†These authors contributed equally.
Academic Editors: Graham Pawelec, Jiang Pi, Anguo Wu and Deyu Kong
Difficult or even non-healing diabetic foot ulcers (DFU) are a global medical challenge. Although current treatments such as debridement, offloading, and infection control have resulted in partial improvement in DFU, the incidence, amputation, and mortality rates of DFU remain high. Therefore, there is an urgent need to find new or more effective drugs. Numerous studies have shown that oxidative stress plays an important role in the pathophysiology of DFU. The nuclear factor erythroid 2-related factor (Nrf2) signaling pathway and the advanced glycated end products (AGEs)-receptor for advanced glycation endproducts (RAGE), protein kinase C (PKC), polyol and hexosamine biochemical pathways play critical roles in the regulation of oxidative stress in the body. Targeting these pathways to restore redox balance can control and alleviate the occurrence and development of DFU. Natural biologics are a major source of potential drugs for these relevant targets, and their antioxidant potential has been extensively demonstrated. Here, we discussed the pathophysiological mechanism of oxidative stress in DFU, and identifiled natural biologics targeting these pathways to accelerate DFU healing, in order to provide a new or potential direction for clinical treatment, nursing and related basic research of DFU.
The incidence and prevalence of diabetes mellitus (DM) is increasing worldwide. In 2021, 536.6 million people in 20–79-year-olds had diabetes worldwide, which is estimated to rise to 783.2 million in 2045 [1]. DFU are a common complication of DM. It is estimated that 19–34% of diabetic patients will develop DFU [2]. With the increase in patients with diabetes, the number of patients with DFU is increasing. Importantly, DFU not only have a high incidence [3], but also a high rate of disability and mortality [4, 5], and once DFU appear, they can be difficult to heal or even become nonhealing. They lead to great suffering both physically and mentally. Current treatments for DFU mainly include debridement, offloading, and infection control [6], but the effect is not ideal. Therefore, more effective treatment strategies need to be explored. Although the exact mechanism of the occurrence and development of DFU is still unclear, there is no doubt that oxidative stress plays a key role in DFU [7].
Oxidative stress is a physiological process, and a reasonable level of oxidative stress can promote wound healing [8, 9]. However, in DFU, there is an imbalance between the body’s reactive oxygen species (ROS) levels and antioxidant enzymes [10]. The pathological oxidative stress not only damages the stages of inflammation, proliferation, and remodeling, making each stage unable to proceed smoothly and orderly, but also leads to vascular, neuropathy, or local infection, and ultimately worsens DFU [7]. Nrf2 is the central regulator of oxidative stress [11]. Damage to the AGEs-RAGE, PKC, polyol and hexosamine biochemical pathways is the key to the imbalance of redox levels [12]. Therefore, seeking drugs targeting the Nrf2 signaling pathway and AGEs-RAGE, PKC, polyol and hexosamine pathways to promote the body’s redox balance may become an important strategy to accelerate the healing of DFU.
Natural biologics have always been a research hotspot in the world due to their advantages of less toxicity and side effects, wide sources, and cost efficiency. Many natural biologics can scavenge oxygen free radicals or increase antioxidant levels by targeting the Nrf2 signaling pathway, AGEs-RAGE, PKC, polyol and hexosamine pathways, and ultimately play a beneficial role in the repair of DFU.
Therefore, the aim of this review was to investigate the role of oxidative stress in the pathophysiology of DFU through a literature review. We then introduced the Nrf2 signaling pathway and AGEs-RAGE, PKC, polyol and hexosamine pathways as pharmacological targets, providing up-to-date information on natural biologics that target these pathways to accelerate DFU healing.
Oxidative stress was defined as: “an imbalance between oxidants and antioxidants in favor of the oxidants, leading to a disruption of redox signaling and control and/or molecular damage” [13]. When the skin barrier structure is destroyed, oxygen immediately flows in, and the injury-induced O2 influx fuels local ROS production [14]. At low concentrations, ROS act as cellular messengers to accelerat wound healing [8, 9]. However, in DFU, abnormalities in the Nrf2 signaling pathway and AGEs-RAGE, PKC, Polyol and Hexosamine biochemical pathways result in excessive oxidative stress on the wound surface, which is one of the main reasons for the difficulty in healing of DFU. The results of clinical specimen experiments showed that there was uncontrolled oxidative stress and decreased antioxidant capacity in DFU, which resulted in redox imbalance [10]. Excessive oxidative stress can damage all stages of DFU repair, such as inflammation, proliferation, and remodeling.
In patients with DFU, continuous hyperglycemia will lead to excessive oxidative stress. Oxidative stress induced by hyperglycemia can enhance neutrophil gene expression and secretion of S100A8 and S100A9 [15, 16]. S100A8/A9 promotes leukocytosis via increased proliferation of Bone Marrow progenitor cells [17]. For example, S100A8/A9 induces macrophages to secrete more proinflammatory mediators, such as IL6 [15]. Moreover, sustained hyperglycemia exposure increases neutrophil metabolism, and ROS production as a byproduct through the mitochondrial electron transport chain also increases [16, 18]. ROS in the neutrophils stimulate NETosis, capturing and killing pathogens via neutrophils extracellular traps (NETs) [19], through both the NOX-dependent and NOX-independent pathways [16]. Reasonable formation of NETs is beneficial to the normalization of the immune microenvironment, but excessive formation of NETs worsens the abnormal inflammatory response of wounds, which is also the key pathological manifestation of diabetic wounds (DW) that is difficult to heal [20, 21, 22]. In addition, NETs also reduce the responsiveness of neutrophils to lipopolysaccharide, leading to an imbalance of M1/M2 macrophages [23]. Neutrophils and macrophages are the core cells in the inflammatory phase, and their abnormal function or phenotype often leads to a continuous low-efficiency inflammatory reaction on the wound. Natural biologics play an import role in decreasing inflammatory response and oxidative stress markers [24]. Solving the problem of pathological oxidative stress in the wound and precise regulation of the start and end of inflammation are the key to promote the repair of DFU.
Excessive ROS production in DFU leads to ROS accumulation in endothelial cells,
which mediates endothelial dysfunction [25, 26]. Inhibition of oxidative stress
can enhance the proliferation of human umbilical vein endothelial cells and human
skin fibroblasts, restore angiogenesis, promote granulation tissue formation and
healing of epithelialization, overall demonstrating markedly improved healing of
DW [27]. In addition, fibroblasts promote keratinocyte proliferation through
Jun-dependent expression of PTN and SDF-1 [28], which is beneficial to epithelial
reformation [29]. However, in DFU, excessive oxidative stress impaired the
proliferation and differentiation of fibroblasts [27]. In DFU, intense oxidative
DNA damage, low vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) and transforming growth
factor
In DFU, excessive oxidative stress leads to impaired proliferation of
fibroblasts. Fibroblasts play an important role not only in reepithelialization
but also in remodeling. Fibroblast derived keratinocyte growth factor-1 (KGF-1),
also known as fibroblast growth factor 7, accelerates wound contraction by
promoting TGF-
Nrf2, a member of the cap ‘n’ collar subfamily of basic region leucine zipper transcription factors [36], maintains the balance of redox in the body by regulating many genes, including but not limited to GSH, catalase (CAT), heme oxygenase 1 (HO1) and quinone oxidoreductase 1 (NQO1) [37, 38]. Research targeting Nrf2 shows great potential and application value in cancer [39], Alzheimer’s disease [40], cardiovascular disease [41] and DW [42] or chronic wound healing [43].
In a normal physiological environment, Nrf2 specifically binds to the
amino-terminal Neh2 domain to mediate the ubiquitination and degradation of Nrf2,
thus maintaining a low intracellular concentration [44]. When the body is in a
state of oxidative stress, the accumulation of ROS or electrophiles will weaken
the interaction between Nrf2 and Keap1, thus releasing Nrf2 and inhibiting Nrf2
ubiquitination, leading to the enhancement of Nrf2 nuclear translocation and the
formation of heterodimerizes with one of the small Maf proteins, and binding with
antioxidant response elements to activate the transcription of antioxidant
protein genes. Ultimately, it acts as an antioxidant and protects cells from
stress factors [45, 46]. Therefore, low levels of oxidative stress can be
regulated by Nrf2 to promote the recovery of redox homeostasis. However,
continuous excessive oxidative stress will lead to the imbalance of ROS, free
radicals, etc., and antioxidants in the body, which is one of the pathological
mechanisms that mediate the development of DFU. Under hyperglycemia, the
activation of Nrf2 is inhibited, and the expression of antioxidant genes
including NQO1 and HO1 are significantly down-regulated, which exacerbates the
occurrence and development of oxidative stress [37]. The study of Rajan
Teena et al. [47] using human clinical specimens showed that Nrf2
expression was significantly reduced in type 2 DM subjects and DFU subjects
compared with normal glucose tolerant subjects. Perilesional skin tissues from
patients with diabetes are often in a more severe state of oxidative stress.
Although the compensatory Nrf2 pathway is activated due to high oxidative stress,
such compensatory Nrf2 activation cannot restore the redox balance of the body
[42]. Activation impairment of Nrf2 not only aggravates oxidative stress, but
also causes abnormal inflammation of the wound surface [37]. Moreover, due to
severe oxidative damage to the skin tissue of diabetic patients, cell apoptosis
often occurs [42]. Silencing Nrf2 by siRNA not only increases cell apoptosis, but
also slows down the migration rate of HaCaT cells [42], and the Nrf2
transcription factor is also a novel target of KGF [48]. An Abnormal Nrf2 pathway
is not conducive to the smooth progression of wound proliferation and remodeling.
There is no doubt that targeted activation of Nrf2 is an effective way to
accelerate healing of DFU. The team of Min Li et al. [37] and Ying Li
et al. [49] confirmed this idea in streptozotocin-induced diabetic rat
wound models using dimethyl fumarate, an Nrf2 activator. In addition, Nrf2 also
promotes angiogenesis through multiple pathways, such as MALAT1/HIF-1
AGEs are a heterogeneous group of modified molecular species [52] that play a central role in oxidative stress. The accumulation of AGEs in vivo can be not only produced endogenously but also acquired by exogenously. For endogenous AGEs, the most classic is the Maillard reaction. The Maillard reaction is a complex network of amino acids and reducing sugars [53]. This non-enzymatic reaction can generate intermediate carbonyl precursors of AGEs, and glucose can also generate dicarbonyls through autoxidation, the polyol pathway and lipid peroxidation, which greatly contribute to the formation of AGEs [54]. Worldwide, the age-standardized prevalence of daily smoking was 25.0% for males and 5.4% for females [55]. Cigarette smoke promotes the production and activation of advanced glycation end products [56]. Food is also an important source of AGEs in the body. Approximately 10–30% of AGEs in food can be absorbed into the systemic circulation [54, 57]. AGEs/RAGE interactions can activate or strengthen numerous signaling pathways to enhance oxidative stress such as the Ras-mediated extracellular signal-regulated kinase (ERK1/2), stress-activated protein kinase/cJun N-terminal kinase (SAPK/JNK), mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK), and Janus kinase signal transducer and activator of transcription (JAK/STAT) pathways [54].
Under normal circumstances, there are only moderate amounts of AGEs in the body. However, for DFU patients, the continuous high glucose environment leads to the continuous accumulation of AGEs in the body [58, 59]. Moreover, many diabetic patients are obese, and the obese patients often acquire more exogenous AGEs orally [60]. The binding of AGEs to RAGE promotes the production of ROS and the inflammatory cascade by reinforcing oxidative stress. For example, excessive accumulation of AGEs decreased the migratory and adhesive functions of neutrophils [61], inhibited the influx of early macrophages, and disrupted the phagocytic function of M1 macrophages [62], which is not conducive to the formation of an early proinflammatory microenvironment on the wound surface. At the late stage of wound healing, accumulated AGEs promote overactivation of the NLRP3 inflammasome by generating ROS [63], which promotes the continued polarization of macrophages toward the M1 type. In addition, AGEs and RAGE binding can affect Ras homolog family member A/Rho kinase signaling to inhibit the anti-inflammatory function of exocytosis [64], putting the wound in a continuous stage of an inefficient inflammatory response. The adverse immune microenvironment prevented the wound from progressing to the stage of proliferation and remodeling from the stage of inflammation. In the proliferation phase, AGEs significantly inhibited HaCaT cells proliferation and migration by down-regulating the expression of miR-146a and upregulating the expression of an anchoring protein 12 (AKAP12) [65]. Moreover, excessive activation of the AGEs-RAGE pathway disrupts collagen I maturation and prevents its deposition in the ECM, which also further impairs DFU remodeling [66, 67]. In addition to these adverse consequences, unfortunately for patients with DFU, the accumulation of AGEs in tissues was independently correlated with vascular lesions that may lead to ischemic lesions in diabetic feet, leading to the adverse consequences of amputation [68, 69]. The accumulation of AGEs is also a risk factor for the development of diabetic neuropathy [70], which may cause the patient’s feet to lose protective pain sensation. Undoubtedly, vascular and neuropathy are an added hazard for an already difficult-to-heal DFU. More troubling is that AGEs induced the release of extracellular DNA (eDNA) by positively affecting sigB transcription and downregulating lrgA expression, thereby promoting the formation of S. aureus biofilms [71], which may aggravate DFU local infection. AGEs not only adversely affect the inflammatory, proliferative, and remodeling phases of DFU repair, but also codamage DFU by inducing or aggravating vasculopathy, neuropathy, and local infection. Targeting AGEs-RAGE pathways could be a good way to treat DFU.
Protein kinase C isozymes (PKCs), serine-threonine protein kinases, are widely
distributed in mammalian tissues and play a critical role in many physiological
functions such as regulating cell growth and proliferation, senescence, and
apoptosis [72, 73]. They are grouped into three categories according to their
domain composition: conventional PKCs (PKC
In the high-glucose environment of DFU, PKC is continuously activated [79].
Excessive activation of PKC aggravates the neutrophil respiratory burst and
releases a large number of NETs [80, 81]. Sushant Kumar Das et al. [82]
also confirmed that the expression of PKC
The polyol pathway includes a family of monomeric nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate (NADPH) dependent aldo-keto reductase enzymes that catalyze the conversion of carbonyl compounds to sugar alcohols [72]. Part of glucose can be converted into sorbitol via aldolase reductase (AR). Then sorbitol is slowly converted to fructose by sorbitol dehydrogenase hindering antioxidant activity [86]. This step uses NAD+ as a cofactor. Substrate-driven reactions mediated by NADPH and NAD+ play a significant role in maintaining the redox balance [87].
However, compared to nondiabetic wounds, higher levels of oxidative stress were present in the tissue of DFU [47]. The increased sorbitol pathway activity is one of the important mechanisms for the development of DFU [88]. AR is the rate-limiting enzyme for this reaction. Under normal conditions, AR has a very low affinity for glucose, and no more than 3% of glucose is processed through this pathway [89]. However, under the condition of continuous hyperglycemia, hexokinase is saturated, and then AR is continuously activated [90], which consumes NADPH and reduces the function of GSH reductase impairing antioxidant activity [86]. The accumulation of sorbitol may cause osmotic damage and lead to cell death. At present, there is no direct evidence that excessive accumulation of sorbitol in DFU tissue can aggravate the death of cells that are beneficial to wound healing such as endothelial cells. Further research is needed. However, the team of Bradley P Mudge [91] confirmed that the level of GSH in DFU was significantly lower than that in nondiabetic wounds. Treatment with local GSH accelerated the recovery of redox levels, which reduced wound tissue biofilm production, increased antibiotic sensitivity and ultimately promoted the healing of DFU [92]. What also bothers us is that the abnormal increase of AR in DFU may make DFU fall into a worse situation [93]. In addition, fructose was abnormally increased in DFU tissue. Excessive fructose is metabolized by fructokinase to produce overly acetyl-CoA, which increases protein acetylation and results in protein dysfunction [94, 95]. Fructose can generate AGEs [96], which are detrimental for the repair of DFU. Continuous abnormal oxidative stress in DFU increases the collagen I-to-collagen III ratio in collagen accumulation and lipid atrophy and may eventually lead to amputation in DFU patients [95]. Therefore, an abnormal polyol pathway may hinder the repair of DFU.
The hexosamine pathway (HP) is identical to the first two steps of glycolysis. The glycolytic intermediate fructose-6 phosphate is converted to glucosamine-6 phosphate under the action of glutamine-fructose-6-phosphate aminotransferase, the rate-limiting enzyme of HP [97]. Subsequent enzymatic steps then lead to acetylation and activation using UTP to produce the amino sugar UDP-N-acetylglucosamine (UDP-GlcNAc) [98]. UDP-GlcNAc is an important metabolic compound for the formation of glycosyl chains of proteins and lipids [99]. Moreover, under the action of Oglycosyltransferase (OGT), UDP-GLcNAC can modify the protein o-GlcNAC [100]. The HP is composed of a series of anabolic reactions [98] and plays an important role in the pathophysiology of diabetes complications [101, 102, 103].
Under normal blood glucose levels, only 2–5% of fructose 6-phosphate enters
the HP [104]. However, in diabetic patients, excess fructose-6-phosphate is
shunted into the HP. The increase in HP flux leads to an increase in UDP-GlcNAC
levels, which in turn increases the flux through OGT, leading to an increase in
O-GlcNAc levels [99, 105]. O-GlcNAc modification is a posttranslational
modification that can regulate inflammatory response by targeting the
NF-
As a classical signaling pathway, Nrf2 is the “master regulator” of the
antioxidant response [118]. Natural biologics have long been a resource for new
drug discovery due to their low toxicity and wide range of sources [119]. In
cancer and antibiotic drug development, natural biologics reportedly account for
53% and 59% of all FDA-approved drugs, respectively [120]. Without exception
natural biologics are also important sources of Nrf2 agonists [120]. Targeted
activation of Nrf2 can drive the balance of redox
homeostasis in the body and
ultimately promote DFU repair. We identified some natural biologics targeting
Nrf2 to promote DFU healing. Here, we briefly list a few natural biologics and
describe how the targeted activation of Nrf2 can promote the repair of DFU.
Neferine (Nef), a bisbenzylisoquinoline alkaloid obtained from the seed embryos
of Nelumbo nucifera, has various pharmacological effects such as anti-oxidative,
anti-inflammatory, anti-arrhythmic and anti-thrombotic. In addition, it can
increase the sensitivity of chemotherapy drugs, such as paclitaxel, cisplatin and
doxorubicin [121, 122, 123]. Juan Li et al. [124] showed that Nef can improve
insulin sensitivity, which significantly reduced blood glucose levels. Local
application of Nef in diabetic rat wounds can activate the Nrf2 signaling
pathway, reduce Keap1 expression, increase the expression of downstream factors
antioxidant enzymes such as superoxide dismutase (SOD), glutathione peroxidase
(GPx) and glutathione reductase (GR), and increase the expression of collagen-1,
TGF-
Targeted Pathways | Natural Biologics | Mechanism | Human/Animal/Cell | Wound | Intervention Dose | Administration route | Administration frequency | Findings/ Outcomes | References |
Nrf2 pathways | neferine | Activated Nrf-2 pathways | Streptozotocin induced diabetic male rats | Excision wound model (wound diameter is 10 mm) | 10% and 20% | Topically applied | Once a day for 14 days | DW healing is accelerated | [124] |
resveratrol | Activated Nrf-2 pathways | HUVECs and Streptozotocininduced diabetic male rats | Excision wound model (wound diameter is 10 mm) | 100 nM (HUVECs), 100 mg/mL (diabetic rat) | Co-incubation (HUVECs), Topically applied (diabetic rat) | / (HUVECs), once a day for 10 days (diabetic rats) | Attenuated oxidative stress-induced impairment of HUVECs proliferation and migration and eventually accelerated DW healing | [125] | |
procyanidin B2 | Activated Nrf-2 pathways | Endothelial progenitor cell (EPC) and streptozotocin induced diabetic mice | Excision wound model (wound diameter is 8 mm) | 2.5 |
Co-incubation (EPC), Intraperitoneal injection (diabetic mice) | / (EPC), once a day for 10 days (diabetic mice) | Improved endothelial progenitor cell function and accelerated wound healing, increases angiogenesis in diabetic mice | [126] | |
rutin | Activated Nrf-2 pathways | Streptozotocin induced diabetic rats | Excision wound model (wound diameter is 15 mm) | 100 mg/kg | Intraperitoneal injection | Once a day for 21 days | Reduceoxidative stress and inflammatory response, promoting DW healing | [127] | |
Paeoniflorin | Activated Nrf-2 pathways | Human immortalized keratinocyte (HaCaT) cells and streptozotocin-induced diabetic rats | Excision wound model (wound diameter is 6 mm) | 100 |
co-incubation (HaCaT), intragastric administration (diabetic rats) | / (HaCaT), once a day for 16 days (diabetic mice) | Increased cell proliferation and migration and accelerated wound healing in diabetic rats | [30] | |
Xanthohumol | Activated Nrf-2 pathways | HaCaT, HUVECs and Streptozotocin induced diabetic rats | Excision wound model (wound diameter is 2 mm) | 2.5 and 5 |
Co-incubation (HaCaT, HUVECs), Intraperitoneal injection (diabetic mice) | Once a day for 10 days (diabetic rats) | Alleviated oxidative stress-induced cell damage and accelerated DW healing in STZ-induced diabetic rats | [128] | |
mangiferin | Increase Nrf2 level | Streptozotocin-nicotinamide-induced type-2 diabetic male rats | / | 1% and 2% mangiferin gel | Topically applied | For 21 days | DW healing is accelerated | [129] | |
Betulinic acid | Activated Nrf-2 pathways | Human primary aorta smooth muscle cells (HASMCs), HUVECs,Streptozotocin induced diabetic rats | The rat’s back was placed in a hot copper column (2 cm in diameter) at 75 °C for 15 s to obtain the burn model | 15 |
Intraperitoneal (IP) and Topically applied | Every three days for 4 weeks starting from 1 week before the introduction of burn injury (IP), each day continuously for 3 weeks starting from the second day after the introduction of burn injury (Topically applied) | Diabetic wounds healing is accelerated | [130] | |
Luteolin | Inactivation of NF-κB and upregulation of Nrf2 | Streptozotocin induced diabetic male rats | Excision wound model (wound diameter is 15 mm) | 100 mg/kg | Intraperitoneal injection | Once a day for 14 days | DW healing is accelerated | [131] | |
Bee venom | Activated Nrf-2 pathways | Streptozotocin induced diabetic male mice | Excision wound model (wound diameter is 8 mm) | 200 |
Subcutaneously injected | Once a day for 15 days | DW healing is accelerated | [132] | |
AGEs-RAGE Pathways | pyridoxamine (PM) | Reduced the accumulation of AGEs, promoted the influx of macrophAGEs in the early stage of tissue repair | Human monocytic THP‐1 cell (THP-1), Male db/db T2DM mice | Excision wound model (wound diameter is 6 mm) | 100 |
Co-incubation, Topically applied, then wound was covered with a transparent dressing (3M, 1624W) | Once a day until day 10 post‐injury | DW healing is accelerated | [62] |
Centella Cordifolia | Inhibited the expression of AGEs and improved antioxidant capacity | The human vascular endothelial cell line (EAhy926), The mouse embryonic fibroblasts (NIH3t3) cell, The human keratinocytes cell line (HaCat) | / | EAhy926:2 mM; NIH3t3: 500 µg/mL; HaCat: 500 µg/mL | Co-incubation | / | Restored the spreading and attachment of endothelial, fibroblast and keratinocyte cells over the glycated ECM | [133] | |
Shixiang Plaster | Inhibited the expression of RAGE and AGEs, Promoted angiogenesis and granulation tissue formation | Streptozotocin induced diabetic Sprague-Dawley rats | Excision wound model (wound diameter is 5 mm) | / (pastes) | Topical application at a thickness of 2 mm over the wound | Once a day | DW healing is accelerated | [134] | |
Momordica Charantia | Blocked RAGE, induced ERK1/2 phosphorylation and tube formation to promote angiogenesis | bovine aortic endothelial cells (BAEC) | / | 10, 50 or 75 |
Co-incubation for 72 hours | / | promoted angiogenesis | [135] | |
Salvianolic acid A (SalA) | Decreased AGEs levels, vascular eNOS expression, and blood glucose, lipid, vWF and malondialdehyde levels | streptozotocin -induced type 2 diabetic rats | / | 1 and 3 mg/kg | Per os (p.o) for for 10 weeks | Once a day | Improved diabetic plantar microcirculation and peripheral nerve function | [136] | |
PKC Pathways | Curcumin | Inhibited PKC- |
streptozotocin-induced type I diabetic rats | / | 100 mg/kg | p.o. for 8 weeks | Once a day | Diabetic nephropathy is attenuated | [137] |
Pueraria tuberosa extract | Downregulated the PKC- |
streptozotocin-induced diabetic nephropathy rats | / | 100 mg/100 g and 50 mg/100 g | p.o for 20 days | / | Inhibited the abnormal inflammatory response in diabetic nephropathy | [138] | |
sasa borealis water-extract | Inhibiting the activation of PKC |
HUVEC | / | 1 and 10 |
Co-incubation | / | Blocked chronic high glucose-induced endothelial apoptos | [139] | |
Verbascoside | Inhibiting PKC/HMGB1/RAGE/NFκB signaling | Smulow-Glickman (S-G) gingival epithelial cell line | / | 25, 50 and 100 |
Co-incubation for 24 hours | / | Mitigated the Suppressed Cell Proliferation and Wound Healing Capacity of Gingival Epithelial Cells under High Glucose Condition | [140] | |
Polyol Pathways | chlorogenic acid | Enhanced hydroxyproline content, decreased malondialdehyde/nitric oxide levels, elevated reduced-glutathione | streptozotocin-induced diabetic rats | Excision wound model (wound diameter is 15 mm) | 50 mg/kg | Intraperitoneal injection | Once a day | DW healing is accelerated | [141] |
AgNPs | Increased GSH peroxidase activity and GSH content | streptozotocin-induced diabetic rats | Incision wound model (straight incisions of 8 cm Length on both sides of the vertebraland closed with interrupted sutures 1 cm apart) | 10, 30 |
Topically applied | Once a day for 21 days | DW healing is accelerated | [142] | |
propolis | Increased the GSH and GSH/ GSSG ratio, depleted TNF- |
Diabetic patients with foot wounds | / | Propolis (Beepolis®) used was 3% in propylene glycol preparation manufactured | Topically applied (Propolis spray was applied to cover the wound surface in each dressing from week 0 until cicatrization or 8 weeks as a maximum, whichever occurred first.) | / | There was a decrease in the wound area by an average of 4 cm |
[143] | |
polyphenolic fraction | Inhibited aldose reductase activity as well as their expression in diabetic animals | Diabetic peripheral neuropathy was induced by streptozotocin and maintained | / | 100, 200 mg/kg | p.o for 30 days | / | Ameliorated diabetic peripheral neuropathy | [144] | |
Hexosamine Pathways | APE | Increased hexosamine levels | Streptozotocin-induced type 2 diabetic Sprague-Dawley rats | Excision wound model (wound diameter is 8 mm) | 100, 200 and 400 mg/kg (p.o), 5, 10 and 20% APE cream (topically applied) | p.o for 7 days and topically applied for 28 days | p.o (once a day) topically applied (twice a day, approximately 1 mm thick) | DW healing is accelerated and neuropathy is ameliorated | [145] |
ethanolic extract of Melia dubia | Improved total collagen and hexosamine | Female Wistar rats | Excision wound model (wound diameter is 2 cm) and Incision wound model (para-vertebral straight incisions of 6 cm Length and closed with interrupted sutures 1 cm apart) | 40 mg/kg b. wt, 200 |
Topically applied | Once a day until the wounds heal completely | DW healing is accelerated | [146] | |
Solanum xanthocarpum | Increased hexosamine levels | streptozotocin-induced diabetic rats | Excision wound model (wound diameter is 10 mm) | 10% gel (topically applied) and 200 mg/kg (p.o) | Topically applied and orally | once a day for 14 days | DW healing is accelerated | [147] | |
embelin | Increased the level of hexosamine | Streptozotocin-induced diabetic rats | Excision wound model (wound diameter is 2 cm) and Incision Incision wound model (para-vertebral straight incisions of 5 cm Length and closed with interrupted sutures 1 cm apart) | 5% embelincream(topically applied), 25 and 50 mg/kg (p.o) | Topically applied and p.o | Once a day | Wound contraction was significantly increased and epithelialization was promoted;Diabetic wounds healing is accelerated | [148] | |
Withania coagulans | Decreased level of hexosamine | Streptozotocin-induced diabetic rats | Excision wound | 10% w/w cream (Topically applied), 500 mg/kg (p.o.) | Topically applied and p.o. | Once a day for 16 days | DW healing is accelerated | [149] |
AGEs-RAGE pathways is a key factor in maintaining the body’s redox balance. Abnormal activation of AGEs-RAGE signaling leads to damage to DFU in all stages. Vascular, neuropathy and local infections also cause patients with DFU to face the threat of amputation or death. Targeting the AGEs-RAGE signaling axis can inhibit abnormal inflammatory responses by regulating the NF-kB/NLRP3 [150], RAGE/RhoA/ROCK signaling pathway [151] or immune cells [64] to normalize the immune microenvironment. Previous studies have reported that topical application of pyridoxamine, a natural vitamin B6 analog, reduced the accumulation of AGEs in the wound tissue of diabetic mice, promoted the influx of macrophages in the early stage of tissue repair, improved the dysfunctional inflammatory response, and accelerated wound healing [62]. Moreover, targeting AGEs-RAGE signaling pathways can also be beneficial in the proliferation and remodeling stages of wound healing such as Centella cordifolia and Shixiang Plaster. Centella cordifolia reversed collagen migratory defects and restored the spreading and attachment of fibroblasts, endothelial cells and keratinocytes over the glycated ECM [133]. Ji Fei et al. [134] also used Shixiang Plaster, a traditional Chinese medicine, to promote the reepithelialization of DW by reducing the expression of AGEs and RAGE. In addition, as mentioned above, the accumulation of AGEs in vivo is inseparable from exogenous acquisition. Diets with a low AGEs content have effectively improved insulin sensitivity and reduced insulin resistance and cholesterol levels, which are beneficial for DFU repair [152]. There is no doubt that targeting AGEs/RAGE has great potential for the healing of DFU. Natural biologics targeting AGEs/RAGE can also prevent the further deterioration of DFU by regulating angiogenesis or neuropathy. For instance, the extracts of Momordica charantia (MC) induce ERK1/2 phosphorylation and tube formation through the AGEs-RAGE pathway, promoting angiogenesis [135], which may improve diabetic foot microcirculation and prevent diabetic foot ischemic lesions. In addition, salvianolic acid A (SalA), the main efficacious, water-soluble component of miltiorrhiza bunge, also improved peripheral blood perfusion, vasodilation responsiveness and peripheral nerve function by targeting AGEs, which to some extent hindered the development or deterioration of DFU [136]. These research results showed that natural biologics, in addition to their own advantages such as low toxicity and wide sources, were also efficacious for DFU. However, the combination of these natural biologics, which play different roles in different stages of wound healing, may be better for seeking the optimal prescription. Moreover, the current research on the mechanism of natural medicines and diseases mostly focuses on the indirect mechanisms, and the research on the direct mechanisms is not deep enough. This may give us the illusion that natural medicines are less effective. Therefore, an in-depth understanding the exact target of DFU, using high-throughput screening technology to efficiently and accurately screen natural biologics targeting AGEs-RAGE pathways, and using combination therapy may be an important direction to promote DFU repair.
Abnormal activation of PKC is an important pathological mechanism for the
occurrence and development of diabetes and its complications. Ruboxistaurin
successfully reversed endothelial progenitor cell dysfunction and prevented the
excessive formation of NETs by targeting PKC
There is no doubt that an abnormal polyol signaling pathway plays a harmful role
in DFU repair. Normalizing the polyol signaling pathway may have unexpected
benefits for the repair of DFU. As mentioned above, an abnormal polyol signaling
pathway will reduce the function of GSH reductase and damage the antioxidant
capacity [86]. AgNPs, produced by a unicellular spherical cyanobacterium with
photo- and hetero-trophic capabilities, also accelerate DW repair by intensifying
GSH peroxidase activities and GSH content [142]. In addition to its high
antioxidant capacity, GSH can help to normalize the immune microenvironment
[156]. Of course, due to the low toxicity and side effects of natural biologics,
they are easy to clinically convert. For example, in a clinical trial, topical
application of propolis to DFU also accelerated wound repair by increasing the
the GSH and GSH/glutathione disulfide (GSSG) ratio [143]. Moreover, Deniz Bagdas
[141] confirmed that systemic antioxidant therapy with chlorogenic acid,
a dietary antioxidant, can ultimately promote DW healing by increasing reduced
GSH. Dietary care, an important auxiliary strategy to maintain the body’s blood
glucose and redox balance [157, 158, 159], combined with other treatment strategies
may result in better outcomes. Because oxidative stress may impair wound healing
through neuropathy and lead to loss of protective sensation for patients with
chronic DFU, drugs that target polyol pathways in natural biologics to reverse
neuropathy are also being sought. Suman Samaddar and Raju Koneri [144] confirmed
that the polyphenolic fraction, isolated from Symphyocladia latiuscula, can
inhibit aldose reductase activity and expression, thereby improving peripheral
neuropathy. Therefore, it can be inferred that targeting the polyol pathway may
be an effective auxiliary strategy for promoting DFU healing. However, although
there are many natural biologics targeting the polyol signaling pathway
[160, 161], there are few studies on the application of DFU, and more relevant
studies are focused on diabetic retinopathy. For example, total lignans from
Fructuse Arctii improve diabetic retinopathy by inhibiting aldose reductase
[162]. Moreover, resveratrol (3,4
As mentioned above, for diabetic patients, the increase in hexosamine flux in the body leads to an increase in the flux through OGT, which in turn increases the level of O-GlcNAc [99, 105]. Lowering protein O-GlcNAc expression reverses delayed wound closure caused by hyperglycemia [117]. However, studies on natural biologics targeting O-GlcNAc to promote DFU healing are lacking. Interestingly, it was reported that the hexosamine of DW tissue decreased compared with the normal control group in streptozotocin-induced diabetic rats [146]. Topical application of apple peel extract (APE) significantly increased hydroxyproline and hexosamine levels, thereby enhancing the DW healing process [145]. The application of natural biologics, such as ethanolic extracts of Melia dubia [146] and Solanum xanthocarpum [147] (more examples are shown in the Table 1), during the wound repair in diabetic rats promotes the deposition of hexosamine, which eventually accelerates the wound repair. Theoretically, increased activation of the HP leads to an increase in its downstream product, O-GlcNAc, which impairs wound repair. This is contrary to the results of increased HP flux in diabetic patients. One important reason may be caused by the different model construction and detection methods. Clinical diabetes is often divided into type I and type II. Type I diabetes is mainly caused by immune-mediated destruction of pancreatic beta cells, and patients with type II diabetes face both insulin resistance and relative insulin deficiency. The pathogenesis of type I and type II diabetes is different, and the method of constructing animal models is also different. It is critical to construct and select a full-thickness injury model of diabetic rat skin specifically. Moreover, direct evidence for changes in HP flux in DFU is lacking. There may be other regulatory mechanisms of HP in DFU. Therefore, in order to better study clinical DFU, it is necessary to collect clinical specimens, use emerging technologies to seek direct evidence, and conduct an indepth study of the specific mechanisms of the onset and difficult healing of DW.
These studies have shown that continuous exposure to hyperglycemia leads to abnormalities in the Nrf2 signaling pathway and AGEs-RAGE, PKC, polyol and hexosamine biochemical pathways, which results in excessive oxidative stress and an imbalance of redox levels in the body. Excessive oxidative stress on the wound will trigger the release of proinflammatory mediators and trigger an inflammatory cascade, which will cause DFU to be in a stage of persistent low-efficiency inflammatory response state and impair the proliferation and remodeling stages of wound repair. These factors are the bases for the onset, progression, and deterioration of DFU and therapies targeting these pathways have been shown to be effective in promoting the healing of DFU (Fig. 1). This review not only describes the pathology and key mechanisms of oxidative stress in DFU, natural biologics targeting Nrf2 signaling pathway and AGEs-RAGE, PKC, polyol and hexosamine biochemical pathways promoting the healing of DFU are also summarized. Some of these natural biologics have been tested in DW models with promising results. They show the therapeutic potential of antioxidation and anti-inflammatory, promoting proliferation and remodeling, and some natural biologics can also promote wound angiogenesis and improve peripheral neuropathy.
The potential therapy of natural biologics for DFU. Oxidative damage plays an important role in the pathology of DFU, including leading to arrest DFU healing in the inflammatory stage, which then impairs wound proliferation and remodeling. Nrf2 signaling Pathway and AGEs-RAGE, PKC, Polyol and Hexosamine biochemical pathways are key regulatory targets in DFU. The treatment of natural biologics with antioxidant properties, targeting these signaling pathways and biochemical pathways, can effectively improve the inefficient inflammatory response of DFU, promote the smooth progress of wound proliferation and remodeling, and finally promote the healing of DFU.
However, targeted natural biologics promoting DFU are more focused on the Nrf2, AGEs-RAGE and HP, while direct studies on the other pathways are currently a shortcoming, but there are many studies on other complications of diabetes (similar to the pathogenesis of DFU). It should also be noted that the specific mechanism of the HP in promoting DW repair is still unclear. Filling in the research gap is bound to happen. Furthermore, due to heterogeneity in animal selection, model construction, blood glucose levels, dosing start, end time, route of administration, frequency of administration, we were unable to identify which natural biologics show better efficacy in the treatment of DFU. The bioavailability, stability and solubility of these natural biologics in vivo need further confirmation. In addition, hyperglycemia is closely related to oxidative stress. Hyperglycemia can upregulate markers of chronic inflammation and contribute to increased ROS generation, which ultimately cause pathological oxidative stress. Conversely, pathological oxidative stress can lead to insulin resistance and impaired insulin secretion [165]. Proper treatment of hyperglycemia and inhibition of pathological oxidative stress are crucial for the healing of DFU. On the basis of proper control of hyperglycemia (including dietary care [166]), the application of natural biologics may achieve better curative effect. And in the study of DFU, it is important not only to focus on the effect of natural biologics on DFU healing, but also consider whether they have an effect on blood glucose level. Of course, many synthetic compounds have been produced as antidiabetic agents [167], and it is also an important direction to search for drugs that can promote DFU healing from these antidiabetic agents. Metformin [168] and insulin [169] are good examples. Moreover, seeking high-efficiency drug delivery systems (such as bioactive nanoparticle delivery systems) and combination therapy of multiple pathways (rather than targeting one pathway alone) are better options for promoting the repair of DFU. However, greater thought, investigation, and verification are still required for both drug selection (based on targets such as signaling networks or metabolic pathways or on different stages of wound healing) and the order of administration. However, it is certain that natural biologics have a wide range of sources and excellent cost effectiveness, which can reduce the economic burden of DFU patients to a certain extent. Therefore, it is crucial to devise strategies to study the effects of these natural biologics on patients with DFU, ethically, without compromising patient interests and obtaining informed consent.
DFU, diabetic foot ulcers; Nrf2, nuclear factor erythroid 2-related factor;
AGEs, advanced glycated end products; RAGEs, receptor For Advanced Glycation
Endproducts; PKC, protein kinase C; DM, diabetes mellitus ; ROS, reactive oxygen
species; NETs, neutrophils extracellular traps; DW, diabetic wounds; VEGF,
endothelial growth factor; TGF-
QC, JS and AL conceptualized this study and wrote the manuscript. BL and WH created the figures and tables. ZJ, XB, LH and SZ contributed to the literature search and provided help and advice on grammar. SG, JW and QC reviewed and modified the manuscript. All authors contributed to editorial changes in the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Not applicable.
We thank Jianhua Wu, Department of Endocrinology and Metabolism, the Affiliated Hospital of Southwest Medical University for deep learning of DFU.
This work was supported by Grants from the joint project of the Luzhou Municipal Government and Southwest Medical University (Grant No. 2020LZXNYDJ30), Doctoral Research Initiation Fund of Affiliated Hospital of Southwest Medical University (Grant No. 20009), Scientific research project of Southwest Medical University (Grant Nos. 2020ZRQNA014 and 2020ZSQN004), Sichuan Medical Association (Grant No. Q21021), Nursing association of Sichuan province (Grant No. H21013), Cadre Health of Sichuan province (Grant Nos. 2021-1502), Sichuan Clinical Medical Research Center for Kidney Diseases 2020 open project (2019YFS0537-11).
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Publisher’s Note: IMR Press stays neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.