83 into non-toxic P3 and
AICD fragments. Under pathological conditions, A is abnormally
increased, and A oligomers are formed, causing senile plaques.
2.2 The Amyloid-Beta Cascade
Hypothesis
Numerous studies have
shown that the pathology of AD is characterized by cortical atrophy, neuronal
cell death, neuroinflammation, synaptic loss, and the accumulation of two
well-defined pathological damages: neurofibrillary tangles (NFTs) and senile
plaques [15, 16]. NFTs are deposited within
neurons and consist of hyperphosphorylated tau proteins, whereas senile plaques
are generated extracellularly and are
mainly composed of faulty autolysosomal
acidification inducing autophagy of A in neurons [17].
Excessive deposition of A in the
brain is considered a major pathogenic factor [18].
Under normal physiological conditions,
A produced by the body can be cleared by glial cells, the lymphatic
system of the central nervous system (CNS), and receptor-mediated transport
across the blood-brain barrier; in contrast, when A is abnormally
deposited in the brain, it induces glial cells to release large amounts of
inflammatory factors, which then trigger inflammation, as a result, mediating the
production of A. The A hypothesis was derived in the 1980s from
A peptides isolated from the brain of patients with AD, confirming that
AD amyloid plaques are composed of A peptides. When A clearance
is dysfunctional, the equilibrium between A production and clearance is
disrupted. For example, when A acts on neurons, it can induce massive
apoptosis through various cell signaling pathways [19, 20].
Moreover, when A
accumulates at synapses, it impairs
synaptic plasticity, blocks long-term potentiation (LTP) effects, and reduces
learning memory in AD [21]. Then, excessive accumulation of A activates
glial cells, which on the one hand, can directly engulf the synapse, causing
synaptic damage and loss. On the other hand, glial cells release large amounts of
harmful substances such as inflammatory mediators and oxidative factors, which
trigger inflammatory responses and oxidative stress and upregulate BACE-1
activity [22], inducing excessive production of
A,
thus forming a vicious circle and promoting the development of AD suggesting that
the main pathogenic mechanism of AD is the generation of amyloid plaques by
A aggregation, and multiple lines of evidence support the idea that
alterations in amyloid processing can support the hypothesis of
AD. The pathophysiological model of AD
proposes a temporal sequence in which the production, clearance, or disruption of
both
A
initiates a biological cascade leading to the formation of A plaques
that spread throughout the cerebral cortex, followed by tauopathy, neuronal
dysfunction, neuronal death, and ultimately, dementia.
3. The Tau
Hypothesis
One of
the characteristics of AD is the development of neuronal fiber tangles (NFTs),
which are protein aggregates of hyperphosphorylated tau that are generated in the
brain. Tau’s post-translational modifications are a major contributor to tau
aggregation and neurodegeneration. The tau protein can transfer between neurons
transsynaptically and transneuronally [23], and the abnormal aggregation of tau
not only occurs intracellularly but also spreads to other areas of the brain
through various forms, starting from the entorhinal cortex, which may result in
diffusion-like pathological changes in adjacent brain areas or other brain areas
with synaptic connections. There have six tau
isoforms expressed in the adult human brain, including three isoforms have three
microtubule-binding repeats (3R) and three isoforms have four repeats (4R) [24].
The tau protein is associated with microtubules and involved in microtubule
assemble and stabilization. Abnormal phosphorylation of tau protein leads to
dissociation of tau protein from microtubules, which reduces microtubule
stability and promotes microtubule depolymerization, and the phosphorylated tau
protein aggregates into a paired helical filament (PHF) structure, which further
aggregates in neurons and leads to NFTs, affecting neuronal axoplasmic transport,
synaptic plasticity, and cytoskeletal stability, ultimately leading to dementia.
Phosphorylation of glycogen synthase kinase-3 (GSK-3) causes
tau filaments to coalesce into tangle-like aggregates, suggesting that
GSK-3 phosphorylates tau to promote tangle-like filament formation [25].
Tau accumulation causes synaptic malfunction, endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress,
inflammation, and mitochondrial dysfunction, ultimately resulting in
neurodegeneration [26]. However, ER stress and tau hyperphosphorylation stimulate
each other, leading to the intensification of tau phosphorylation. The
hyperphosphorylation associated with tau toxicity also predispositions tau
filaments to coalescence into neurofibrillary tangles [27]. Post-translational
modifications (PTM) are greatly altered in AD, and acetylation is an integral
part of PTM, involved in protein regulation, metabolism and stress response.
Acetylation modifications make tau protein insoluble by neutralizing the
repulsive effect of positively charged lysine residues, promote tau aggregation,
and inhibit pathological tau degradation. Acetylation neutralizes the repulsive
reaction of positively charged lysine residues. Since the charge repulsion
between the positively charged side chains is less, the charge neutralization of
lysine by acetylation makes the stacking of -chains in parallel
registers more favorable [28, 29]. Succinylation is a type of PTM, and increased
succinylation at key sites of APP and microtubule-associated tau not only
disrupts its normal protein hydrolysis process, but also promotes tau aggregation
into tangles and impairs microtubule assembly [30]. Similarly, ubiquitination
plays an important role in the pathogenesis of tau lesions, and in addition,
ubiquitination can affect the physiological state and pathological transformation
of tau in cellular condensates [31].
4.
Inflammatory Hypothesis
Neuroinflammation, a hallmark of AD, is an
inflammatory response in the CNS caused by a variety of factors, including brain
injury, infection, aging, and neurodegenerative diseases [32].
A-mediated glial cell activation is a key factor in triggering the
inflammatory response. Glial cells are the most numerous cells in the CNS, and
interact with neurons and immune cells [33]. In the early stages of AD, glial
cells activate a neuroinflammatory response, leading to a decrease in metabolism,
blood-brain barrier dysfunction, and energy impairment, which accelerates
neuronal death [34]. Although inflammation is a normal response of the body and
the process is important for protection under normal conditions, excessive
production of inflammatory factors can be damaging to some extent, more so in the
extremely sensitive CNS. Neuroinflammation causes neurodegenerative disease,
which is difficult to control and progressively deteriorates into a chronic
disease. There is growing evidence that the pathogenesis of AD extends beyond the
neuronal compartment and interacts closely with the immune mechanisms of the
brain [35, 36]. Microglia are widely
distributed in the brain. As immune sentinel cells in the brain, microglia play
an immune role in the CNS. Microglia are highly active in designated brain
regions [37]. They search for pathogens and cellular debris in specific areas,
respond to unfamiliar and dangerous signals, remove cellular and extracellular
debris, and regulate synaptic plasticity [38, 39, 40]. Microglia can differentiate
into two morphologically similar and functionally distinct cell subtypes, M1 and
M2, which play different roles in the inflammatory response depending on signals
from different injury environments. The M1 type, the classically activated
microglia, produce high levels of oxidative metabolites and pro-inflammatory
cytokines, such as IL-12, IL-1, IL-6, inducible nitric oxide synthase
(iNOS), and tumor necrosis factor- (TNF-), which contribute
to local antigen delivery, destroy invading pathogens, increase oligodendrocyte
death, and promote inflammatory responses and neuronal damage. The M2 type, the
selectively activated microglia are categorized as M2a, M2b, M2c, Mox, and so on,
which can secrete a multitude of anti-inflammatory cytokines, such as IL-4,
IL-10, vascular endothelial growth factor, transforming growth factor-,
and brain-derived neurotrophic factor. They have the ability to repair arginase
activity, inhibit inflammatory responses, and promote tissue repair and
functional remodeling [41]. When pathogens
or apoptotic debris are present in the organism, microglia are activated into an
amoeboid phagocytic form with large cell bodies and sparse, thick branches.
They rapidly migrate to the site of injury
to exert phagocytosis and release tumor necrosis factors. At the same time,
microglia help protect and remodel synapses [42], allowing neuronal circuits to
be maintained. Microglia in the brain are highly activated and can release
various immune and cytotoxic factors such as inflammatory cytokines
(TNF- and NO) as well as reactive oxygen radicals [43]. The
overproduction of these substances induces neuronal death, especially
TNF-, which has a dual nature: low levels are protective for the body,
but excessive levels cause inflammatory damage. TNF- mediates
neurotoxicity by binding directly to neuronal receptors on the one hand and
expresses more inflammatory cytokines by activating glial cells on the other. In
turn, the entry of TNF- into the brain activates the relevant receptors
on microglia, initiating a cascade reaction that leads to increased production of
TNF- and other pro-inflammatory factors [44]. Meanwhile, A
aggregates can induce the release of inflammatory mediators such as reactive
oxygen species (ROS), NO, and leukocyte mediators by activating microglia, which
ultimately leads to neuronal death. On the contrary, as the most numerous and
functional class of glial cells, astrocytes regulate ions and neurotransmitters
in the CNS environment by controlling neuronal metabolism. Under normal
physiological conditions, astrocytes rely on apolipoprotein E (APOE)
lipidation to enhance the ability of microglia to clear A. Increasing
evidence suggests that besides microglia and astrocytes, T cells are also
involved in the regulation of the inflammatory response in AD. With the
development of AD, the infiltration of T cells into the brain increases, and a
large number of T-cell-derived inflammatory cytokines from the peripheral blood
enter the brain, which ultimately increases neuroinflammation and accelerates
neuronal death [45].
5.
Synaptic Deficiency
Dendritic
spines are the protrusions at the synapse ends of neurons which consist of
cytoskeletal networks, scaffolding proteins, and surface receptors; these
receptors contain both N-methyl-d-aspartate (NMDA) and
-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methyl-4-isoxazolepropionic acid (AMPA) receptors.
Actin is the main factor affecting the shape and number of dendritic spines, and
the actin content of dendritic spines is about 6 times higher than that of
dendrites. The cross-linkage between F-actin and G-actin causes the dendrites to
change morphologically. Dendritic spines are divided into three categories
according to their shape: mushroom-shaped, stubby spines, and thin spines [46].
To study the effects on the presynaptic and postsynaptic neuronal compartments in
AD patients, Reddy et al. [47] quantified the number of synapses and
showed that there were 25–30% fewer synapses in AD brains than in controls and
that there were 25–30% fewer synapses in the cerebral cortex and 15–35% fewer
synapses per cortical nerve than in controls. At the same time, they studied and
compared the protein levels in frontal and parietal cortices of a large number of
AD subjects and healthy controls by immunoblot analysis, which showed that all
brain specimens from AD patients lost presynaptic vesicle proteins and
postsynaptic proteins, showing that postsynaptic and presynaptic proteins are
important for synaptic function in AD [47].
Synaptic loss is one of the most important
factors in cognitive decline in AD, and there is evidence that AD is primarily a
disease of synaptic dysfunction [48, 49], with A and tau oligomers
contributing to synaptic loss [50]. In addition to plaques and amyloid
angiopathy,
A
is multimerized into a series of oligomers [51]; soluble oligomeric forms of
A, a peptide that aggregates in the brains of AD patients to form senile
plaques, have been shown in vitro and in vivo to be toxic to
neuronal synapses. A oligomers inhibit long-term dementia (LTP) and
promote long-term depression (LTD), a memory formation electrophysiologically
relevant, thus functioning as a memory formation. In addition, oligomeric
A has been shown to cause synaptic loss and cognitive impairment in
animals [52]. Massive loss of synapses in the temporal region of the brain of the
patient is one of the features of AD [53], and synaptic loss is one of the most
important causal mechanisms of cognitive dysfunction in AD [54], with the most
severe areas of synaptic loss being in the vicinity of senile plaques, suggesting
that plaques may be a reservoir of synaptotoxic molecules such as A [55, 56, 57, 58]. When testing the hypothesis that oligomeric A around plaques
causes synaptic loss in a mouse model of AD,
Koffie RM
et al. [59] found that senile plaques are surrounded by an oligomeric
A halo. Analysis of over 14,000 synapses revealed a 60% loss of
excitatory synapses in the oligomeric A halo surrounding senile plaques.
This suggests that oligomeric A may be present in AD in balance with
plaques [59]. Moreover, one of the functions of microglia is to maintain the
homeostasis of the brain and eliminates inflammation caused by injury or
infectious microorganisms through phagocytosis. Although a small amount of
inflammatory response can protect the brain neurologically, once this homeostasis
is disrupted, continuous stimulation activates microglia to convert them into
harmful responses, leading to prominent dysfunction and neuronal death [60] (See
Fig. 2). A recent study that age affects the brain’s ability to activate
asparagine endopeptidase. Synapsin I is broken down by active AEP into the
synapsin I C83 fragment, which alters synaptic vesicle recycling, results in
synaptic dysfunction, impairs cognitive function, and aids in the development of
AD [61].
Fig. 2.
Structural differences
between the brain of a person with Alzheimer’s disease and a normal brain. When
synapses are lost, the structure of the brain changes significantly. Compared
with the normal brain, the neuronal cell in the AD brain dies, and the volume is
reduced.
6.
Oxidative Stress and Apoptosis
The accumulation of A in the brain is an important factor contributing
to neuronal apoptosis, and A can mediate the mitochondrial apoptotic
pathway, the death receptor pathway, and the endoplasmic reticulum apoptotic
pathway, which together induce apoptosis in neuronal cells. There is substantial
evidence that A disrupts the
electron transport chain by decreasing the activity of key enzymes [62].
A is the largest contributor to mitochondrial dysfunction, disrupting
mitochondrial dynamics and participating in ROS production. Metal ions such as Cu
and Fe play an important role in oxidative stress and are also involved in ROS
production. Cu and Fe can produce a complex with A, and this complex is
directly involved in ROS production; because the redox activity of Fe-A
is low, the production of ROS is mainly analyzed by examining Cu-A.
During ROS production, the A peptide is damaged by oxidation [63].
Mitochondria are the refueling stations of cells, and their core function is to
provide cells with the required energy, participate in the process of cell
generation up to apoptosis, and play an important role in the regulation of
apoptosis, calcium handling, and innate immunity [64]. Oxidative stress is a
cascade response resulting from an imbalance between oxidative and antioxidant
systems. When oxidative stress begins, free radicals such as ROS and reactive
nitrogen species are significantly elevated in the body. Free radicals are
continuously produced during the body’s metabolic processes; therefore,
antioxidant enzymes and antioxidant proteases are required to maintain redox
homeostasis by scavenging free radicals [65]. Although the brain is an extremely
oxygen-consuming organ, it has a relatively weak antioxidant capacity and is
therefore vulnerable to damage from oxidative stress. Oxidative damage is caused
to biomolecules during oxidative stress [66]. Oxidative stress can lead to
increased secretion of neutrophil inflammatory infiltrative proteases and the
production of large amounts of oxidative intermediates, ROS. ROS not only
directly damage the cells but also activates various oxidative and anti-oxidative
stress pathways. Oxidative stress is a negative effect of free radicals in the
body, which is an important factor in inflammation and aging. It has been shown
that APP undergoes cleavage to produce a large number of A molecules,
some of which remain in the neuronal lipid bilayer and evolve into A
oligomers through a series of reactions that cause channel-like active pores in
the neuronal membrane, which in turn contribute to increased calcium inward flow
[67]. Simultaneously, A can regulate calcium/calmodulin-dependent
protein kinase II, calcium phosphatase, protein phosphatase 1, and cyclic AMP
response element-binding protein (CREB) through N-methyl-D-aspartate
receptor-mediated regulation of calcium channels. CREB induces intracellular
calcium overload [68], and excess calcium and other metal ions increase
mitochondrial dysfunction, affecting various apoptotic signaling pathways and
even neuronal apoptosis. If calcium ion stabilization is dysregulated, it also
leads to increased levels of the pro-apoptotic protein Bax and decreased
expression of the anti-apoptotic protein Bcl-2 in the mitochondrial membrane.
Ultimately, the outer mitochondrial membrane is permeabilized, and neuronal
cytochrome c oxidase activity is reduced, allowing it to bind to apoptotic
protease activator-1, cysteine aspartate-specific protease 9 (caspase-9), forming
an apoptosome complex that activates caspase-3 and initiates the caspase protease
cascade reaction that mediates apoptosis [69]. When stimulated by A,
mitochondrial fusion proteins 1 (mitofusins, Mfn1) and Mfn2 are significantly
reduced, while division-related factors are highly upregulated, leading to
increased permeability of the outer mitochondrial membrane and massive release of
cytochrome c, which activates caspase-3 and ultimately triggers the apoptotic
pathway [70]. This suggests that A is highly susceptible to damage to
intracellular neuronal mitochondria, which induces oxidative stress and mediates
apoptosis.
7.
The Apolipoprotein E (APOE) Family
AD
is inherited as an autosomal dominant gene, and its lipoprotein e4 genotype
(APOE4) on chromosome 19 is the highest genetic risk. APOE is
part of the large lipoprotein (lipoprotein) family and plays a key role in lipid
metabolism [71]. APOE, a 34 kDa glycoprotein, is a plasma lipoprotein,
synthesized mainly by the liver and involved in systemic lipid transport [72].
APOE production and secretion have distinct cellular and tissue
properties [73]. APOE is abundant in the brain, is a chaperone of
lipoproteins, is mainly expressed by astrocytes, and can be transported to
neurons. Compared with astrocytes, microglia can take up ApoE from other cellular
sources. In addition APOE expressed by microglia may contribute to
neuronal damage in AD [74]. There are three allelic variants of APOE,
namely APOE2, APOE3, and APOE4, which differ in amino
acid composition, APOE2 (Cys112, Cys158), APOE3 (Cys112,
Arg158), and APOE4 (Arg112, Arg158) [75]. The difference in amino acid
sequences between these isoforms leads to different conformations.
Patients carrying the APOE4 gene differ significantly in the
interaction of APOE4 and A. A study spanning more than 6 years
showed that the interaction of the APOE isoform with A
increases the risk of
AD.
Mishra S and Blazey TM et al. [76] analyzed dates from a dominantly inherited
Alzheimer’s network regarding mutation non-carriers, asymptomatic carriers, and
symptomatic carriers from families with mutations in the preset protein 1
(PS1), preset protein 2 (PS2), or amyloid
precursor protein (APP) genes, and then, using linear mixed-effects models,
estimated the risk of 11C-Pittsburgh compound B and 18F-deoxyglucose by positron
emission tomography (PET) and structural magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). PET
and MRI can be used to assess the number and location of A plaques.
Finally, it was found that the rate of A deposition was significantly
different in mutation carriers compared to non-carriers, with elevated A
deposition in mutation carriers than in non-carriers, followed by a decrease in
metabolism, and finally, structural atrophy [76].
8. The Effect of Fatty Acids on Alzheimer’s Disease
Fatty
acids (FAs) can be broadly classified into three categories, saturated fatty
acids, monounsaturated fatty acids, and polyunsaturated fatty acids, based on the
saturation and unsaturation of the hydrocarbon chain. Studies have shown that
fatty acids can affect gene expression and metabolic responses not only by
altering intracellular and extracellular signaling pathways but also by altering
intracellular and extracellular signaling pathways in many different cells and
tissue types [77]. The recent study found Stearoyl-CoA desaturase (SCD) which is
a key regulator of fatty acid desaturation, inhibition of its activity in the
3xTg mouse model of AD brain alters core transcriptomic pathways associated with
AD in the hippocampus [78]. With the improvement of quality of life and lifestyle
changes, high sugar and high-fat diets (HFDs) have become an important part of
the contemporary diet. It has been found that the cerebral glucose metabolism of
AD patients is lower than normal, and the altered cerebral energy metabolism
increases the risk of AD [79]. The main pathological process of AD is the
aggregation of A, and the protein plaques in the AD brain are mainly
formed by the aggregation of A fibers, which are mainly formed by the
aggregation of monomeric A
peptides. Fatty acids and anionic
surfactants such as lipids are important factors affecting A nucleation
kinetics [80], where polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA) affect the interaction
between amyloid precursor protein (APP) and -secretase. A diet high in
unsaturated fatty acids can reduce amyloid accumulation and mitigate glial cell
activation, as well as affect mitochondrial energy homeostasis and the production
of inflammatory or pro-lysis immune factors, the production of mitochondrial
energy homeostasis and inflammatory or pro-soluble and immune regulators [81].
Simultaneously, short-chain fatty acids can inhibit NF-B
transactivation through GPR43-mediated oxidative stress, thereby reducing the
inflammatory response [82]. But lipid droplet accumulation in astrocytes and
microglia promotes inflammatory responses [83].
APP is a transmembrane protein, and its membrane-bound proteins are influenced
by membrane lipids, of which fatty acyl is a major component; on cell membranes,
fatty acyl enhances the activity of transmembrane proteins in cells. Lipids are
central in central metabolism and can directly initiate aging. Fatty acids can
enhance brain cell activity and memory, and thinking ability, and they are
present in large amounts in brain tissue and cerebrospinal
fluid.
Alfred N. Fonteh et al. [84] found that lipid metabolism leads to
abnormal processing of A. Neuropsychological measurements of
A in the cerebrospinal fluid showed that PUFA metabolism is associated
with amyloid and tau processing and that unsaturated fatty acids improve memory
and restore cognition.
9. Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) for the Treatment of Alzheimer’s
Disease
The drugs currently in clinical trials and
approved for the treatment of AD are all based on the regulation of excitatory
neurotransmitter transmission pathways, and they are all agonists or antagonists
of neurotransmitter production or neurotransmitter receptors. All these drugs
have different degrees of side effects in clinical use. For example, tacrine, the
first reversible acetylcholinesterase inhibitor approved for clinical treatment
of AD, was discontinued due to hepatotoxicity. The most common adverse effects of
donepezil, a reversible acetylcholinesterase inhibitor, are diarrhea, nausea,
vomiting, insomnia, fatigue, urinary incontinence, etc. So far, even though a
large number of clinical trials of AD drugs have ended in failure and the
efficacy of the drugs that have been approved for clinical use is unsatisfactory,
the search for a TCM to treat AD has never stopped.
TCM has long been a valuable source of medication, and research on herbal
medicine has developed rapidly in recent years. Many herbal medicines and
combinations have been shown to be effective in treating AD, with significant
improvements in cognitive function in clinical trials (Fig. 3). It is effective
in reducing A deposition and inflammation, maybe is a potential drug for
AD treatment.
9.1 Based on the Amyloid-Beta Hypothesis
The amyloid senile plaques in the brain of AD patients are caused by A
aggregation [85]; therefore, we can treat AD by re-establishing the dynamic
balance of A production and
clearance, wherein reducing A
production and increasing A clearance are both useful measures.
A is derived from -secretase and -secretase cleavage
APP, so reducing the activity of -secretase and -secretase can
effectively inhibit the production of A. -secretase, also known
as -site amyloid cleavage enzyme 1 (BACE1), is composed of 501 amino
acid residues, The protein amount and enzyme activity of BACE1 are higher in AD
brains than in normal brains, and the hydrolysis of APP can be inhibited by
decreasing the activity of BACE1, thus reducing the production of A [86]. Severin Filser et al. [87]
studied the effects of BACE1 inhibition on dendritic spine dynamics, synaptic
function, and cognitive performance and demonstrated that low doses of BACE1
inhibitors promoted the reduction of A production, and consequently,
high doses of BACE1 inhibitors caused synaptic damage as well as memory loss.
Jiannao Yizhi Formula (JYF) is commonly used in TCM clinics for the treatment of
AD. To investigate the long-term efficacy of JYF in treating AD, Hui-Chan Wang
et al. [88] recruited 60 patients aged 50–80 years with mild to
moderate AD and randomly assigned them to the treatment group (n = 30) and the
control group (n = 30). The treatment group was given 5 g of JYF orally twice
daily and 5 mg of donepezil placebo once daily, while the control group was given
5 mg of donepezil once daily and 5 g of JYF placebo twice daily. After 6 months
of treatment, the scores of the AD Rating Scale-Cognitive (ADAS-Cog) and Chinese
Medicine Symptom Scale (CM-SS) were tested. Compared with baseline, both JYF and
donepezil decreased the ADAS-Cog and CM-SS scores (p 0.05 or
p 0.01). Acetylcholine (Ach), A, and the
microtubule-associated protein tau were measured in the serum of patients by
enzyme linked immunosorbent assay. The results demonstrated that both drugs
increased the serum levels of Ach and decreased the serum levels of A
and tau (p 0.05). These results suggest that the effect and safety
of JYF for the treatment of AD were not inferior to those of donepezil and the
mechanisms were related to regulating the levels of Ach, A and tau in
serum [88]. -secretase is a complex consisting of PS1, PS2, and dull
protein, and mutation in PS1 and PS2 genes increases the production of the highly
amyloidogenic 42-residue form of amyloid-beta protein (A) [89].
Phytochemical studies reveal that inhibition of A aggregation is also
important. More than 140 compounds, including saponins, xanthones,
oligosaccharide esters, 3,6-disinapoyl sucrose (DISS), onjisaponin B (OB),
etc. have been isolated from Polygala tenuifolia [90, 91, 92] (Fig. 3). These
components have a wide range of pharmacological activities; among them, farcicin
saponins can reduce the aggregation of A, and DISS can improve the
cognitive deficits and pathological defects of hippocampal neurons in adult
APP/PS1 mice and increase the number of neurons [93]. CA-30, an oligosaccharide
extracted from LiuweiDihuang decoction (LW), consists of stachyose and
mannotriose. Jianhui Wang et al. [94] investigated the effects of CA-30
on senescence-accelerated mouse prone 8 (SAMP8) mice. The behavioral assessments
showed that CA-30 slowed down the aging of SAMP8 mice and also alleviated their
cognitive impairment; further radioimmunoassays showed that CA-30 balanced the
neuroendocrine system of SAMP8 mice. Long-term administration of LW or its active
ingredient has restorative and regulatory effects on the neuroendocrine-immune
system and intestinal microbiota in AD animal models and can reduce the
accumulation of A in model mice [94]. Danggui-Shaoyao-San (DSS), a
classic herbal formula, has been widely used in gynecological treatment [95].
There is substantial clinical evidence that DSS affects free radical-mediated
neurological disorders and has multiple effects on neurons. Previous studies have
shown that DSS has an antioxidant capacity, reduces inflammatory responses, and
attenuates apoptosis in the hippocampus [96]. Nobuaki Egashira et al.
[97] found that DSS could significantly reduce neuronal damage by
A while reducing neuronal death and lipid peroxidation in
primary cultured rat cortical neurons. Panax notoginseng saponins (PNS) contains
a variety of monomeric components that are widely used in the treatment of
cardiovascular and cerebrovascular diseases; furthermore, it is neuroprotective
by inhibiting -amyloid peptide (A) mediated apoptosis. In
addition, PNS has been reported to accelerate nerve cell growth, increase axon
length, and promote synaptic plasticity. Liu et al. [98] found that
because A could reduce the number of CA1 neurons in the hippocampal corpus by inducing
spatial learning and memory impairment in rats; the level of hyperphosphorylated
-secretase processing of APP at the Thr668 locus was increased, while
BACE1 and PS1 were downregulated. Rg1, a monomeric component of PNS, was
effective in ameliorating cognitive impairment and neuronal loss by reducing
APP-Thr668 phosphorylation and BACE1/PS1 expression to inhibit
-secretase shearing of APP, resulting in decreased A production
and increased degradation, thereby ameliorating cognitive impairment and neuronal
loss [98].
9.2 Based on the Tau Hypothesis
Initially, tau-based therapies focused on
kinase inhibition, tau aggregation, or microtubule stabilization, but most of
these approaches have been discontinued due to safety concerns. Currently, the
majority of tau-targeted therapies in clinical trials are immunotherapies.
Recently, therapies targeting tau proteins or tau-related pathways have been
proposed, such as small interfering RNA (si RNA) or antisense oligonucleotides
(ASOs) to reduce tau expression [99]. In addition, reduction of Tau with chemical
molecules may offer a novel strategy for treating AD [100]. Bushen-huatan-yizhi
formula, a common clinical prescription in traditional Chinese medicine, can
effectively reverse the decline of learning and memory ability in AD-like rats,
and its effective mechanism is to delay NFTs by reducing the high phosphorylation
level of tau protein, thus improving cognitive impairment [101]. In addition,
research shows that berberine improves tau
hyperphosphorylation and reduces axonal damage via restoring the PI3K/Akt/GSK3
signaling pathway, acting as a preventative agent against cognitive impairments
[27].
9.3 Based on the Inflammatory
Hypothesis
Neuroinflammation
is a factor in the pathogenesis of AD, so anti-inflammation is considered an
effective treatment. A promotes neuronal death by damaging mitochondria,
exacerbating neuroinflammation and oxidative stress, and long-term
neuroinflammatory reactions can cause serious damage to the brain. A multitude of
Chinese medicines is considered to have good therapeutic effects, Forsythoside A
(FA) is the main constituent of Forsythia suspensa (Thunb.). Its effects are
anti-inflammatory, antibacterial, antioxidant, and
neuroprotective [102]. At the same time, the
formation of pro-inflammatory factors IL-6, IL-1, and NO in
lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-stimulated BV2 cells could be reduced by FA treatment.
In exploring the effects of FA on double
transgenic (APP/PS1) mice, Chunyue Wang et al. [103] found that
FA-treated mice had a significantly shorter avoidance latency than the other
groups and spent more time crossing the effective area after removal of the
platform than the other groups. FA-treated APP/PS1 mice showed significantly less
A deposition and lower levels of phosphorylated tau protein in the
hippocampus than the other groups. The results of subsequent cellular experiments
were similar to the previous reports, confirming that FA could protect cells from
A and LPS-induced damages. In addition, FA could reduce
neuroinflammation in APP/PS1 mice [103]. Forsythoside B (FTB), one of the active
ingredients of Forsythiae, has been shown to modulate neuroinflammation, reduce
microglia and astrocyte activation, and
decrease microglia-mediated neurotoxicity in APP/PS1 mice via the NF-B
signaling pathway [104]. Raisins have
several active ingredients, including polyphenols, phenolic acids, and tannins,
which are antioxidant and anti-inflammatory, and these properties have been shown
to improve spatial memory in animal models of AD [105]. Matrine is an active
ingredient extracted from the TCM Sophora flavescens Alt., and it has good
anti-inflammatory effects. Matrine has been found to improve neuroinflammation
and memory impairment in AD mice [106]. Lei-gong-gen is a useful
anti-inflammatory agent whose active ingredient, triptolide, can inhibit
microglial activation and the release of pro-inflammatory factors. In addition,
it exerts biological activity in different types of brain cells [107].
9.4 Based on the Synaptic Deficiency
Carthamus
tinctorius L. is a common TCM widely used for bruises and injuries. Safflower
yellow (SY) is the active ingredient of Carthamus tinctorius L., and
Hydroxysafflor yellow A (HSYA) is the highest single active ingredient in SY.
Jiawei Hou et al. [108] used rats injected with A
bilaterally in the hippocampus as an AD model, and after treatment with SY and
HSYA for a period, they found improved learning and memory abilities and the
structural damage of dendritic spines and synaptic loss of the model rats, and
reduced deposition of A in these AD rats. Additionally, the loss of
synapse-associated proteins was alleviated, and glutamatergic cycling impairment
was improved. SY and HSYA have been proved to have the
effect of regulate excitatory
neurotransmitter transmission; furthermore, they could enhance the synaptic
structural plasticity of brain tissue and reduce the structural damage of
A1 dendritic spines in the gluteal region [108]. In addition,
Bushen-Huatan-Yizhi formula (BSHTYZ) is also widely used in the treatment of
dementia, which not only has a good effect of regulate excitatory
neurotransmitter transmission but also enhances synaptogenesis within the
neurons. Yang et al. [101] found that BSHTYZ is a potential compound
preparations for the treatment of AD by inhibiting the GSK-3/CREB
signaling. The involved mechanism of BSHTYZ was found to improve the
learning/memory ability of the rat AD model under the influence of A
through the inhibition of the GSK-3/CREB signaling pathway. They also
identified the “thin/mushroom” type of dendritic spines by Golgi staining and
observed a decrease in the population of “thin/mushroom” type dendritic spines
when rats were injected with A, but these dendritic spines could be
rescued by treatment with BSHTYZ. These data suggest that A induces
a neuronal and dendritic loss in the CA1/DG regions of the hippocampus and that
BSHTYZ reverses the loss in these regions [101].
9.5 Based on the Oxidative Stress
Oxidative
stress plays a very important role in neurodegenerative diseases, so reducing
oxidative stress is a potential therapeutic strategy. Curcumin is a phenolic
compound extracted from the rhizome of turmeric and is a natural antioxidant,
with bifunctional oxidative properties. It not only protects astrocytes from
HO-induced oxidative stress but also reverses oxidation-induced
mitochondrial damage and dysfunction. Curcumin inhibits oxidative stress-induced
inflammation and apoptosis by regulating transaminases, inducing endogenous
antioxidants and anti-inflammatory defense mechanisms. In addition, it also
reduces astrocyte damage and apoptosis [109, 110, 111].
Curculigoorchioides belongs to the family Amaryllidaceae and is a common herbal
medicine in TCM. Curculigoside (CUR) is the main active ingredient in
curculigoorchioides, which has a wide range
of pharmacological activities such as neuroprotection, anti-immune stimulation,
antioxidant, and anti-osteoporosis. CUR can
promote calcium deposition through antioxidant properties and increase the levels
of alkaline phosphatase and the transcription factor Runx2 in osteoblasts under
oxidative stress. It has been found that CUR can reduce oxidative damage and
induce proliferation in oxidative stress and differentiation [112].
9.6 Effects on Fatty Acids
HFDs have been shown to cause systemic inflammation and obesity, which in turn
may interfere with immune processes in the brain [113, 114]. Obesity causes
prolonged activation of inflammatory pathways, and HFDs lead to neuroinflammation
and reactive gliosis in the hypothalamus of mice. Toll-like receptor 4 (TLR4) is
a receptor for LPS and plays a vital role in innate immunity. Most TLR4 signaling
is mediated through myeloid differentiation primary response 88 (MyD88). Studies
have shown that free fatty acids induce TLR4 signaling associated with MyD88 and
can use TLR4 signaling to induce inflammatory responses in macrophages [115]. TCM
has vast clinical experience in treating obesity, and Rhubarb is one of the most
widely used herbs in TCM. Chrysophanol, a yellow crystalline substance extracted
from rhubarb, was shown to regulate lipid metabolism by activating AMPK signaling
and reducing HFD-induced fat accumulation in metazoan hepatocytes [116].
10. Other Effective Treatment Methods for the Treatment of Alzheimer’s
Disease
Other
than medication, some effective treatment methods are gaining increasing
attention, including acupuncture, electro-acupuncture, aromatherapy, pulsed
electromagnetic field, etc.
Acupuncture is widely accepted by patients because of its good treatment effect
and fewer adverse effects. A randomized trial
was conducted between November and May 2016 by
YJ Jia et al. [117]. They recruited
152 residents aged 50–85 years, collected their personal information, and
randomly assigned patients to the AG and DG groups. Treatment was thrice a week
for 12 weeks, with patients in the DG group given 5 mg/d donepezil hydrochloride
for the first 4 weeks. The AD Assessment Scale-Cognitive (ADAS-cog) and Clinician
Interview-Based Impression of Change-Plus (CIBIC-Plus) were used to assess the
effect after treatment. The ADAS-Cog scores improved by 6.99 (standard deviation:
3.23) and 4.02 (standard deviation: 2.11) in the acupuncture and control groups,
respectively. The CIBIC-Plus scores in the AG group decreased substantially
compared to the DG group, with a statistically significant difference between the
two groups (p 0.05). Finally, acupuncture is effective in improving
cognitive function and clinical status [117].
11. Conclusions
AD is a disease with complex pathogenesis and many factors, and the exact
pathogenesis has not been determined, so it is difficult to develop targeted
drugs. The difficulties that make drug development difficult so far include
complex pathogenesis, inability to determine the exact pathogenesis, difficulty
in finding suitable animal models, and the side effects of drugs already on the
market that have affected the quality of life of patients. Therefore, with
numerous active ingredients and a wide range of pathways of action, TCM has
brought a ray of hope for the treatment of AD (See Fig. 4). Its multi-target and
multi-pathway advantages make up for the shortcomings of existing drugs; in
addition, its human-centered treatment concept improves the life quality of
patients. Nowadays, with the rapid development of science and technology,
together with the increasing depth of scientific research, more new technologies
are providing a strong scientific basis for Chinese medicine, which can unveil
the implications of TCM and improve the working efficiency of Chinese medicine
researchers. New gene-editing technologies such as high-throughput screening
technology and CRISPR/Cas have brought us convenience. Meantime, new brain
imaging technologies make early diagnosis possible. All these new technologies
are helpful in discovering the exact pathogenesis and providing effective
treatment of AD.
Fig. 4.
Schematic diagram of A generation and possible
mechanism of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) intervention. When A is
in excess, senile plaques and A oligomers are formed, and microglia are
also activated. Rg1 reduces A production by inhibiting
-secretase, JDYZF can decrease A aggregation, safflower yellow
(SY) and the Bushen-Huatan-Yizhi formula (BSHTYZ) can reduce synaptic loss and
enhance the plasticity of synaptic structures, curculigoside (CUR) and curcumin
can reduce oxidative damage by enhancing antioxidant properties, and forsythoside
A (FA), matrine FA and matrine can regulate neuroinflammation.
Credit Author Statement
All authors agree to be accountable for all aspects of work ensuring integrity and accuracy.
Author Contributions
JZ wrote the manuscript. JY and LD participated in the conception and writing the articles. FW revised the manuscript. LL designed and revised the manuscript and got the funding. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Ethics Approval and Consent to Participate
Not applicable.
Acknowledgment
We would like to express our gratitude to all those who helped us during the writing of this manuscript. Thanks to all the peer reviewers for their opinions and suggestions.
Funding
This work was supported in parts by grants from the National Nature Science Foundation of China (81673856), China Postdoctoral Science Foundation (2016M592319, 2017T100542).
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.