1. Introduction
The distal metastasis of tumor cells remains the dominant cause of
cancer-related mortality. Metastasis is a multiple stepwise cell-biological
process, which involves: one or several tumor cells acquire the capacity to
invade locally through surrounding extracellular matrix (ECM) and stromal cell
layers; intravasate into the circulation and escape from immune surveillance;
arrest at distant organ sites; extravasate into the parenchyma of distant
tissues; form micro-metastases in these foreign microenvironments; reinitiate
their proliferative programs at metastatic sites, thereby generating
macro-metastasis [1, 2, 3]. Traditionally, previous studies were mainly focused on
oncogenic transformation, epithelial-mesenchymal transition (EMT), cancer
stem-like cells (CSCs), etc. These perspectives were appealing while limited. The
famous “seed and soil” hypothesis was proposed by Stephen Paget in 1889, which is
widely cited and accepted, proposing the importance of both pro-metastatic tumor
cells and a supportive microenvironment. In recent years, based on the “seed and
soil” hypothesis, a new concept of “pre-metastatic niche” brought fresh
insight into our understanding of cancer metastasis.
The theory of pre-metastatic niche was first proposed by Kaplan et al.
[4] in 2005, who demonstrated that the vascular endothelial growth factor receptor 1 (VEGFR1) cells from the bone marrow
homed to tumor-specific pre-metastatic sites before the arrival of metastatic
tumor cells, providing a permissive microenvironment for incoming tumor cells.
Since then, much attention was focused on the characteristics and significance of
the pre-metastatic niche in metastasis. Apart from MDSC, the formation of
pre-metastatic niches is a result of tumor-secreted factors, tumor-derived
exosomes, reprogramming of tissue-resident stromal cells, etc. Myeloid-derived
suppressor cells (MDSCs) are one kind of bone marrow-derived myeloid cells
(BMDCs), which play a major role in the pre-metastatic niche. A decreased
accumulation of MDSCs in the pre-metastatic lung is associated with increased
disease-free survival and overall survival [5]. In this review, we aim to
conceptualize the framework and highlight the dynamic interplay between MDSCs and
pre-metastatic niche.
2. The Characteristic of MDSCs
MDSC is a heterogeneous population, which is consist of immature myeloid cells
and myeloid progenitor cells. Now MDSC is widely studied in pathological fields,
such as tumors, bacterial and parasitic infections, chronic inflammation, sepsis
and autoimmunity, though they were first characterized in tumor patients and
tumour-bearing mice (Table 1).
Table 1.Surface markers to define MDSCs.
Name |
Markers (mouse) |
Markers (human) |
Total MDSCs |
CD11bGr1 |
HLA-DRCD11bCD33 |
M-MDSCs |
CD11bLy6CLy6G |
CD14CD15HLA-DR |
PMN-MDSCs |
CD11bLy6CLy6G |
CD11bCD14CD15/CD66b |
eMDSCs |
- |
LIN (CD3, CD14, CD15, CD19, CD56) HLA-DRCD33 |
F-MDSCs |
- |
CD33IL4Ra |
Undoubtedly, most of the MDSCs are derived from hematopoietic progenitor cells
(HPC), which are markedly expanded in the bone marrow, and then enter the blood
stream and get the immunosuppressive activity. MDSCs include two major subtypes:
polymorphonuclear (PMN) and monocytic (M)-MDSC, which were termed based on their
phenotypic and morphological features. In mice, the surface marker of MDSCs is
CD11bGr1. Depending on the two different epitopes of Gr1, M-MDSCs are
characterized as CD11bLy6CLy6G, and PMN-MDSCs are
CD11bLy6CLy6G. In human, the standard phenotypical markers of
M-MDSCs are CD14CD15HLA-DR and PMN-MDSCs are
CD11bCD14CD15/CD66b. The LIN (including CD3, CD14,
CD15, CD19, CD56) HLA-DRCD33 cells are now defined as “early-stage
MDSCs” (eMDSCs), which contain mixed groups of MDSC comprising more immature
progenitors. The eMDSC subset has only been identified in human (not in mouse).
In addition, a novel fibrocytic MDSCs (F-MDSCs) was described in human, which
share the characterization of MDSC-, DC-, and fibrocyte-associated markers [6, 7, 8, 9].
However, the reports about F-MDSCs are limited, and a better understanding of
association between F-MDSCs and typical MDSCs is needed.
In addition to be detected in the blood, MDSCs have also been found in the lung
and liver, which were two organs for future distal metastasis. Different from
blood, the PMN-MDSCs from livers of NSG (NOD/SCID/Il2rg ) mice do not express Ly6C [10].
Furthermore, in most experimental tumor models, the number of PMN-MDSCs are more
markedly elevated than M-MDSCs, especially in pre-metastatic liver [10, 11, 12].
Similar to PMN-MDSCs, M-MDSCs have also been detected outside of the circulation,
including in primary tumor sites, pre-metastatic tissues, metastatic lesions, and
lymph nodes [13]. Different from monocytes, the differentiation of M-MDSCs into
conventional macrophages (M) and dendritic cells (DCs) is inhibited in
the pre-metastatic tissues. The types of pathologic microenvironment determine
the pathway of M-MDSCs differentiation. The M-MDSCs subset has the potential to
give rise to a subset of CD11bGr1Ly6GF4/80
macrophages with potent immunosuppressive property in response to hypoxia, VEGF
and colony-stimulating factor 1 (CSF1), which was termed as TAMs (tumor associated macrophages) [14, 15]. This
subset can also differentiate into inflammatory DCs after migration to the tumor
microenvironment [16, 17]. The existence of immune suppressive regulatory DCs in
tumor microenvironment was described in recent years, but whether these DCs are
immunosuppressive needs a further illustration. Some reported that M-MDSCs can
contribute to the accumulation of tumor associated DCs by differentiating to
inflammatory DCs (inf-DCs), which have specific phenotype and are critical
components of anti-tumor response [16]. Some revealed that cancers can subvert DC
function, inducing DC tolerization in the tumor microenvironment [18, 19].
Accordingly, the PMN-MDSCs, M-MDSCs, TAM and DCs together accumulate in the tumor
microenvironment, as well as in the pre-metastatic tissues, providing a
tolerogenic environment and favoring tumor progression [19, 20].
3. Recruitment of MDSCs in the Pre-Metastatic Niche
Multiple factors induce the mobilization of MDSCs to the pre-metastatic niche,
including chemokines, growth factors, interleukins, resided extracellular matrix
components and so on (Table 2, Ref [5, 10, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39]).
Table 2.Factors associated with the accumulation of MDSCs in
pre-metastatic niche.
Factor |
Source |
MDSC subset |
Receptor |
Model |
Reference |
CXCL1 |
tumor-associated macrophage in the primary tumor |
CXCR2 MDSCs |
CXCR2 |
colorectal cancer |
[10] |
SDF-1 |
systemic TIMP-1 treated hepatocyte |
PMN-MDSCs |
CXCR4 |
colorectal cancer |
[21] |
CCL2 |
BMDCs |
MDSCs |
CCR2 |
breast cancer |
[5, 22, 37] |
CCL12 |
alveolar macrophages |
M-MDSCs |
- |
melanoma |
[23, 38] |
IL6 |
- |
PMN-MDSCs |
- |
lung cancer, colorectal cancer |
[24, 25] |
G-CSF |
- |
MDSC |
- |
melanoma, lung cancer, lymphoma, breast cancer |
[27, 26, 39] |
COX1 |
platelet |
CXCR1 M-MDSCs |
- |
melanoma |
[28] |
HIF1 |
breast tumor cells |
PMN-MDSCs |
- |
breast cancer |
[29] |
LOX |
breast tumor cells |
CD11b myeloid cells |
- |
breast cancer |
[30, 31] |
periostin |
- |
MDSCs |
- |
breast cancer |
[32] |
PGE2 |
- |
MDSCs |
- |
prostate cancer |
[33] |
S100A8/A9 |
MDSCs |
MDSCs |
TLR4 |
lung cancer, breast cancer |
[34, 35] |
miR-494 |
MDSCs |
CXCR4MDSCs |
- |
breast cancer |
[36] |
CXCL1 is one kind of chemokines which is originally known to recruit neutrophils
during tissue damage [40]. In colorectal carcinoma, the tumor-associated
macrophages produced CXCL1, which is induced by tumor cells secreted VEGFA,
recruits CXCR2-positive MDSCs to form a pre-metastatic niche that ultimately
promotes liver metastases [10]. The SDF-1/CXCR4-dependent Ly6G PMN-MDSCs recruitment in mice creates a pre-metastatic niche in the liver, a process
which is initiated by elevated systemic levels of tissue inhibitor of
metalloproteinases (TIMP-1) [21]. In breast cancer, the CCL2 induced
Ly6CCCR2 M-MDSCs expansion in the pulmonary pre-metastatic niche
facilitate lung metastasis, and the sole neutralization of CCL2 in hypoxic
conditioned medium (HCM) results in decreased CD11bLy6CLy6G
myeloid cells in the pre-metastatic niche and reduced metastatic burden
in vivo [22]. Our previous study shows that the knockdown of CCL12 in
tumor-bearing mice significantly decreased M-MDSCs infiltration into the
pre-metastatic lungs, resulting in reduced E-selectin expression and decreased
tumor cell metastasis [23]. Interleukin 6 (IL-6) is a cytokine which is widely expressed in
multiple immune cells and malignant tumors. The IL-6 accumulation has been
reported to be associated with the enrichment of immunosuppressive MDSC in
different cancer types, including malignant melanoma, hepatocellular carcinoma
(HCC), squamous cell carcinoma (SCC), ovarian cancer and bladder cancer [41]. In
lung cancer, IL-6 gene knockout in Gprc5a-ko/IL-6-ko mice completely reversed the
G-MDSCs upregulation and M-MDSCs downregulation in Gprc5a-ko mice [24]. Increased
S1PR1-STAT3 signaling in colorectal cancer cells induces a production of IL-6,
leading to more MDSCs infiltration that could prime distant pre-metastatic sites
in the liver, and high level of circulating IL-6 associates with the percentage
of CD14HLA-DR MDSCs in the patients correlated with colorectal cancer liver metastasis (CRLM)
[25]. Granulocyte colony-stimulating factor (G-CSF) is
generally believed to induce the differentiation of myeloid progenitor and MDSC
expansion. In the breast cancer model, G-CSF is detected to drive the
mobilization of MDSC to the lung metastatic niche [26], and anti-G-CSF treatment
dramatically decreased the number of circulating or tumor-associated
CD11bGr1 cells [27]. COX-1/TXA2 pathway in platelets participant in
the aggregation of platelets on tumor cells, endothelial activation, and
recruitment of metastasis-promoting CXCR1 M-MDSCs, thus inhibition of
this pathway in platelets diminishes the formation of a pre-metastatic niche
[28].
MDSCs sustain tumor progression by establishing a pre-metastatic niche and
dynamically remodeling the tumor microenvironment through the production of
angiogenic factors and metalloproteases. Correspondingly, a class of
matricellular proteins affect the recruitment and the immune-suppressive activity
of MDSCs [42]. The upregulated fibronectin expressed by resident fibroblasts
induced by tumor-specific growth factors, interact with VLA-4 expressed on
VEGFR1 BMDCs, supporting the adhesion of the BMDCs to form the
pre-metastatic niche [4]. In breast cancer, primary tumor hypoxia not only
provides hypoxia-inducible factor 1 (HIF-1) but also increases secretion of lysyl oxidase (LOX) in plasma through the
HIF-1/LOX axis, which are both capable of recruiting CD11b myeloid cells,
contributing to tumor progression by pre-metastatic niche formation [29, 30, 31].
Periostin (POSTN) is one kind of nonstructural ECM proteins, which function as
adaptor and modulator of interaction between cells and their extracellular
microenvironment. In a mouse breast tumor model, POSTN is found to enhance the
accumulation and immunosuppressive functions of MDSCs in the pre-metastatic lungs
[32]. In addition, COX-2/mPGES-1/PGE2 modulates the accumulation of MDSCs to
metastasized lungs in prostate cancer [33]. The upregulated S100A8/A9 in the
pre-metastatic lung recruits MDSCs in an TLR4/MD-2 dependent manner [34, 35].
Growing numbers of ncRNAs have been reported to have specific functions and
underlying mechanisms in the formation of tumor microenvironment and
pre-metastatic niches, ranging from microRNAs to long ncRNAs [43]. miR-494, which
is dramatically induced by tumor-derived transforming growth factor 1 (TGF-1), plays an essential role in
regulating the accumulation and activity of MDSCs by targeting of phosphatase and
tensin homolog (PTEN) and activation of the Akt pathway [36].
In addition to be mobilized by tumor-related factors, the circulating MDSCs in
the blood can also protect the circulating tumors cells (CTCs) from being
eliminated, shielding CTCs from immune surveillance [44]. In the microenvironment
of blood, the CTCs and circulatory PMN-MDSCs form CTC/MDSC clusters and increase
the metastatic properties of CTCs through ROS/Notch/Nodal signaling [45].
4. Functions of MDSCs in the Pre-Metastatic Niche
MDSCs are the major component for the formation of the pre-metastatic
microenvironment before tumor distal metastasis or after surgical resection of
primary tumors in mouse models of pulmonary metastases. Compared with
chemotherapy, the adjuvant epigenetic treatment leads to longer periods of
disease-free survival and overall survival, which can decrease the accumulation
of MDSCs in the pre-metastatic lung [5]. Within the pre-metastatic niche, MDSCs
are shown to suppress immune response, induce an inflammatory microenvironment,
promote neoangiogenesis and vascular permeability, and promote the arrest and
survival of tumor cells (Fig. 1). These evidences demonstrate that MDSCs might be
the protagonist in the pre-metastatic niche, playing essential roles in the
formation of pre-metastatic niche.
Fig. 1.
Effects of MDSCs in the tumor pre-metastatic organs. MDSCs
exert immunosuppression by regulating T cells, Treg, DCs and NK cells.
4.1 MDSCs Suppress Immune Response in Pre-Metastatic Niche
A main feature of MDSCs is immune suppression activity, which are important
negative regulators of host innate immunity in tumor microenvironment. MDSCs
utilize multiple suppressive mechanism to inhibit CD8 T, DC, and natural killer cells (NK) through arginase 1 (ARG1), inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS), reactive oxygen species (ROS) and so on.
One of the suppressive mechanisms attributed to MDSCs is the inhibition of T
cell activation and proliferation. Different subsets of MDSCs might use different
mechanisms by which to suppress T-cell. L-arginine (L-Arg) is a conditionally
necessary amino acid which serves as a substrate for two enzymes: iNOS and
ARG. Lack of L-Arg blocks T-cell proliferation and decreases
expression of CD3 chain and interferon (IFN) production [46, 47, 48]. Recent findings indicate
that both MDSCs subsets express ARG1, which converted L-Arg into urea and
L-ornithine. In addition, there are substantial differences of depriving L-Arg by
MDSCs between mice and human. In murine MDSCs, an increased uptake and
intracellular degradation of L-Arg is detected. In human MDSCs, enhanced ARG
expression is found in the circulation [49]. Furthermore, multiple studies
indicate that the PMN-MDSCs express higher level of ARG than M-MDSCs [50, 51, 52]. In
addition, the expression of ARG1 is regulated by inflammatory cytokine and tumor
cell-derived factors. In lung cancer, head and neck tumor, colon carcinoma and
renal carcinoma, tumor cells derived cyclooxygenase-2 (COX2) induces and maintains ARG1 production,
and PGE2 induces ARG1 expression in MDSCs by signaling through the E-prostanoid
(EP) 4 receptor [53]. Increased stress-induced activation of 2-AR signaling in
MDSCs modulates the expression of ARG1, which is dependent upon STAT3
phosphorylation [54]. In hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), wild-type hepatic
stellate cells (HSCs)-induced MDSCs expressed increased level of iNOS and ARG1
compared with MDSCs induced by IL-6-deficient HSCs in vitro [55].
Additionally, IL-6/IL-8-ARG1 axis of CD45CD33CD11b MDSCs in
human gastric cancer suppress CD8 T cell activity [51].
Elevated iNOS expression is a hallmark of MDSCs in tumor-bearing condition. Only
M-MDSCs express high level of iNOS, which metabolize L-Arg into NO. Both T-cell
receptor and STAT1 are nitrated by MDSCs-produced NO, which results in T-cell
activation inhibition and antitumor immune response reduction [56]. HIF-1 is
reported to be associated with increased activity of ARG1 and iNOS in MDSCs,
leading to strong inhibition of T-cell functions in the tumor microenvironment
[57]. In tumor-induced MDSCs, iNOS expression is enhanced by SETD1B, which
regulates the trimethylation of histone H3 lysine 4 (H3K4Me3) at the nos2
promoter [56]. Moreover, in ovarian cancer patients, IL-6 and IL-10-driven STAT3
activation upregulates the expression of ARG1 and iNOS in induced M-MDSC [58].
CBP/EP300-BRD pathway maintain the immunosuppressive activity through STAT
pathway-related genes and the expression of Arg1 and iNOS [59]. Clearly, the
increased STAT3 and NADPH oxidase activity of PMN-MDSCs subset result in high
release of ROS but low NO release. Nevertheless, the M-MDSCs subset expresses
high levels of STAT1 and iNOS, and enhanced level of NO but low level of ROS are
produced [60]. MDSCs-derived ROS and peroxynitrite, which are the product of the
reaction of ROS with NO, modify T cell receptor (TCR) and CD8 molecules. The modified TCR and CD8
molecules can not bind phosphorylated MHC, leading to the antigen-specific
tolerance of CD8 T cells [61].
MDSCs can also exert their immunosuppression by inducing regulatory T cells
through cytokine [62]. For example, in tumor-bearing host, Gr-1CD115 MDSCs mediate the development of Treg cell through a combination of multiple
pathways dependent on TGF-, IL-10, and cell-cell contact [63]. miR-130a and
miR-145 directly target TGF receptor II (TRII) and are down-regulated in the
Gr-1CD11b immature myeloid cells, leading to increased TRII, and
increased response to TGF [64]. In CD33 MDSCs, the indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase (IDO) expression is
positively related with Foxp3Tregs, which were all correlated with advanced
clinical stage prior to neoadjuvant chemotherapy in tumor tissues [65].
In addition to inhibiting T cells, MDSCs can also regulate the functions of
other immune cells, including NK cells, macrophages, and DCs. NK cells play a
crucial role in anti-tumor immunity because of their innate ability to
distinguish malignant cells from normal cells. In head and neck cancer model,
PMN-MDSCs suppress NK-cell function through TGF and production of HO [66]. In vitro, binding of PGE2 to EP2 and EP4 receptors on M-MDSCs
activates the p38MAPK/ERK pathway and elevates the secretion of TGF as a result.
Therefore, PGE2-treated M-MDSCs potently suppress NK-cell activity through
production of TGF [67]. In syngeneic orthotopic mammary cancer model, the
cytotoxicity of NK cells is significantly decreased in the presence of MDSCs in
pre-metastatic niche, resulting in a reduced anti-tumor response and an increased
successful metastasis in the secondary organs [29]. Furthermore, in addition to
decrease cytotoxicity, MDSCs are reported to inhibit NKG2D expression and IFN-
production of NK cells both in vivo and in vitro [68]. However,
a study reports that intraperitoneal polyinosinic:polycytidylic acid (poly I:C)
treatment in B16-bearing mice induces MDSC activation, driving CD69 expression
and IFN- production in NK cells [69], implying that the effect of MDSCs to NK
cells is dependent on stimulating factors. In addition, DCs are a critical
component of immune responses in cancer which cross-present tumor-associated
antigens, and PMN-MDSCs are reported to block the cross-presentation by DCs,
which is dependent on myeloperoxidase (MPO) [70].
Last but not least, HIF-1 can also enhance the suppressive activity of
MDSCs by inducing expression of programmed death-ligand 1 (PD-L1), leading to
reduced production of IL-2 and decreased proliferation of cytotoxic T cells [71, 72].
Recent findings revealed that type I interferons (IFN1) receptor signaling can
also restrict acquisition of suppressive activity through an universal mechanism.
In G-MDSCs, the downregulation of IFN1 signaling activates the PI3K-Akt/mTOR
pathway through SOCS1 downregulation [73], and the downregulation of IFNAR1
dependent on tumor-derived factors-driven p38 kinase leads to an overwhelmed IFN1
pathway in myeloid cells during tumorigenesis, leading to the acquirement of
immune-suppressive activities [74]. In addition, through type I IFN signaling,
DNMTi 5-azacytidine (AZA) can reduce the percentage of MDSCs in the tumor
microenvironment [75].
4.2 MDSCs and Inflammatory Microenvironment Interact with Each Other
in Pre-Metastatic Niche
An inflammatory microenvironment is implicated as a contributory factor to tumor
development and metastasis in many cases. MDSCs promote the inflammatory
microenvironment formation in pre-metastatic niche. During inflammation,
S100A8/A9 is actively released and plays an important role in regulating the
inflammatory response [76]. In cancer, S100A8/A9 is reported as a “soil signal”
to attract cancer cells that with TLR4, and a study showed that abundant
production and release of S100A8/A9 in the M-MDSCs is detected in the
pre-metastatic region [77]. Our work showed that the recruited M-MDSCs in
pre-metastatic niche produce IL-1, which is a hallmark of inflammation, thereby
increasing the expression of E-selectin and contributing to the arrest of tumor
cell on endothelial cells [23]. Another study showed that accompanied with the
recruitment of CD11bGr1 MDSCs, the proinflammatory cytokines, such as
IL-1, monocyte chemotactic protein-1 (MCP1), stromal cell derived factor 1 (SDF-1), and macrophage-derived chemokine
are also significantly elevated. Ex vivo coculture of lung single-cell suspension
with CD11bGr-1 MDSCs significantly upregulated the production of
basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF), insulin-like growth factor-I (IGFI), IL-5, macrophage-derived chemokine, SDF-1, MMP9 and VEGFR1. This work
suggested that the CD11bGr-1 MDSCs is likely induce an inflammatory
microenvironment in the pre-metastatic lung [78].
Except for the recruited MDSCs induce the inflammatory responses in
pre-metastatic niche, MDSCs development and activation are also influenced by
inflammation. In murine melanoma model, upregulated inflammatory factors such as
IL-1, GM-CSF, and IFN- are accompanied with MDSC recruitment and increased
immunosuppressive activity, which correlated with tumor progression. Upon
manipulation with the phosphodiesterase-5 inhibitor sildenafil, reduced levels of
numerous inflammatory mediators (e.g., IL-1, IL-6, VEGF, S100A9) are detected,
which are in association with decreased MDSC amounts and immunosuppressive
function [79]. Besides tooth loss, periodontitis can also increase the patient’s
risk for multiple disease [80]. It is reported that periodontal inflammation
promotes metastasis of breast cancer through MDSCs recruitment, which is
partially dependent on pyroptosis-induced multiple inflammatory factors and
chemokines generation, such as IL-1, CCL2, CXCL5 and CCL5 in the early steps of
metastasis [81]. The pro-inflammatory cytokines S100A8 and S100A9 as well as
these two factors-induced SAA protein and recruited CD11b myeloid cells by
SAA together contribute to the development of pre-metastatic niches in the lung
[82].
4.3 MDSCs Induce Neoangiogenesis and Vascular Permeability in
Pre-Metastatic Niche
Neoangiogenesis and high vascular permeability are effective methods for tumor
metastasis. MDSCs are defined as one of major contributors to stimulate
angiogenesis and induce high vascular permeability in pre-metastatic niche.
Angiogenesis is considered as a hallmark of cancer and an imperative process for
tumor growth and metastatic dissemination [83]. Multiple investigations have been
reported to illuminate the contribution of MDSCs to angiogenesis. It is well
known that proteolysis mediated by matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) promotes
angiogenesis and inflammation in the tumor microenvironment. MDSCs can produce
high levels of MMPs, such as MMP14, MMP13, MMP2 and MMP9, to promote angiogenesis
and accelerate tumor neovasculature [83, 84]. In addition,
CD11bGr1 MDSCs can also acquire endothelial cell properties
or being incorporated into the vessel wall directly to contribute to tumor
angiogenesis in the tumor microenvironment [85]. The activated MDSCs induce the
production of VEGF and FGF2 so as to promote tumor angiogenesis [86]. Bv8
protein, which is produced by G-CSF-mobilized Ly6GLy6C cells, is
implicated in angiogenesis and mobilization of myeloid cells. Anti-Bv8 antibody
significantly decreases lung metastasis [39]. In response to the melanoma-derived
exosomes, the MDSCs are reprogrammed into a pro-vasculogenic phenotype that is
positive for c-kit, the receptor tyrosine kinase Tie2 and Met [87]. In the models
of breast carcinoma, the MDSCs recruited to the pre-metastatic lungs appear to be
a angiogenic switching through secreting several proangiogenic factors in tumors,
including IL-1 and MMP-9 [88]. Most cancers will appear organ-specific
metastasis, a process also considered as “organotropism”. This process is related
with multiple factors, including the tumor-intrinsic properties and their
interaction with unique features of host organs. Studies show that the
organotropic metastasis of tumor cells is mediated by tumor-derived extracellular
vesicles. In addition to the angiogenesis, the vascular hyperpermeability in
pre-metastatic niche contributes to subsequent tumor cell homing in lung vessels.
The CCR2-CCL2 system has been reported to induce the abundant secretion of SAA3
and S100A8 to increase the permeability of vessels [89], which are also secreted
by recruited MDSCs in pre-metastatic niche [77]. The interaction of MDSCs with
epithelial cells increase the permeability in blood vessel [90], although the
exact mechanism remains to be elucidated.
4.4 MDSCs Promote the Arrest and Survival of Tumor Cells in
Pre-Metastatic Niche
The recruitment and survival of disseminated circulating tumor cells in target
organs are essential for successful metastasis. E-selectin mediates adhesion of
circulating cells to the vessel surface via interaction with its ligand present
on the circulating cells [91]. In the pre-metastatic lung, the recruited M-MDSCs
ahead of tumor cells increase the expression of E-selectin through IL-1, and
thereby promote the arrest of tumor cells on endothelial cells. Depletion of
M-MDSCs in the pre-metastatic lungs results in reduced E-selectin expression
[23].
The survival of tumor cells in the hostile distant organs rate-limited the
successful metastasis in cancer. CCL9 was highly induced in Gr1CD11b
immature myeloid cells and in pre-metastatic lung in tumor-bearing mice. It
promotes tumor cell survival by increasing phospho-AKT (P-AKT) and BLC-2, in
addition to decreasing the expression of poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase (PARP)
[92]. PMN-MDSCs isolated from pre-metastatic livers of NSG mice bearing HCT-116
cecal tumors or LS-174T cecal tumors inhibits HCT-116 cell apoptosis, and the
PMN-MDSCs enhancement of tumor cell survival is ratio dependent [10]. Tissue
factor (TF) recruited CD11b macrophages enhances the survival of tumor
cells after arrest in the lung, and impairment of macrophage function decreases
tumor cell survival [93].
Based on the crucial function of MDSCs in the formation of pre-metastatic
microenvironment, targeting MDSCs could be an effective means to hamper the
establishment of pre-metastatic microenvironment. Multiple strategies have been
proposed to target MDSCs which is including but not limited in the pre-metastatic
niche. Studies have been conducted to explore drugs that focused on inhibiting
the immunosuppressive activity of MDSCs. Sunitinib is a small molecule synthetic
dihydroindole receptor tyrosine kinase (RTK) inhibitor. In various types of
cancer patients, Sunitinib treatment can weaken the immunosuppressive activity of
M-MDSC by reducing Arg-1 and pSTAT3 [94]. Another drug targeting MDSC is 5
phosphodiesterase (PDE5) inhibitor, which has been proved to reduce
IL-4R, pSTAT6 and Arg-1, thereby effectively blocking the function of
MDSC [95, 96]. Drugs targeting corresponding chemokines and receptors have also
been developed. SX-682, a small molecule inhibitor targeting CXCR1 and CXCR2,
significantly reduces the invasion of CXCR2+PMN MDSCs to tumors [97]. Blocking
the interaction of CCL2-CCR2 by using carlumab or CCR2 antagonist PF-04136309 has
been proved to have potential anti-tumor effect in several preclinical cancer
models [98, 99]. Maraviroc, a CCR5 antagonist, effectively block the CCL5/CCR5
axis and exhibit a significant anti-tumor effect in a phase I clinical trial
[100]. CSF-1R inhibitors, such as IMC-CS4, GW2580, PLX3397, AMG820, imatizumab,
and pecidatinib, also show an anti-tumor effect by inhibiting the recruitment of
M-MDSC [101, 102]. Another way targeting MDSCs is the elimination of MDSCs. The
traditional chemotherapy drugs such as gemcitabine and 5-fluorouracil can induce
the apoptosis of MDSCs and reduce the number of MDSCs in the tumor
microenvironment [103, 104]. In addition, an anti-Gr1 antibody (RB6-8C5) is used
to clear MDSCs in mice [105].
5. Conclusions and Perspectives
The successful arrival and survival of cancer cells in distant metastatic sites
depends on the microenvironment they encounter. Traditionally, immunosuppression,
inflammation, angiogenesis/vascular permeability, lymphangiogenesis,
organotropism, and reprogramming are summarized as the major characteristics of
the pre-metastatic niche, and the reprogramming include metabolic reprogramming,
stromal reprogramming, and epigenetic reprogramming [106]. Last but not the
least, the primary tumor mobilized MDSCs remodel the pre-metastatic
microenvironment to create a favorable niche for the dissemination of tumor cell,
including induction of immunosuppression, inflammation, neoangiogenesis, vascular
hyperpermeability, and increased arrest and survival of disseminated tumor cells,
revealing the leading role in pre-metastatic niche. Much attention has been
focused on the functions of MDSCs in the formation of pre-metastatic
microenvironment. Multiple factors participate in the formation, including
chemokines, cytokines, extracellular vesicles and so on. Although the individual
factor secreted by MDSCs is not enough to develop the pre-metastatic niche, their
combined functions may result in a significant increase in the sequential steps
of pre-metastatic niche development. However, the exact mechanism remains to be
further elucidated. MDSCs play a pivotal role in pre-metastatic niche formation
and tumor metastasis, while the detection and elimination of MDSCs in
pre-metastatic niche remain a huge challenge in human. Therefore, effective
control of the expansion of MDSCs and inhibition of the recruitment and function
of MDSCs in pre-metastatic niche might be beneficial for relieving tumor
metastasis to some extent. Furthermore, there are limiting clinical research on
the function of MDSCs in the formation of pre-metastatic niche, and more
attention is needed in clinic.
Author Contributions
This work was conceptualized by WC and HS; Preparation of the original draft was
completed by WC, ZW, JL, YQ and HS; Editing and proofreading were completed by
all authors. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the
manuscript.
Ethics Approval and Consent to Participate
Not applicable.
Acknowledgment
We thank Pro. Xianlu Zeng (Institute of Genetics and Cytology, Northeast Normal
University) for critical reading of the manuscript.
Funding
This work was supported by the Natural Science Foundation of Rizhao (grant no.
RZ2021ZR59), the Supporting Fund for Shandong Province Medical and Health Science
and Technology Development Plan Project (grant no. 202002080284); and Teachers’
Research of Jining Medical University (grant no. JYFC2019FKJ029).
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.